Skip to main content
Carolina Cabin Rentals logo

Carolina Cabin Rentals reviews & trust report

Carolina Cabin Rentals, Inc. is a family-owned vacation rental management company established in 2008, located in the northwest mountains of North Carolina. The company specializes in managing a diverse portfolio of over 430 cabin and vacation rental properties across popular destinations, including Boone, Blowing Rock, Banner Elk, and Beech Mountain. In addition to its primary focus on the North Carolina Blue Ridge Mountains, Carolina Cabin Rentals also offers properties near Lake Norman and Watauga Lake in Tennessee. The company provides comprehensive property management services for homeowners and vacationers alike. Its team of more than 75 full-time staff and 50+ contractors ensures a seamless rental experience, catering to families, groups, and individuals seeking a mountain getaway. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Carolina Cabin Rentals aims to connect travelers with ideal accommodations for their outdoor adventures.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview703 customer reviews

Carolina Cabin Rentals has a positive customer experience.

Carolina Cabin Rentals receives high praise for its beautiful cabins and excellent customer service, with many reviewers highlighting the cleanliness and comfort of the accommodations. Guests appreciate the spaciousness of the cabins, making them ideal for family gatherings, and the accurate online descriptions of the properties.

Read full summary

However, there are significant concerns regarding the company's strict cancellation policy, which has left some customers frustrated, especially in cases of emergencies like natural disasters. Reviewers also report poor communication and responsiveness from the staff, with several expressing dissatisfaction over unresolved issues during their stays. While many enjoy their experiences, the negative feedback regarding customer service and cancellation practices cannot be overlooked.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.7/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 90% happy · 9% unhappy

Best for

  • Easy to use
  • Customer service
  • Fast & efficient

Watch out for

  • Refund
  • Customer service
  • Cancellation
703 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.7
100%
4.7 / 5 overall
703 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jan 2025.

Last 3 months
3.0▲ 2.0
12-month avg
2.0
All-time
4.7
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Apr 24MayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJan 25Category avg 4.0Apr 24: 5.0 from 1 reviewJun 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewOct 24: 1.0 from 4 reviewsNov 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewJan 25: 5.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Apr 245.01
May 24—0
Jun 241.01
Jul 24—0
Aug 24—0
Sep 24—0
Oct 241.04
Nov 241.01
Dec 24—0
Jan 255.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 449 positive reviews

  • Easy to use15%
    67 mentions
  • Customer service9%
    42 mentions
  • Fast & efficient8%
    35 mentions
  • Professionalism5%
    23 mentions
“Easy to book with”
On “Easy to use” · Jun 6, 2022

Top complaintsof 44 negative reviews

  • Refund43%
    19 mentions
  • Customer service34%
    15 mentions
  • Cancellation30%
    13 mentions
  • Payment issues27%
    12 mentions
“So, I proceeded the very next morning on the18th To notify Carolina Cabin rentals of the medical emergency and they e...”
On “Refund” · Nov 19, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Carolina Cabin Rentals logo
Carolina Cabin Rentals
4.7 out of 5 (good)703
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: Carolina Cabin Rentals is #3 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On website & app, Audley Travel scores higher (5.0 vs 3.8).

Reviews

500 reviews of Carolina Cabin Rentals. Filter by what matters to you.

4.7ⓘ

Customer reviews (703)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Rhonda Newson
Featured

No refund or reschedule Allowed, even if your brother had a stroke and you cannot come!

We are with a Church organization that decided to go back down for a second time to the Boone area and serve with Samaritan’s Purse with the disaster cleanup from hurricane Helene. We decided this time we would stay in a large vacation home to accommodate the group that was coming to volunteer and so we found a place from the agency “Carolina Cabin Rentals”. I was able to reserve it with little to no trouble, and my money was received immediately in full. The night before, we were supposed to arrive at the cabin on 11-18-24 thru 11-21-24, my brother had a very serious stroke. He was the driver and one of our leads for the trip. Of course, the only right thing to do at that time was to reschedule the volunteer trip. So, I proceeded the very next morning on the18th To notify Carolina Cabin rentals of the medical emergency and they expressed to me that the “cancellation policy” will “stay intact”, their exact words, and that , Not only will they NOT give us a refund , they will in addition NOT allow us to choose another day and use the property that has been paid in full with our money. So, not only is my brother in the hospital recovering from a stroke, but we have now lost a little bit over $1400 because someone decided in their infinite wisdom that we don’t deserve our money back OR an opportunity to come back and use our money for another date. I am only posting this so that we as consumers can be aware of bad businesses and immoral and heartless business practices.

Report
EN
EN
1 review
Featured

Extremely poor customer service!

Extremely poor customer service!! We booked a cabin for my daughter's 16th birthday through Carolina Cabin Rentals. After learning that the area was devastated by the hurricane, we contacted them to cancel. After 22 days they finally responded and denied our request to be refunded our initial payment of $722. We understood there was a cancellation policy in place, but assumed that - given the situation - they would make an exception. We waited several weeks after the hurricane to see how the area would recover, but a day before we were to be charged the remaining amount of our rental fee ($1400) we had no choice but to cancel. According to government websites, multiple roads were still closed, the area was still under a state of emergency, and it was advised that people stay out of the river directly behind our cabin due to hazardous debris in the water. In addition, all of the trails in the area were closed, as were state parks. None of the parents felt comfortable with their children traveling to this area. After CCR denied my refund request, I emailed them explaining I had researched the area's current situation (even including links to government websites with the info). They emphatically told me that schools were open and that they would not be refunding my money. I then explained to them that I did not plan to enroll my child in school there and reiterated that the purpose of our trip was to TOURIST activities that were closed (hike, kayak, raft, visit state parks). We were not spending $2200 and driving 4 hours to simply sit in a cabin for 2 days. I tried getting help from Airbnb, but didn’t get much further. I will not use either company again. What poor customer service and how sad it is that they would use a natural disaster to their advantage.

Report
Gina Flowers
Gina Flowers
1 review
Featured

If I could give this a 0

If I could give this a 0, I would. After natural disaster, Hurricane Helene, traveled through the area, leaving destruction in it’s wake (no power, flooding, no major highways into the area, not to mention a boiling water was in effect for the area) we attempted to cancel our reservation as the government advised all visitors to avoid the area to allow the cleanup and relocation efforts to continue. This organization chose to disregard the state of emergency and told us that the cabin we reserved had no damage and had power and, as such, we would not be getting a refund. This insensitivity towards their own community cleanup, at a time when they are most vulnerable, is absolutely absurd. I cannot support organizations that care more about money than each other.

Report
Shawn Duprey
Shawn Duprey
1 review

Day 3 and still have not received my…

Day 3 and still have not received my deposit back, they even took out the second payment even though it was not due until 15 days out. We agreed to rent a place with certain expectations of ability to move around the area safely and we are definitely not being afforded that opportunity. All we asked for was a full refund. Please do your homework and check these guys out.

Report
Jennifer Davidson

Open app

Open app Your location Carolina Cabin Rentals 491 George Wilson Rd, Boone, NC 28607 Cabin rental agency Jennifer Davidson 47 points a day ago My review has nothing to do with the homeowner and everything to do with Carolina Cabin Rentals. I rented a cabin through them for a women's retreat and was given a lot of misinformation that led me to making a decision that put our group in danger. Our retreat was planned for the weekend that Hurricane Helene hit western NC. Nobody ever expects a storm of this magnitude in the mountains, but I did my best to get as much details about the location of the cabin in order to make the right decision. I asked about accessing the cabin and was told we could drive our church bus there. Thank God we didn't because even on the driest and sunniest of days, accessing the cabin wouldn't have been possible in our 18 passenger bus. We would have gotten stuck in the elements. We took cars instead, which are still stuck there. I asked about the location of the cabin and was told it was just off the main road in Blowing Rock. Nope. It was 9 miles outside of Blowing Rock, off of a road full of switch back and S curves. It was NOWHERE near town and couldn't have been any more remote. I asked about the neighborhood itself and was told it was a gated community and completely paved. The first mile in was paved, but unfortunately the back 2 miles was not paved, which matters in a storm. Armed with those answers we made the decision to go. I KNOW we could have chosen not to go, but nobody expected a storm of the century. I just wanted to know the truth so I could have made a better decision. We got out and made it to a Holiday Inn to wait on transportation home. While there I met an older couple who had rented a cabin through them and was given directions to the cabin they rented. The directions given almost got the couple stranded. They needed a Jeep Wrangler or something like that to follow those directions and they just had their car. What I want out of this is for the company to just tell the truth! When I spoke to several different employees of theirs last Wednesday before we left, they each said they didn't even live in or know the area. How were they able to answer my questions if they didn't know the right answers? One of the reps said he would call the homeowner and get answers from him. He called me back and said he had spoken with the homeowner. We found out on Saturday from neighbors who had spoken to the homeowner that he didn't even know we were there. What? Why would you tell me you spoke to the homeowner and you didn't? Just tell the truth! I realize that we are so blessed to have gotten out when so many didn't or they lost everything. I accept my responsibility in the decision to go, but I would have NEVER gone and taken a group of women had I known ALL of the truth about the location. What a poor way to do business!

Report
Bo Jack
Bo Jack
1 review

Absolutely disgusted with Lei Lei…

Absolutely disgusted with Lei Lei Mountainstay. If this issue isn't corrected by the company, then we will take it to the YouTube vlog and also our social media group followers. Absolutely gross, unsafe and unsuitable for children. Don't use this company.

Report
Sam
Sam
1 review

Beware of the very strict cancelation…

Beware of the very strict cancelation policy! Read the fine print before booking! Most rentals offer a full refund if you cancel over 30 days out but with Carolina Cabin Rentals, you will pay 25% if you cancel after 24 hours of your booking and 50% if you cancel within 30 days of your booking. Highway robbery!

Report
Larry Goldberg

Proceed with caution with this company

Proceed with caution with this company. We rented a home on Eagles Nest for 30 days. We spent over $14K. On day two we noticed the A/C was not cooling well. We reported it and they sent a "handy many" to check it out, not a certified tech. The said it was fixed. 5 more visits later and being told we are the problem not the A/C, they finally sent someone with the proper testing equipment and found a freon leak. The maintenance guy apoloigized for not havin the proper equipment on the other visits. Carolina Cabin Rentals did not apologize. There were no sceens on the windows so when we opened them to cool off at night, misqiotos and moths were landing on our faces in bed. We were unfomfortable for 3 out of our 4 weeks due to gross neglagence. The worst! We asked for a discount and they did not respond. Also, we got there and found the Ice maker was not working. Thier response 10 days later was to change the water filter. Seriously! Of coure we never had an ice maker, so they had to keep bringing us ice. This company ruined our vacation. Next season we will be sure to use another company for our 30 day rental.

Report
Sean Kitchen
Sean Kitchen
1 review

I was looking at ski in ski out places…

I was looking at ski in ski out places to stay and Condo at Pinnacle Inn came up ! It’s definitely not that , it’s across the main road you would have to walk a quarter mile cross a main road and walk behind peoples houses to get to the slopes . There is some kind a of white stains on coach , red stains on the pillow in the bedroom, mold in the bathroom !! Definitely would not recommend!! I have pictures but not sure how to post them .

Report
Amy Baker
Amy Baker
1 review

Terrible communication!!!

Terrible communication!!!! Our cabin stay was during the week, last week, and I am STILL waiting to hear back from management!! The house we paid for relied completely on propane and when we checked into the cabin the propane tank was completely empty!! We had no heat and no hot water!! It was more than 24 hours when we were sent 3 space heaters, one of which stopped working after 2 minutes of use! We did not have BASIC amenities until 22 hours prior to our checkout!! All I have received is a handful of apologies from remote reservation staff!! I have sent numerous emails and made multiple phone calls about speaking to management and I have yet to hear back from anyone about any kind of refund! The cabin I paid for was not the cabin my family received!!

Report
Bailey fusco
Bailey fusco
1 review

DISGUSTING OVERPRICED DANGEROUS

Absolutely DEPLORABLE conditions of this rental. For the STEEP price we were charged It is HORRIBLE value you actually get. The windows were broken and the door was broken and the dishwasher was broken. There was mold in the bathroom there was mold in the hot tub. One of the bedroom lights wouldn’t even turn on so we couldn’t use the bedroom and we couldn’t use the bathroom. The heat was not turned on when we got there and barely worked during our stay. It was absolutely freezing. The one door barely closed and the lock was broken. UNSAFE. We weren’t given an entry code until AFTER our arrival. We weren’t given the Wi-Fi. There was no Wi-Fi to be found in the rental, which caused a very dangerous situation, considering we had no service. The floor of the living room was dirty when we got there. It absolutely was NOT CLEAN for Covid, so they put our health in direct risk of exposure. Worst rental ever. Dirty unsafe and stealing money. I have pictures and videos to prove everything! Absolutely disappointed in the condition of the rental and the lack of communication from the company. I feel my money was stolen from me.

Report
Dana Said
Dana Said
1 review

Infested with flies & no assistance from management to solve the issue

$400 refund for a cabin we paid over $4500 for 4 nights. That’s what was offered when we walked in to find the cabin INFESTED with flies. All we asked was to fix the the issue by transferring us to a new cabin or a refund for 2 nights since we no longer wanted to stay there. I have never stayed in a place so disgusting. DEAD flies in every corner and at least 10 in each room buzzing around while we’re sleeping. Won’t book here in the future, I’ll try a different, cleaner company to rent from. USE YOUR MONEY ELSEWHERE.

Report
Donnie Underwood

Not as great as website photos may lead you to believe

As others mentioned, it is difficult to communicate with the office due to so many diff staff you may get. Some are very rude & condescending. The cabin furnishings & design are top notch but you need to know that the shower pressure & hot water volume is poor; drinking water from tap is terrible; strong smell of gas each morning after we cooked breakfast & showered. So much so that we became nauseous. We have stayed at other cabin & vacation home agencies before and we won't be returning to this one.

Report
Chris Cannata

North Carolina Cabin Rentals

Me and my wife live in Florida and hurricane Ian Sept 29, 2022 came directly through our home town the same day we were supposed to leave and go to Boone, NC. I called North Carolina Cabin rentals a week ahead of our departure knowing that the hurricane would hit us. After I called several times to multiple employees and managers, they told me there is nothing they can do for me. No refund, no rescheduling, no promotion for next time or trip, and they were not kind to me on the phone either. People in Florida lost everything they have because of how serious this storm was and North Carolina cabin rentals showed no class, or compassion. Me and my wife are emergency registered nurses and had to work at our local hospital to support and be there for our local community during this storm. We will not be using this company again. Very disappointed.

Report
J “Lightning” Frank

Carolina Cabin trash!!!

Carolina Cabin trash!!!! These folks straight up robbed us. We booked a weekend and had to cancel, well in advance mind you. They refused to refund us 900$. Come to find out they get you in the "con" of their policy. Do yourself a favor people. Go to a hotel.

Report
Heather Dickson

Horrible company beware

Absolutely horrible stay at Almost Heaven and awful management company. Beware. We arrived late Thursday evening with our two infants and toddler and found the driveway was a sheet of ice and has not been plowed in weeks even though our agreement stated they would send their crew when snow accumulated to 3 inches. Ended up getting 2 vehicles stuck (we have 4 wheel drive). Had to pay a company to come help us and 4 men including 2 from Our own party had to shovel the driveway for 3 hours to move the cars. The tow truck company said chains would have done nothing in this situation even though Carolina Cabin Rentals argued with me and said we should have brought chains. The rest of The time we stayed at the house we had to park 300 ft away and carry our infants down an icy hill to get to the house. I’m addition to the unsafe not family friendly condition of the driveway the home itself was disgusting. Blood stains on the comforter, trash under the sofas, food left in the fridge, dirty towels, the list goes on. We cut our stay short because of the filth and dangers and I’ve called the company multiple times and they have done nothing. Stay far away from Almost Heaven and Carolina Cabin Rentals.

Report
Rachel
Rachel
1 review

No working door locks, hot tub, fire table, or customer service provided.

We had a hellacious experience. There was no working door code or key at check in or for the duration of our stay. Even after waiting outside for nearly 20 minutes in freezing weather, the best they could do was remotely unlock it for us. No code was ever provided, meaning we had to leave our belongings in an unlocked home for our dinner reservations. The home was missing a key piece of the advertising, the glass fire table on the deck, entirely. It also lacked a working hot tub, neither the heating or jets working, and had for some time, according to both the most recent reviews AND the maintenance man who was sent to, “look at it.” We were told by that gentleman a work order had been in for longer than a week, despite Carolina Cabin Rentals assuring me less than 24 hours prior to my check in that it was working. This amenity, particularly, had been the primary filter on which we based our decision to rent. Despite all these issues, the host refused to provide adequate recourse. By the time I despaired of reaching resolution and reached out to Airbnb, I’d been trying for HOURS, and it was nearing midnight and well below freezing. This host is in flagrant violation of almost all Airbnb policies. Thank god Airbnb handled my issues, provided options for me to find an available listing that met my criteria, and importantly, could be locked when I left and unlocked when I returned. They provided a refund and assisted with finding safe and secure accommodations. I will happily use Airbnb in the future knowing that the added fee from using this platform actually does mean they stand up for clients when hosts completely disregard their terms of service. Find another Airbnb property to rent - we are SO much happier with our replacement accommodations.

Report
Kim Shay
Kim Shay
1 review

Terrible service!!!

If I could give a 0 star review I would. We reserved a cabin thru Carolina Cabin Rentals and when we showed up today, 12/27/21, the owner was home and said that the house had sold and that the house was not available to rent. Needless to say we were in a very bad situation with no place to stay and nowhere to go. We ended up over paying for a hotel room for 5 adults…I wouldn’t ever recommend this company to rent from!!!!

Report
Nancy
Nancy
1 review

If there was a minus 5

If there was a minus 5, I would give it to them!! Steer clear of this company. Horrible customer service!!

Report
Tom P
Tom P
1 review

I paid in full in July for a December…

I paid in full in July for a December reservation. Carolina Cabins canceled the reservation in November with no notice.

Report

Alternatives to Carolina Cabin Rentals

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.