Skip to main content
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals reviews & trust report

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals specializes in providing a diverse selection of vacation rental properties along the Gulf Shores and Orange Beach areas. The company offers a range of accommodations, including condos and beach houses, catering to families, couples, and groups seeking a memorable getaway. With an extensive portfolio of properties, Brett/Robinson aims to meet the varying needs of vacationers looking for beachfront access, modern amenities, and a comfortable stay. The company’s website, www.brett-robinson.com, features an easy-to-navigate platform where customers can browse available rentals, check rates, and make reservations. Targeting individuals and families interested in vacationing in Alabama's coastal regions, Brett/Robinson provides essential information to help guests plan their ideal vacation experience.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals has a positive customer experience.

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals receives a mix of feedback from customers, with a notable portion expressing dissatisfaction. Many reviewers appreciate the quality of the condos, highlighting comfortable beds and well-maintained units, particularly at locations like Phoenix IX.

Read full summary

However, numerous complaints arise regarding cleanliness and maintenance issues, with reports of mold infestations, bed bugs, and dirty linens in various units. Customers also voice frustration over poor customer service, including long wait times for check-in and unresponsive staff. While some guests commend individual team members for their assistance, the overall sentiment reflects significant concerns about the condition of the properties and the company's handling of issues. Consequently, the prevailing sentiment leans towards the negative.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.0/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 62% happy · 21% unhappy

Best for

  • Friendly staff
  • Helpful support
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Pricing
  • Defective product
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.0
100%
4.0 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
2.0
12-month avg
1.3
All-time
4.0
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Aug 24SepOctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.0Aug 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsOct 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsJun 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewJul 25: 3.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Aug 241.02
Sep 24—0
Oct 241.02
Nov 24—0
Dec 24—0
Jan 25—0
Feb 25—0
Mar 25—0
Apr 25—0
May 25—0
Jun 251.01
Jul 253.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 308 positive reviews

  • Friendly staff17%
    52 mentions
  • Helpful support16%
    50 mentions
  • Easy to use10%
    30 mentions
  • Customer service7%
    22 mentions
“The staff here are very friendly and helpful and the premises are immaculate”
On “Friendly staff” · Sep 14, 2020

Top complaintsof 106 negative reviews

  • Payment issues21%
    22 mentions
  • Pricing11%
    12 mentions
  • Defective product10%
    11 mentions
  • Customer service9%
    10 mentions
“I am staying at Phoenix I, and someone threw a white powdery water mix on one side of my black car”
On “Payment issues” · Oct 28, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals is #5 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Alfa Travel scores higher (4.6 vs 2.9).

Reviews

500 reviews of Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals. Filter by what matters to you.

4.0ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Melissa Owens

This place is a joke

This place is a joke. The only reason I’ve gave it one star is because that’s the only way I could write the review. My daughters and I have reservations for July 6,2022 my girls grandmother has took a turn for the worst and dying. I just called to see if we could have our money back or even just reschedule the vacation for a later date and was no it’s against policy and just like I told the lady we spoke with if your grandmother was dying would you continue with your vacation? The only thing she would say was I’m sorry that’s the policy. I guess that’s why the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE NOR WILL I EVER EVER DEAL WITH THIS PLACE AGAIN!!! Melissa Owens Rutledge Tennessee

Report
Lisa Mountcasel

Stay somewhere else!

We were first time visitors to Gulf Shores. We rented from Brett Robinson on a recommendation from someone who had visited before. Never again!!! The condo was subpar. The sofa was nasty and looked like it had been pulled out of a dumpster. The worst was the day before we were supposed to leave I woke up covered in a rash and bites. Pulled back the mattress cover. Yup bedbugs. Left a day early. Called and notified them. They called me back to say the pest company checked and no bedbugs. Right… like they’re going to admit they found them? Do you yourself a favor and stay somewhere else.

Report
Connie Thompson

Phoenix I very old and out dated

We have been coming to Orange beach and staying at the Phoenix for years, this year we stayed at Phoenix I and it was the worse we have ever had. The place was not clean, the floors were dirty. Phoenix I is so old and out dated to compared to the other ones we have stayed at. The owners need to get together on having this building and facility updated. Paying for parking in your own location?? What is happening to Orange Beach/Gulf Shores you guys are starting to get so picky like a big city.

Report
Eduard Morgan

We booked a condo for 4 nights ( #904 @…

We booked a condo for 4 nights ( #904 @ Phoenix East). According to the website, check in is after 3pm during our dates. So we arrive at 2:30, hoping for an early check in seeing that we have 2 small children and it is nap time. No luck, was told they might get to it in the next hour or so. So here we are, sitting in the car waiting until they decide to call. Apparently we were supposed to have been notified by email that they are experiencing high volumes and a later check in can be expected, but never received such. So what recourse do you have, you ask. Nothing, but talk to the front desk (says BR reservations). They might knock of the cleaning fee or something. Yes its fall break, but the parking area is not even half full, where are the "large numbers" they are talking about?

Report
Melissa Pitts

Phoenix VII 708 very very disappointed

Phoenix VII 708 very very disappointed. First very outdated, second faucet in master bathroom about to fall off, third stove light came on and off without anyone doing it, fourth shower curtain had mold, fifth bathroom had light burned out, sixth door that should have been locked was not and kept blowing open when trying to leave, seventh the dryer took forever to dry even after emptying vent, I could go on!! We have been coming here for the past few years and it’s not getting any better. The final straw three nights in a row the smell of marijuana!!! We had little kids and could not even sit on the balcony and enjoy the evening. This is a smoke free environment how can you allow this!! Additionally two elevators down and wait time ridiculous! Brett take some time to update units and not allow visitors or residents to smoke! I will not refer anyone in the future to your properties!

Report
..............

Concerning Unit 310 I do have several…

Concerning Unit 310 I do have several complaints (And really I am not a complainer) But after a long enjoy full day at the beach we had to come back to the condo with the drain in the 2nd bedroom bath tub and sink not draining correctly and the washer and dryer not working. We had 10 dirty beach towels along with all of our bath towels and cloths that can't be washed and dried. I specifically asked if there was a washer and dryer with the intention of them working. I reported it to the front desk and the desk clerk was very nice and made a note of it. We were told later in the day that the wash and dryer would have to be pulled out and worked on and it probably would not be this weekend. WE were also informed that you all along with the owner Knew the Dryer was not working and still you rented this unit out. SHAME ON YOU and I am not at all satisfied. I am writing this complaint to you with intention on something getting done for the next tenant. It has made our trip very inconvenient and I will definitely not recommend this location. Also, it seems like you could supply the unit with a broom and a mop so that it can be kept up while being occupied.

Report
Kara
Kara
1 review

Find another property other than Phoenix V

First time visiting Gulf Shores in 13 years and Phoenix property. Disappointment with Phoenix V Unit 711 is an understatement. This building is completely run down. Elevator wait time is no less than 20 minutes. Good luck to get on one that works! On to unit 711-the unit was filthy and in need of renovation work. Problem #1-the sofa was dirty and sofa bed contained a dirty mattress pad. When I removed the cushions, every type of food particle fell onto the bed. Problem #2-the dishes in the cabinet were DIRTY. They contained greasy finger prints and remaining traces of food. The same for the utensils and pans. Problem #3-the door handle broke and would not allow the door to properly close OR lock. Problem #4-the dishwasher would not close or lock, which means you can't get it to come on to cycle through the wash. I was able to get it to power on by HOLDING the door shut and then water spilled over the top as it washed through the cycle. Yes, all of these things were reported to the desk attendant and someone was sent to try to remedy the problem. However, the point of this review is this is a vacation. You are supposed to enjoy the time spent away from home. This was anything but enjoyable staying at this property and unit. Here's a suggestion-take some of the money made from people on this horrible unit and renovate it a bit. In my opinion, if you want a nice vacation, go elsewhere!

Report
Margaret Rhodes

I was very disappointed with Phoenix…

I was very disappointed with Phoenix West All Suites- Thursday-Monday-pool was always closed- said closed for maintenance but when you questioned they always said due to lightning- while every other pool inthe area was open they still remained closed until everyone complained- one elevator was always broken- hard to stay on the 9th floor with only one elevator working. Sad that you spend over $3000.00 for a family vacation and have hardly any pool access for your family

Report
Pam Peery Hodges

My family recently stayed at Phoenix…

My family recently stayed at Phoenix West II, unit 1409 and I have to say that I cannot recommend staying at this unit. The unit was decorated nicely, however, the furniture is worn out. When sitting, you sink all the way down to the frame. The mattresses in the guest rooms are worn out. The bedroom with the 2 queen beds was the worst. One bed was so bad it felt as if the mattress was broken. I did mention it to the front desk and they sent maintenance up to "fix" it. He did make an adjustment to the frame, but that was not the problem. Considering the price you pay to stay, you should not be faced with worn out furniture and bedding. I give this unit a 0 rating!!!

Report
Janet Watson
Janet Watson
1 review

I will never use Brett Robinson again

I’ve used Brett Robinson rentals for 30 years and always had a great experience. This time I stayed in Pheonix V. I was informed they have a new HOA and parking was not included in the price for rental. I rented a three bedroom and had to pay my own parking .. meaning I had to pay $105 extra dollars for three parking spaces. The inside and outside needs better cleaning and maintenance. I was told pheonix V is the only condo under this new management but this will be the last time I will use Brett Robinson.

Report
Cody Robertson

Most horrible places to stay in Gulf Shores.

Came to stay for a weekend and to propose to my woman which was the only good part about our stay. The staffing is like a bunch of poorly trained rental cops that don't even know their own rules. It say's once you arrive you will receive a parking pass 1 for a 8 sleeper and 2 for 11 sleeper. When you get there you do not receive one nor do you even know where the office is located. Which is located on the back side of the islands wind east building. Before knowing this the rental cop wrote a ticket for not having the parking pass. Went to get it and they made us pay 30$ for the initial pass that was supposed to be free. The ticket will not be paid. Then the second day there I'm out on the balcony with the door closed and get threatened a fine if I smoke. I then had a overlook of the rules and guidelines of the paper on the fridge. It clearly say's no smoking allowed inside of the properties, "if smoking make sure to close the balcony door" so that no signs of smoke are inside the premises. The last day we checked out and went shopping for souvenirs. Only a hour had passed and my fiance realized she had left her makeup box underneath the bathroom sink. Easily over 200$ worth value, so we went straight to the office and talked with the rudest staff. Mrs. Piggy tells us that we could either wait until 5-6p.m for it to be put in the lost and found, or we could pay to have it shipped home which is a 4 and a half hour drive. She refused to get some much needed exercise by walking us back to the room, to be the generous/right thing to do and retrieve our belongings for us. Instead I had to go back and go inside myself to get our own belongings back. Pretty sure Mrs.Piggy had intentions on getting free makeup. This will be a place checked off on for never staying again.

Report
C. White
C. White
1 review

BR dropped the ball this time

First of all we have rented from BR for almost 13yrs. We have always been offered promo codes or coupons. Well not this time. They charged everybody 100% rental, and booked the whole building at 100% capacity. Phoenix West is entirely too big of a building to only have 4 elevators. To make things worse, only 3 are working and made wait times for elevators up to 30 min. This is a joke. Hot tubs were repeatedly shut down for “maintenance”. As soon as we arrived we had to call for a cleaning crew to come back and clean up food from the tables and mop floors from the mess that was left from previous visitors. There isn’t enough chairs at the pool for 100% occupants. Overall this trip has been more of an inconvenience than a vacation. We won’t be back here and most likely won’t rent from BR again. $5500+ for a weeks stay doesn’t set well with me right now when obviously BR wasn’t prepared for the number of people here. This is June. Not January. They should’ve been prepared to accommodate the crowd that they knew was coming. Should’ve offered something for the inconveniences that we had to face.

Report
William & Freda

Not a happy visit!

My husband and I celebrated our 29th anniversary earlier this month, and were thrilled to be able to return to Orange Beach! We missed it so much last year! We stayed at the Phoenix VI, and I’m sorry to say that the condo left much to be desired! The location was great, views from the condo were beautiful, it was peaceful, and the parking was very handy. With that being said, the negatives far out-weighed the positives! The condo was simply dirty! The floors were filthy, cabinets and drawers in the kitchen had food crumbs and pieces left over from previous guests, apparently more than a few visits! We put silverware, coffee cups, etc into the dishwasher to clean them, and did not put them back in the drawers & cabinets, because I didn’t want to clean those on our vacation! We bought plastic cups and paper plates to use instead of using those in the condo. The coffee maker and toaster had residue & crumbs from previous uses. There were extra blankets on the closet shelves, but when we got them out to use, there was an odor and it appeared they had not been washed after the last visitors used them. I wore white footies to keep from walking barefoot on the floors, and after just an hour of walking around in the condo, the bottoms were filthy - I have a picture of those! The next day I bought a pair of flip-flops to wear in the condo only (nowhere else) and before I could put them in my closet at home, I had to scrape the bottoms and then scrub them. Have pictures of the crap that came off of the bottoms! We are long-time customers of Brett Robinson, having preferred to stay in the Phoenix condos through the years. The last time we stayed in a Phoenix condo, which was in 2019, the cleanliness of the unit left a little to be desired, but we really thought it was a fluke occurrence. However, based upon our experience this time, we will most likely choose someplace else! Very disappointed!!

Report
Young Nguyen
Young Nguyen
1 review

The worst place ever

This is our 2nd time in Orange beach and 1st with Brett/Robinson. We stayed at building V, unit 1005. OMG!!! Took 1 star off for the receptionist, thin girl, black hair, she is not even friendly, hateful is the right word for her behavior and attitude when I checked in, waited for another hour to check in-1 star off for the worst property I have ever rented, the indoor pool was so dirty that my teenage girl came up immediately after she jumped in, her word "disgusting". Don't rent the unit 1005, furniture is beyond repaired, we cannot sit without making constant adjustment because of the bottom keep sliding off base. Kitchen is dirty, coffee maker needed to fix so we can use, electrical outlets loosen off and dangerous to use, outdoor chairs...how can you sit on those chair? The owner, this place represent you! Have a little pride on yourself and spend a little man, Can't believe we paid for this...Never again I rent another unit at Brett/Robinson, do you need HOA for these condos' owners to keep their places clean?

Report
Kat Mil
Kat Mil
1 review

Displeased and disgusted

I have stayed in their condos twice and was not pleased at all, the condos were filthy, the staff was rude even overheard them downing and harassing other employees which were new hires. Id rather vacation in a card board box than stay in another phoenix/brett robinson property.

Report
Sandra
Sandra
1 review

This was our second time to stay in…

This was our second time to stay in Driftwood Towers 5E in a four year period. This condo can surely use some updating and a thorough cleaning. But the worst were the beds! They were so hard and uncomfortable. It would have been better to sleep on the sand. Honestly, it took a few days after I returned home for my back and hips to quit aching. Other than the beds, our trip was enjoyable.

Report
Kelly Guthrie

PH1-1116

We arrived on Sunday the 9th a little early so drove around we were lucky room was ready for 4. We walk in the ceiling was stained and still popcorn ceilings. The 3 different floorings for a one bedroom condo was discouraging. The bed was made but not very inviting as no comforter on the bed just sheets and a blanket. The remotes in the bedroom had no batteries. The bathroom tub had cracks we thought we were going to go thru the tub. The shower head was so old it it looked dirty. The bathroom faucet was the same, no matter how much i tried to clean it, it looked the same. The counter in the bathroom was coming unglued. The carpet in the bedroom was coming apart as I thought it was dust bunnies in the corner. The living room ceiling fan made noise. The furniture was so uncomfortable and dated. The lamps didn't even match each other. The kitchen faucet leaked 24/7. The refrigerator had rust on the side. The floor was so dirty we had to wear shoes because our feet would get black. We have been to the phoenix a few times an have never had an issue but stayed in a different unit. The owner should be ashamed to charge that much money for this. Brett Robinson as a management company should hold the owners to a standard to rent these units out. Also, during this pandemic, the elevators should be wiped down hourly. We brought napkins with us to touch the buttons as it looked liked it hasn't been wiped in months. Whoever your cleaning crew is, get new ones. Especially during this time. Your expecting your guest to wear mask while your cleaning crew walks around with no mask. One even got in the elevator with us. We are renewing our vows next April and have already booked at the Phoenix 2. Kind of rethinking it now. We may be switching.

Report
Tammy Harrison Palmore

PhoenixV 517

PhoenixV - 517 Filthiest kitchen of any condo I’ve ever stayed in. Dirty dishes in D/W AND in cabinets. Frig ice did not work and indicated new filter was required. The stand alone ice maker did not work. We bought ice, paper products to eat with cause nothing could be trusted. TVs did not work in 2 of the rooms. Floors made your feet black. Reported these issues on Sunday morning it took until Wednesday for a brief voice mail from Cashindra the Phoenix V manger. What a joke end of trips with Brett Robinson!!!! Not to big to fail!!!

Report
Kevin Sinquefield

Island Winds East is not suitable for families

Can’t believe that Brett Robinson represents the Island Winds East Property. Condos are small and dated. Limited to 1 parking space per condo, including the 3 bedrooms. Worst of all is that their is no restroom for the pool, so it acts as a large urinal. Extremely disappointed in our stay, and as annual travelers to Brett Robinson properties this stay will serve as reason to book elsewhere in the future.

Report
Jessica Carr
Jessica Carr
1 review

Not Worth The Money!!!

Nightmare is the best way to describe our experience! We stayed at the Phoenix West ll last week and when we arrived to our room we found it a mess. I can over look a lot because I had planned on cleaning myself because of COVID just to be extra safe, but 2 toilets were absolutely disgusting! I called down to the front desk after cleaning everything and the lady was extremely rude acting as if I was lying! They eventually sent someone up to clean but we had already cleaned everything so that was pointless. We noticed the next day when we came up from the beach to eat lunch that all the utensils were dirty, even had hair in the tray in the cabinet. We then had to take all the dishes down and wash everything. After two days my husband was looking for a towel and found a pill bottle dated 2018 in the bathroom cabinet. That was a huge mistake on their part! Thank goodness my children know better but if someone else had stayed there it could have not been as nice. I immediately called down to the front desk and they again started acting like I was lying and sent someone up to the room. When the lady came to the room to remove the pills she was extremely rude acting as if this disaster was all my fault! I have NEVER been more disappointed in my life! As much money as we paid to stay there it was totally not worth it at all!!! The only reason I am leaving 1 star is because I have to! I talked to others who were there at the same time and their rooms were pretty bad too! Unacceptable!!!

Report

Alternatives to Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.