Skip to main content
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals reviews & trust report

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals specializes in providing a diverse selection of vacation rental properties along the Gulf Shores and Orange Beach areas. The company offers a range of accommodations, including condos and beach houses, catering to families, couples, and groups seeking a memorable getaway. With an extensive portfolio of properties, Brett/Robinson aims to meet the varying needs of vacationers looking for beachfront access, modern amenities, and a comfortable stay. The company’s website, www.brett-robinson.com, features an easy-to-navigate platform where customers can browse available rentals, check rates, and make reservations. Targeting individuals and families interested in vacationing in Alabama's coastal regions, Brett/Robinson provides essential information to help guests plan their ideal vacation experience.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals has a positive customer experience.

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals receives a mix of feedback from customers, with a notable portion expressing dissatisfaction. Many reviewers appreciate the quality of the condos, highlighting comfortable beds and well-maintained units, particularly at locations like Phoenix IX.

Read full summary

However, numerous complaints arise regarding cleanliness and maintenance issues, with reports of mold infestations, bed bugs, and dirty linens in various units. Customers also voice frustration over poor customer service, including long wait times for check-in and unresponsive staff. While some guests commend individual team members for their assistance, the overall sentiment reflects significant concerns about the condition of the properties and the company's handling of issues. Consequently, the prevailing sentiment leans towards the negative.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.0/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 62% happy · 21% unhappy

Best for

  • Friendly staff
  • Helpful support
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Pricing
  • Defective product
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.0
100%
4.0 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
2.0
12-month avg
1.3
All-time
4.0
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Aug 24SepOctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.0Aug 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsOct 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsJun 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewJul 25: 3.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Aug 241.02
Sep 24—0
Oct 241.02
Nov 24—0
Dec 24—0
Jan 25—0
Feb 25—0
Mar 25—0
Apr 25—0
May 25—0
Jun 251.01
Jul 253.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 308 positive reviews

  • Friendly staff17%
    52 mentions
  • Helpful support16%
    50 mentions
  • Easy to use10%
    30 mentions
  • Customer service7%
    22 mentions
“The staff here are very friendly and helpful and the premises are immaculate”
On “Friendly staff” · Sep 14, 2020

Top complaintsof 106 negative reviews

  • Payment issues21%
    22 mentions
  • Pricing11%
    12 mentions
  • Defective product10%
    11 mentions
  • Customer service9%
    10 mentions
“I am staying at Phoenix I, and someone threw a white powdery water mix on one side of my black car”
On “Payment issues” · Oct 28, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals is #5 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Alfa Travel scores higher (4.6 vs 2.9).

Reviews

500 reviews of Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals. Filter by what matters to you.

4.0ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Corry Finnerty

We stayed at Phoenix V June 21-25

We stayed at Phoenix V June 21-25. Our unit, 615, was obviously recently renovated and super nice. It was not available right at 5:00, but soon thereafter. There were some cleaning issues that we discovered as the trip went on and we reported them when we left. The walkways, beach and pool were crowded much of the time. It was hard to get an elevator, and when you did, it was usually packed. If it were not for the pandemic, this would actually be tolerable given that this is such a large complex. Hand sanitizers in more areas would be great. Perhaps staggering check-in times would also help the rush to get elevators in the afternoon.

Report
C.J. Hathcock

Phoenix V nice facilities, but out of date unit.

Phoenix V facilities were very nice and inviting. Pool and splash pad were fantastic. However, they chose to close off part of the pool area to repair the concrete during the middle of the day in the middle of peak season. Kind of odd timing. The room we had, #308, needs some serious attention. Dining table top was solid glass and wobbled and slid around like crazy. Not safe for a condo, just an accident waiting to happen. Master bedroom had a tv, but no remote that worked. One by the tv didn’t have batteries and there were about 6 in a nightstand drawer that looked to be 10-15 years old. Carpet was really old and worn out. Looked like the furniture was fairly new, but that’s kinda like putting lipstick on a pig if the rest of the condo is worn out. It also wasn’t quite as clean/sanitized as we expected during the middle of the coronavirus pandemic. The toilets were the size of something you would find in a daycare facility for toddlers, definitely not made for a grown adult. Might be time to do a little overhaul in this particular unit. We enjoyed our trip, but will not pay that much again for a subpar, outdated unit.

Report
Jeff Brewer
Jeff Brewer
1 review

Room 7816

King size mattress in master was terrible. Simmons is one of the worst. I've been in the mattress industry almost 20 years and can attest to it. Other than that everything else was great. Change that terrible mattress.

Report
Kevin
Kevin
1 review

Phoenix All West Suite

Location was great for the Phoenix All West Suite room 504. Outside pools were very clean. Unfortunately upon arriving the front desk was very rude and acted very annoyed at us arriving. Poor communication once room was booked. The room had a large hole in the Sheetrock of the ceiling, the dishwasher had a large burn spot on the door and the add said newly renovated. Housekeeping did do touch up the first day but nothing after; I had to go to the front desk for towels, toilet paper and dishwashing soap everyday and take our trash out each day myself. When the front desk was asked about it they just kept saying they were short staffed and that someone had signed off saying they had done and they were trying to find out who falsified their reports. Just felt for what we paid it could have been a little better.

Report
Brooke
Brooke
1 review

Island Winds East is definitely an…

Island Winds East is definitely an older complex. Our condo, 803, was updated and very nice; however, the complex itself was not. Upon arriving, we were told that we actually couldn’t get into our room until 5, even though our confirmation email said 4. After waiting for an hour, I had to go into the office and demand the keys because I had watched our room and no one was inside cleaning. If you aren’t concerned about a nice complex and pool then you’ll be happy here. Luckily, we were able to stay in a much updated room.

Report
BRef Vols
BRef Vols
1 review

We arrive to get are room at Phoenix 3…

We arrive to get are room at Phoenix 3 and as we got to to are room the door code did not work they finally gave us a one time code to get in as they created us like 3 different codes That still didn’t work. We finally got inside and the musk smell would knock you down. As we unpack I fine the kitchen floor wet were the fridge had been Leaking under the cabinets creating a serious mold issue. The manager came up finally to get the code to work as I explain the smell and mold inside the cabinets. He was outstanding on the issue along with the lady at the front desk! He move us over to Phoenix 4 building and the room was great and we enjoy the week. Things happen and we have no control over things...we were mad about the room but they went the extra mile to make things good for us on the other building that was next door I would stay there again. I do have one thing I think that every room needs to be expected after it’s clean before letting people move in for the week like the drains and make sure everything is working.

Report
John Welch
John Welch
1 review

We were in Phoenix X unit 1406

We were in Phoenix X unit 1406. There was blood on the sheets in bedroom #2, the master bedroom did not have a sheet, the shower curtain in the master bathroom had a stain on it, one chair on the balcony was missing a leg, the WiFi was terrible, two of the remotes needed batteries and the door to the balcony from the master bedroom leaked during the rain storm.

Report
Mitsy May
Mitsy May
1 review

Stinky condo!

Last week my husband and I stayed at Phoenix 2 number 2034. We got to check in early which was nice but the smell when we opened the door was awful! I wasn’t sure I would be able to stay there but we went and bought air fresheners and eventually it was tolerable. The condo was very outdated and not very clean. It felt very grungy. There was also no supplies in the condo. Just 1 roll of toilet paper, a roll of paper towels and 1 packet of dishwasher powder. The drawers in the kitchen almost fell out when you opened them. We wouldn’t even sit on the couch. The bed was comfortable but there was only a cheap itchy blanket for cover. The elevator also smelled bad and the whole complex wasn’t very clean. I will say the shower pressure was good and the furniture on the balcony was nice. We have been to Gulf Shore/Orange Beach many times and this was the first time we stayed at a Phoenix property. I don’t think we will be going back.

Report
Gina Develin
Gina Develin
1 review

Island Winds West

We stayed at Island Winds West. There were no batteries in two remotes, the WiFi was horrible and there wasn’t enough parking for all the guests. We had to park in public parking down the street. This condo wasn’t cheap and I would expect to have a parking space. We were told by the security person if we were staying in West we couldn’t park in the East parking lot.

Report
Kelly Rogers
Kelly Rogers
1 review

We have stayed at Phoenix West yearly…

We have stayed at Phoenix West yearly for the last 12 years and have rarely had a bad experience but this year was not good. The condo (602) was not as well stocked In the kitchen as previous condos. The dryer never worked correctly despite reporting it and someone coming up to “fix it”. The beds were very uncomfortable. We did enjoy the lower level and not requiring so much elevator time. I can truly say this is the worst of the units we have stayed in at Phoenix West. Hoping for a better experience next year.

Report
Mark Kuchefski

Needs attention!

We stayed in PW 1008 during February and March this year. We’ve stayed in the building before and again this time it was overall a good experience, even though it ended abruptly. However, this particular unit needs attention. The Beds, furniture, carpets, window blinds and appliances all show extreme wear. Well beyond any reasonable life span for rentals in this price range. I’d suggest checking it out before committing to a rental.

Report
Barbara Lecy
Barbara Lecy
1 review

We have stayed several years at Phoenix…

We have stayed several years at Phoenix III. We enjoy the warm indoor pool and hot tubs. The pool area is in need of some repair around the hot tubs and walls starting to peel. Our unit had new paint and carpet a couple years ago. This was appreciated. High top table and chairs are difficult for older people. Furniture needs to be firmer in construction. Kitchen is adequately stocked but electric stove needs help. Burners are so uneven it is difficult for pans to make contact with the heating surface. Washer and dryer worked fine. GREATEST DISSAPOINTMENT came this year. When we went to reserve for the month of February we were told someone else had reserved this unit for both January and February of the following year. We were never given notice or an opportunity to reserve for the 2 months. We love this location and the 2 bedrooms. We are left with a higher location and only a 1 bedroom. This was not handled well.!!

Report
MSJAN Praska
MSJAN Praska
1 review

Phoenix VI unit 6113

This unit is convenient for coming straight in from the parking lot. However the carpeting in the bedrooms is very worn out...Desperately needs replacing. The clothes dryer take long time to dry loads. Pleased with the staff here.

Report
Disappointed

…disappointed

I received an email 2 days before my stay saying there will be construction n the balcony may not be available, it was too late to try to find another place to stay. You couldn’t spend much time in the room during the day due to noise. Balcony was not available. Also I was told I would get a 25% discount and would be credited to my card, 6 days later never happened. I sent emails about it with no responses

Report
Victor Colburn

Stayed at Phoenix III 3 nights on 7th…

Stayed at Phoenix III 3 nights on 7th floor room 3072 I think it was. There was no counter space in the bathroom to put things on. Same with the bedroom stands by the bed. I ended up with a bill much more than the quoted price for the room per day once I paid the $142.38 cleaning fee, the $28.25 Phoenix service fee, the $79.10 reservation fee etc.. There was noise in the surrounding rooms, upstairs there must have been construction all day and kids beside us. The toilet was hard to flush. The wifi was slow .52 mbps but the upload was over 10 mbps. I called front desk and no answer 3 times then I called the next day they said that they would get it reset. It got faster for about an hour and then was back to slow. Everything else was ok. I wouldn't go back because of the hidden costs which I was given the grand total when I booked the room but I guess it didn't dawn on me until I got the itemized bill what all I was paying for. The lack of counter space and the noise. I'll find somewhere else to stay.

Report
Jodie Harden
Jodie Harden
1 review

Phoenix VII is a nice complex, unit 1411, not so much

Phoenix VII is a nice complex! Room 1411 is not! 1). Walls are cracking throughout. 2). Many floor tiles are loose. 3). The toilet hadn’t been completely cleaned in weeks! The underside of the bowl was filthy!!!

Report
Steven Debrow

After 20yrs, my first disappointment....

I've visited the area for more than 20yrs and this is the first time that I've had to deal with problems as such that I had. We stayed in Phoenix 7. As that we had a three bedroom, there were no towels for the guest rooms and the guest bathroom towel rack was broken, the showers were filthy, the kitchen was dirty, there weren't enough chairs on our balcony, the bedding had not been changed, there was no mop nor dust pan for us to clean with, there were no skillets for cooking. We had to purchase our own to cook with. And the carpet was dirty. They had a person to come in during our visit to do the carpet. Therefore, we had to walk around on wet carpet for 3 to 4 hours. Given, we were offered and received a partial refund for cleaning, I had visitors,who were not from the area, who were not impressed at all.

Report
Claire K
Claire K
1 review

Great facility, bad unit

As always, Pheonix X was great! Great location in the beach right next to Florabama. Beach was great, pool was great. Our unit, #412 on the other hand was not up to par with our prior visits. It was very run down. Wall paper peeling off the walls, counter top peeling up, old moldy fixtures in the bathroom. It reminded me of a bad 1.5 star hotel. After this stay, I am hesitant to book with Pheonix again for fear of getting another unit like this.

Report
Tammy Harris
Tammy Harris
1 review

Easy access to beach was a plus!

Easy access to beach was a plus! We reserved 1 BR condo that sleeps 4... we had 4 people on reservation. There were no linens/pillows/blankets for the sofa sleeper. When we finally received the sheets/pillowcase the NEXT day, we were informed they were out of pillows and we were not given a blanket. Not impressed with that at all. Should be stocked in condo just like it is everywhere else we’ve been for the last 13 years.

Report
Kimmy
Kimmy
1 review

Pheonix 2 Room 2053

We vacationed to Orange Beach 7/26-7/29 staying in Pheonix 2 room 2053. Definitely not up to par. The master bathroom sink did not have any hot water & the sink would back up due to drainage issues. The room was not cleaned well especially master bedroom/bathroom. Still sand all over floor. The linen in the 2nd bedroom was very hard & starchy feeling! The table on the balcony was very dirty & had not been cleaned in probably months by looking at it. Very dissatisfied with room! Never had any complaints when staying in a Pheonix room but this one I would not recommend spending your money on. Expensive room for the condition it was in!! Also, I sent an email to Brett Robinson regarding my complaints & no one from their office has reached out with a reply. Bad customer service!

Report

Alternatives to Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.