Skip to main content
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals reviews & trust report

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals specializes in providing a diverse selection of vacation rental properties along the Gulf Shores and Orange Beach areas. The company offers a range of accommodations, including condos and beach houses, catering to families, couples, and groups seeking a memorable getaway. With an extensive portfolio of properties, Brett/Robinson aims to meet the varying needs of vacationers looking for beachfront access, modern amenities, and a comfortable stay. The company’s website, www.brett-robinson.com, features an easy-to-navigate platform where customers can browse available rentals, check rates, and make reservations. Targeting individuals and families interested in vacationing in Alabama's coastal regions, Brett/Robinson provides essential information to help guests plan their ideal vacation experience.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals has a positive customer experience.

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals receives a mix of feedback from customers, with a notable portion expressing dissatisfaction. Many reviewers appreciate the quality of the condos, highlighting comfortable beds and well-maintained units, particularly at locations like Phoenix IX.

Read full summary

However, numerous complaints arise regarding cleanliness and maintenance issues, with reports of mold infestations, bed bugs, and dirty linens in various units. Customers also voice frustration over poor customer service, including long wait times for check-in and unresponsive staff. While some guests commend individual team members for their assistance, the overall sentiment reflects significant concerns about the condition of the properties and the company's handling of issues. Consequently, the prevailing sentiment leans towards the negative.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.0/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 62% happy · 21% unhappy

Best for

  • Friendly staff
  • Helpful support
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Pricing
  • Defective product
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.0
100%
4.0 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
2.0
12-month avg
1.3
All-time
4.0
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Aug 24SepOctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.0Aug 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsOct 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsJun 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewJul 25: 3.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Aug 241.02
Sep 24—0
Oct 241.02
Nov 24—0
Dec 24—0
Jan 25—0
Feb 25—0
Mar 25—0
Apr 25—0
May 25—0
Jun 251.01
Jul 253.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 308 positive reviews

  • Friendly staff17%
    52 mentions
  • Helpful support16%
    50 mentions
  • Easy to use10%
    30 mentions
  • Customer service7%
    22 mentions
“The staff here are very friendly and helpful and the premises are immaculate”
On “Friendly staff” · Sep 14, 2020

Top complaintsof 106 negative reviews

  • Payment issues21%
    22 mentions
  • Pricing11%
    12 mentions
  • Defective product10%
    11 mentions
  • Customer service9%
    10 mentions
“I am staying at Phoenix I, and someone threw a white powdery water mix on one side of my black car”
On “Payment issues” · Oct 28, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals is #5 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Alfa Travel scores higher (4.6 vs 2.9).

Reviews

500 reviews of Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals. Filter by what matters to you.

4.0ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Gigi
Gigi
1 review

Family Vacation

Our family loves staying at PW II and all the amenities. Unit 1208.. Upon arrival we found the Master bathroom had a terrible smell and hadn’t been thoroughly cleaned. We contacted the front desk and they quickly sent housekeeping. The cleaning fee is extremely high not to find a clean bathroom. Both sinks in the master bathroom would not hold water which probably hadn’t been reported before our visit. The mattresses in both the 2nd king-size bedroom and room with two queen beds are broken in and need replacing. I had read this in the reviews and felt this had been taken care of so I booked this condo. I’ve stayed at this property several years and feel you should at least be able to rest for the price paid. Some of the kitchen cookware needs replacing. Overall, our family had an awesome time making more memories. Weather was absolutely beautiful! Please consider replacing mattresses, I would return to this condo.

Report
Brandon
Brandon
1 review

Phoenix West 2

We typically love staying at Phoenix West 2, but we had a few problems on this trip. Every day around 10:30 a.m. our code to our condo would change and we would be locked out! Everyday!! It was very annoying to have to come down and ask for a new code everyday and the front staff act like you were the one causing it by putting in the wrong code. We’ve stayed here for 4 years straight and never had this problem. The walls and decor were also in need of updating. Other than that we had a great trip.

Report
Angela P
Angela P
1 review

Condo 1507

I gave 3 stars since the condo was really spacious, but the furniture in it needs some severe cleaning or replacement, it has black nasty looking spots all over it, the refrigerator barely kept stuff cold but the freezer part work Great! Patio furniture could be better. For the price of this condo 1507, you would think it wouldn’t have these issues. the bedrooms and bathrooms are great size They just need to fix these few issue then I could give a perfect 5 stars

Report
Rebecca
Rebecca
1 review

We enjoyed our stay but

We enjoyed our stay, but for 12-13 years we have been going here. Over the last 2-3 times we have noticed a decline in the condos, and facilities. Memorial weekend and some of the lazy river pumps wasn't working. They had to shock the pool during people swimming. The inside pool reeks of chlorine. Check out time moved up and a cleaning fee that you do all the work prior to, and the price keeps going up with the decline in the property. With all that being said it's still a nice place its just not like it used to be.

Report
Katrina
Katrina
1 review

Cold pools - broken dryer

The weather was chilly, which is always possible on spring break.... We were really disappointed to learn only after arrival that none of the outdoor pools were heated. Total bummer. Our dryer hardly worked. After a couple of days of trying to figure out if the problem was the dryer or the user, we put in a maintenance request. the maintenance man stopped by to check it out, but said it wasn't an emergency so he wasn't going to fix it right then. Although I agree, it was not an emergency... It definitely was a total bummer to not be able to bring our laundry home clean.

Report
Cheryl
Cheryl
1 review

The rental experience was great but…

The rental experience was great but this particular condo needs some updating and repairs. We have rented from Brett/Robinson for three years in a row and love them. I just wouldn't rent this particular unit again.

Report
Pene' Kedzorski

Needs some work

This is our 3rd stay at Brett Robinson (BR) in 7 years. Tried to get a condo for 3 weeks for the 2018 winter season but BR told us they were not taking reservations so we went the VRBO route which we will never do again. Why? No customer service or awesome amenities like we have come to expect at BR P-VII and PW-II. BR Staff at POB I was exceptional and very attentive to our needs. A broken patio recliner was promptly replaced and maintenance personnel responded quickly to our broken icemaker and several burned out bulbs. The reason I only gave them three stars is because of the condition and cleanliness of the condo itself. If we could have PERSONALLY visited this unit (POB #1322) before we rented, we would not have rented it. It is evident that there is no minimum standard to which condo owners must adhere to. When we spend the amount of money that we do we expect that the place we are renting will be as nice as or better than our home. The furnishings were outdated, beat up, dirty, broken and appear to be "stock" furnishings that you might see in a hotel with several hundred rooms. Springs in the living room sofas were broken so it made getting up difficult. Living room lighting was woefully inadequate. Tiny little lamps and too few of them. We had a recliner that must have been covered in grease and shampooed over and over to no avail. The metal linkage in the underside of the rocker was broken in half and squeaked anytime someone sat on it. Vertical blinds in the living room were a joke. All different lengths, several of them twisted and impossible to close or just plain missing. Box springs in the beds were broken. Dining room table was on a rectangular pedestal such that when seated you couldn't push your chair up to the table because there was no place to put your legs. Cooking utensils? Only 2- 8 inch revere ware frying pans to cook with in a place that sleeps 8 people! Had to go to the Dollar Store to get a large nonstick pan with spatulas so I could make a real breakfast. The way the living room was arranged it was impossible to see the TV because it was only 36" and placed waaaaaay at the other end of the room. Two of the carpeted bedrooms had old style "box" TV's which did not work. Bedroom carpets were filthy. The heater vents and ceiling fan blades were dirty black. Outside areas, landscaping, pools were very clean and inviting. Very well kept up. The elevators and stairwells however REEK of mold/mildew and are in need of a cosmetic repair, better lighting and some moisture absorbing packs. The manager did come up and we expressed our displeasure. He informed us that the owners lived out of state and it's my guess that they never visit or if they do they don't care and it shows. We love POB and will be back next year. But if you are looking to rent this particular unit (#1322), don't waste your money.

Report
Barb
Barb
1 review

Unit was not very clean

Unit was not very clean. Overnight guests I had for only one night were told they had to park across Perdido Blvd even though there were a lot of spaces in the lower lots never used. I feel this is very dangerous to try to make your way across the busy street with suitcases. After much discussion it was decided that I could have a second parking pass for a two bedroom unit. Most staff were very pleasant and helpful. It was evident that improvements have been made in the building since I was last there 2 years ago.

Report
Sharon
Sharon
1 review

Good location

Good location. Convenient parking. Good stuff: kitchen well supplied. Good closet & dresser space. Carpet appeared to be clean. Furniture adequate but lazy boy chair seemed old & in need of some repair. So nice to have a table. Needs attention: front door does not always close properly. Main bathroom sink drain does not close. Overall experience Good!!

Report
Michael
Michael
1 review

Room was ok

Check in was very easy. The room need upgraded. There was some furniture broken. Ice maker would not turn off causing ice to fall out when opened. Not enough wine glasses and silverware was a joke. The broken furniture was finally replaced and extra wine glasses provided. Most problems were the owners issues and not that of the building. The pool and fitness room was very nice. We will go to the Phoenix west II again but not in condo 804.

Report
Sandra
Sandra
1 review

Mixed review

The reservation system for Brett Robinson is second to none. Responses were nearly immediate with the highest level of professionalism and efficiency mixed with politeness and concern for our situation. The reason for a three star rating stemmed from two concerns. The first being that the condo that we chose (using pictures only and not personally able to see first hand) was very clean and, at first look, tastefully decorated. After one day, it became apparent that all was not as it seemed. The kitchen appliances were subpar seemingly the cheapest on the market. There was only one small dresser in the master bedroom. The sofa was sagging and the lounge chair on the balcony was completely broken. Proper maintenance was also an issue. From the broken dryer vent, to the almost inoperable sliding doors, to the nearly broken toilet seat, to the wide gap under the entrance door. Not to mention the very poor WiFi. Disappointing to say the least. Then, there was a power outage issue, that, in itself, couldn’t be helped. But the helpfulness of the desk personnel was lacking. It seemed almost a joke to them as we struggled to find alternative shelter for the two nights. Brett Robinson alleviated the situation by providing a credit for the major inconvenience which was greatly appreciated. So, three stars. That being said, still we will definitely use Brett Robinson in the future. We have booked for next winter, but at an entirely different building. If I could rate these separately, Brett Robinson would receive five stars and our accommodations would rate maybe a two.

Report
Pauline
Pauline
1 review

When i booked the condo I ask about the…

When i booked the condo I ask about the view because we were on 1st floor and she said it would be good because we could see over everything. but there was a large balcony from conference room extending to our left. blocking the view to the east. Very disappointing since i did ask also expected a fitness room and indoor pool'

Report
Anne
Anne
1 review

Numerous repairs needed during…

Numerous repairs needed during stay-mold in the master bedroom and bathroom,broken dishwasher and blender. Remote controls needed replacement. Master bedroom TV did not work. Laundry room door did not stay closed. Many light bulbs burnt out. Staff were very responsive but all should have been in good working order prior to our monthly stay.

Report
Grady
Grady
1 review

we had a good time at the Phoenix 10

we had a good time at the Phoenix 10. we've stayed there several times. our condo was out dated and I didnt feel like it was worth the money we paid to rent it. usually all the condos are very nice but this one looked like they got all there furniture at a cheap flea market. I wont rent that condo again

Report
Dan
Dan
1 review

Location of Phoenix III is excellent.

Location of Phoenix III is excellent. Minor repairs are poorly maintained, burned out lights, clogged drain in tub, general upkeep. We stayed in a one bedroom unit that sleeps four but were told overnight guests were expected to pay $28.50 /night for parking. Furniture is outdated and doesn’t match, nor do the appliances. Kitchen is extremely under stocked in spite of a guest book review in condo stating needed kitchenware. Shower curtain outdated, missing some shower rings so curtain doesn’t hang properly. Locked out of guest closet , really limiting our already compromised space.

Report
Gerald
Gerald
1 review

Little things

One thing I would like to see is a business center or at least access to a computer to print various business items. Our housekeeping staff was marginal, dirty linens left at our front door in bag for 4 days. For a premium type of vacation facility, little things mean a lot.

Report
Mary
Mary
1 review

Nice condo with a lot of issues

The condo outwardly looked clean upon arrival but I soon realized all the floors were filthy, needed scrubbing. I used the mop in the condo which was really worthless. There were several other things that needed attention, which I made a list of and gave to the front desk when we checked out. One major issue was the whirlpool was unusable. I cleaned it upon arrival and then turned on the jets. Lots of black mildew chunks came out of the jets. NOT USABLE! The dryer had to be replaced shortly after our first load of washing but very satisfied and they were very prompt in doing so. The water on the refrigerator door did not work. I reported it, maintenance looked at it and said they had to get approval from the owner. We stayed a month. Still not working when we left. High pitched whine the whole time from the fridge. I mentioned it to maintenance and he said probably because the water wasn’t working. Fridge stopped working while we were there. Maintenance came and cleaned off the back of the fridge and re-set it. It started working but continued the whining noise and surging until we left. I went out and bought some teaspoons and kitchen bowls as there were only 3 teaspoons in the 3 bedroom condo and 3 cereal bowls in the kitchen. Otherwise, bed was comfy, great TVs, stove and MW worked. The kitchen had most everything else necessary. Had a nice view from the balcony.

Report
Robert and Iris

We have been coming to Orange Beach…

We have been coming to Orange Beach staying in a Phoenix condo since the mid 90"s during the month of March and sometimes extending into April. We have always found the management to be excellent with clean facilities, good maintenance and quick service if something is a problem in the unit. We appreciate being on the beach for walks and the view. The location is great for all kinds of recreation, entertainment and restaurants.

Report
Daniel Lester

Unit was in need of better…

Unit was in need of better furniture,very broken down and uncomfortable.We also had one of your employees unlock the door of the condo and walk in without knocking or any sort of warning.that is NOT acceptable. The refridgerator doors were dirty on the outside and the floor made your feet black when walking barefoot until we cleaned them. I stopped at your office and requested if someone could explain how to operate the cable system on the tv and if we were able to use our netlix acct on it and if so how to get into it on this system. no help ever showed up. This unit has the potential to be really nice if updated but the way it is at present we would not stay there again. also the toilet let has a problem with not shutting off and water keeps running until you wiggle the handle

Report
Bonnie
Bonnie
1 review

We've stayed at PW II 4 time but this…

We've stayed at PW II 4 time but this condo was by far the worst experience. Water, fire alarm in middle of night-3 times. It's a very noisy unit also. Will not stay in this unit again.

Report

Alternatives to Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.