Skip to main content
Donald Russell logo

Donald Russell reviews & trust report

Donald Russell is a UK-based online butcher specializing in the supply of high-quality meat products, including beef, chicken, lamb, and seafood. With over 50 years of experience in the industry, the company caters to both individual consumers and restaurants, providing a wide range of frozen and fresh meat options. Customers can conveniently shop for various cuts of meat and prepared meals through their user-friendly website, which offers features like bespoke delivery options and seasonal promotions. The target market for Donald Russell includes home cooks seeking premium quality ingredients for everyday meals and special occasions, as well as businesses in the food service industry requiring reliable meat suppliers. The company emphasizes customer satisfaction, as evidenced by numerous positive reviews, reflecting its commitment to quality and service.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview999 customer reviews

Donald Russell has a positive customer experience.

Donald Russell receives high praise for the quality of its meat products, with many reviewers highlighting the excellent taste and overall satisfaction with their purchases. Customers frequently mention the superb quality of items like pork sausages and rump steaks, reinforcing the brand's reputation for premium offerings.

Read full summary

However, there are significant concerns regarding delivery issues, particularly since the switch to FedEx, which has led to late deliveries and mishandled orders. Some consumers express frustration over receiving frozen products without prior notice and missing items from their orders. Additionally, the customer service experience appears to be lacking, with difficulties in reaching support for complaints. While many enjoy the products, the delivery and service challenges detract from the overall experience.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.5/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 86% happy · 11% unhappy
Momentum · 6 months
-46%
Declining vs the 6 months before · was 4.5

Best for

  • Quality
  • Delivery
  • Customer service

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Delivery
  • Refund
999 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.5
100%
4.5 / 5 overall
999 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Aug 2025.

Last 3 months
1.7▼ 1.6
12-month avg
4.4
All-time
4.5
Category avg
4.1
1.02.03.04.05.0Sep 24OctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJulAug 25Category avg 4.1Sep 24: 2.8 from 5 reviewsOct 24: 4.8 from 180 reviewsNov 24: 3.0 from 12 reviewsDec 24: 3.6 from 20 reviewsJan 25: 4.0 from 9 reviewsFeb 25: 4.4 from 5 reviewsMar 25: 2.0 from 1 reviewApr 25: 4.2 from 6 reviewsMay 25: 1.5 from 2 reviewsJun 25: 1.5 from 4 reviewsJul 25: 2.2 from 5 reviewsAug 25: 1.0 from 2 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Sep 242.85
Oct 244.8180
Nov 243.012
Dec 243.620
Jan 254.09
Feb 254.45
Mar 252.01
Apr 254.26
May 251.52
Jun 251.54
Jul 252.25
Aug 251.02

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 428 positive reviews

  • Quality54%
    230 mentions
  • Delivery47%
    203 mentions
  • Customer service33%
    140 mentions
  • Prices & value20%
    85 mentions
“Just received my second meat box ,excellent again from ordering to delivery ,love the pork sausages and look forward...”
On “Quality” · Jul 7, 2025

Top complaintsof 53 negative reviews

  • Customer service38%
    20 mentions
  • Delivery28%
    15 mentions
  • Refund23%
    12 mentions
  • Pricing17%
    9 mentions
“I ordered Sunday for delivery Tuesday, received the FedEx delivery email but then, just after 5pm on the Tuesday ( wh...”
On “Customer service” · Aug 1, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Specialty Foods.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Donald Russell logo
Donald Russell
4.5 out of 5 (good)999
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.4 out of 5 (good)100
2.0 out of 5 (poor)72
4.7 out of 5 (good)51

Bottom line: Donald Russell is #3 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On service, Copenhagen Coffee Dealers scores higher (4.9 vs 4.5).

Reviews

500 reviews of Donald Russell. Filter by what matters to you.

4.5ⓘ

Customer reviews (999)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Deborah Heal
Deborah Heal
1 review

Disappointed

I’m usually very impressed with my order from you but my last order I was very disappointed. I was trying to order the chateaubriand joint for the special price of £25.00. along with some beef trims steak plus some other items to make it over£50.00 for free postage. However when I got to the payment part the chateaubriand had shot up to the usual £45. So I deleted a few things as it was more than I expected to pay and then when the joint arrived it was so small , it was only enough for 2 small portions at 500 g. I was cross as it was such a puny joint at £45.00 and I had originally ordered at special price of 25.00 but for some reason it had changed while I was doing the order. Yours disappointedly Deborah Heal

Report
MICHAEL MCGLINCHEY

Frozen. Bad quality. Avoid.

I ordered online with this butchers and I was left very disappointed. It was all frozen stuff from as far back as 2023 (this is October 2024) Absolutely horrendous. The thing is, all their stuff us expensive, so I thought it would be high-quality but it's just disappointing all around. I'd never order from here ever again. It's such a shame because we were looking for a butcher to deliver to us monthly. They lost our custom due to their bad quality.

Report
Oliver B
Oliver B
1 review

Agressivley spamming my email

Agressivley spamming my email, never signed up and unsubscribe wont work

Report
Eddie Moffatt

Order did not arrive from DHL, Donald Russell don’t seem to care

My first order made on September 4th for specific delivery today (dinner party). Told meat would come via DHL by 8pm latest. Just past 8pm I get message to say now deliver tomorrow. Very very poor and somewhere in DHL world there is meat lying in a box, whilst we had to get take away. Never again!!! Update:- Donald Russell (DR) did not even bother ringing me or answering my e mails (apart from auto responses) and I have now had to ring them myself (11 a.m). Promised a call from customer services (CS). Called again at 12 as no CS call as of yet, said that I wanted to sort my refund out. Promised call from CS. Now 1 pm, no call yet - These guys don’t care and just seem to think it’s fine that it’ll come today (well, we’ll have to wait and see for that), despite it getting to DHL Weds a.m (don’t even know when it left DR. I have remained calm & polite in all my calls to DR. Finally called back at 1.30 pm (Laura) and refund agreed. Pleasant and apologetic but offered nothing to change my view of this company, back to my original online meat delivery for me. Apologies, final update. I suggested (they didn’t) that for my time and disappointment, they might like to compensate me to encourage me to shop with them again. They have. £10 😂😂😂. Just about sums them up. A day and a half wait, a cancelled dinner party and £10 😂😂😂 Final bit, I promise……. Well, that was a surprise. Woke up this morning (Saturday) to a big upside down box of half defrosted meat outside my front door. Delivery time was 23:25 (pic below) whilst I was tucked up in bed but no knock or call given. Contents now in bin. What a waste and the lesson is - COMMUNICATION!!!!! Please take note DHL and Donald Russell as a lot of this could have been avoided. END!!!

Report
caroline Kirkpatrick

Poor Rib Eye Steaks

I ordered 4 x 28 day rib eye steaks at £60, along with a gammon joint. The rib eye steaks that arrived looked very small and not at all appealing. We had 2 for dinner tonight and they were tough and gristly and not at all pleasant. Won't be ordering again.

Report
gary denholm
gary denholm
1 review

Not fit for consumption, no response to complaints.

I’ve bought from Donald Russel for years off and on. Products are better than supermarkets apart from steaks where Lidl 36 dry aged are far superior On a recent order, my last ever, I had some wagu burgers. Not fit for consumption. I griddled without extra oil and the griddle was swimming in rendered fat. I poured it off and from each 160gm burger I had 40 gm of pure fat. I sent a complaint to them with photos and whilst acknowledged I’m still awaiting satisfaction. I could waste time holding on their call centre line but life’s to short. Shocking customer service and at best average products. Far better options out there. In my opinion I would strongly advise you avoid them.

Report
Devon Really
Devon Really
1 review

Bought 50 day aged steak

Bought 50 day aged steak. I thought it would be melt in the mouth. Unfortunately exceptionally tough. Cooked med rare And sous vide. Worst steak I’ve ever had . Have used DR for over 25 years.

Report
Viki Leigh
Viki Leigh
1 review

Just received my first order of pies…

Just received my first order of pies and ready meals. Big mistake as I usually use rendalls Online in Scotland I thought I'd try somewhere else for a change and they photograph their ready meals very well. Disgusting the steak and ale pie was all gravy and very sweet no chunks of meat whatsoever Just little chopped up pieces. The shepherd's pie was like a tesco meal. Runny mash and again the mince was sweet with some kind of herbs and lacking in meat content. I'm gutted I wasted 150 pounds on a month's worth of food I'm not going to enjoy. Either people have strange taste buds to leave such great reviews or they are used to cr@@p. Terrible never again the website is a fraud.

Report
Wendy Astin
Wendy Astin
1 review

This was my first order, never again

This was my first order, never again telephoned customer service as soon as I opened the box and realised something was wrong. I have never seen such small Barnsley chops and was not a chop but a steak. Pork very fatty and the bacon looked like it was all the small end pieces that are left after slicing. Spoke to customer service they are the worst I have ever dealt with. Yes I have received a full refund but they do not deserve anyone's custom.

Report
Alison Fraser

Far too much salt

Very little fish in fish pie and packaging information states 1.5 grams of salt per 100 grams. Meaning if you ate all the 400 grams you're having 6 grams of salt which is the total maximum daily recommended salt intake. Very disappointed.

Report
Jane
Jane
1 review

Things have changed here.Not what it…

Things have changed here. Not what it was. Bombarded by emails with special offers for a start. I prefer quality over quantity. The bombardment is not what I would expect from a reputable company but from a very greedy company. I have also found that the quality has declined and, if their recent survey is anything to go by, I think they are on the wrong track altogether regarding what their loyal customers want and why they have bought from Donald Russell in the past. I used to love going online to order but now doing this rarely as the trust I had in what I perceived as a quality and very reputable company has gone downhill. Please get your values in order Donald Russell. I would love to feel the trust again and know that you are providing the quality I knew and loved for a long time. The impression you are now giving is not that of a long trusted company but one that is just thirsty for customers’ money.

Report
john langley
john langley
1 review

NOT worth the Money

Paid £50 for a bit of fillet steak . Chateabriand centre cut supposed to be the finest ! Sorry but the simple truth is I have been buying far better quality fillets from Lidl and Tesco for last 45 yrs ! A normal size fillet is only £5-£6 and 8/10 times it’s very high quality, no fat grisel and it so tender it’s satisfying. I’ve often gone to steak houses and come away thinking why is it I can get so much better quality for 5-£6 yet all this so called grass fed etc is tough and fatty and is definitely not worth the extra money . First time I wasted £50 with Donald Russell and my advice DONT waste your money !

Report
Peter Neill
Peter Neill
1 review

Declining Quality

Ordered their gammon steaks and they were very poor quality.They are only a little thicker than a piece of bacon, full of water when cooked and because if the thinness are tough even when cooked for a very short time.Definitely would not recommend these. Also ordered Extra trimmed rump steaks, on cooking one was very tender but the other was so tough and sinewy that not even a steak knife could cut it. We have used Donald Russell for many years, but sadly the original quality has disappeared and all too often the products are no better than some supermarket products and not as good as local butchers yet have a higher price.

Report
Mrs Barnwell
Mrs Barnwell
1 review

I ordered poorly handled complaint a discounted chateabriand…

I ordered a discounted chateabriand 2for 1 only one arrived I telephoned they said I had ordered wrongly although the lady on phone was very nice her supervisor wasn’t. She would not send me another withou £15 charge. I know it’s not a large amount of money but so badly handled. I will not be ordering again Your information is wrong I paid the extra money on a credit card over the phone!!! This was for postage and £5.00 extra for second chateabriand.

Report
VJ of South Wales

Meat is much to lean

Meat is much to lean: Steak burgers once cooked in the oven were dry and tasteless, they were so lean that I didn’t even need to wash the baking tray that I used to cook them on. the beef mince wasn’t much better or liver, although the beef steaks were a tiny bit better. I wouldn’t recommend any of this meat I’ve tried for a keto diet especially not a carnivore it is much to lean.

Report
Mrs Smith
Mrs Smith
1 review

Poor service overall

I have ordered from Donald Russell many times and normally the produce is good. This order was well over £100 and when received I was surprised at the quality. The steaks were tiny half size pieces, pork chops the same, thinly cut and scraggy looking. Cheesecakes were very bland and claggy in texture and, overall, I felt like I’d been done. Customer services replied to complaint with ‘sorry but sizes of meat were cut to size stated’. That was it. No offer of small discount or any refund, nothing. I replied saying I would not be ordering again and was shocked to receive the response ‘sorry to hear about that, do you want me to remove you from our mailing list?’ Not the response expected from a butcher that advertises its quality produce and customer satisfaction. I’ve spent £100’s over the last few years, and never raised a complaint, even when a few items weren’t as expected, I usually take the good with the bad. I won’t be ordering again though after this, and would advise caution of you are expecting good size cuts and real value for money. Mrs Smith

Report
Laura Aston
Laura Aston
1 review

I placed an order and it didn't arrive

I placed an order and it didn't arrive. When I contacted them they blamed their couriers but their excuse didn't stand up. I eventually received a replacement but with no compensation for the inconvenience and distress it caused !! I am very disappointed both with their customer service and their ordering controls !!

Report
Fred Christmas

Beware of Donald Russel Special Offers. After many years as a customer we…

After many years as a customer we thought we would respond to the 50 years celebration mail shot offer of two Chateaubriand steaks for £50. The mail shot said to order on line or call. We decided to order on line. The problem was that the special offer was not on the website so assumed it would appear during the check out process but it did not and we accidentally ordered the non special offer single Chateaubriand for £45 plus an additional 2 fillet steaks. We only realised this error after delivery. We called customer service to explain and they helpfully suggested that they would correct this by issuing a credit of one Chateaubriand added to our next order. This was satisfactory and all was well until we had a call back from customer service that this offer had to be withdrawn as a mistake had been made. This is totally unacceptable and we will now no longer buy from this company and we are posting this review to warn others so they do not get misled by these special offers mail shots which do not appear on their website.

Report
Sally Arkley
Sally Arkley
1 review

D minus!

Good products. All fine until something goes wrong. Then the customer is blamed for clear problems with new systems. Appalled by customer service! After some years of being a good customer and many recommendations to friends, I am not using them ever again, so many excellent competitors!

Report
S ZANANIRI
S ZANANIRI
1 review

A long time customer of Donald Russell…

A long time customer of Donald Russell (DR) and I really like their food. But I will never place an order with them again. DR use DHL as their courier to deliver to our home in Berkshire. DHL often advise on a 2-3 hour delivery slot, though sometimes the box is just left at the door so you have to keep an eye out. But yesterday DHL gave me a 10 hour delivery slot starting at 10am and ending at 8pm. I watched on the app as the driver made his way through 150 deliveries (I was number 143). By the time delivery 91 was reached the app stopped working. I assume so did the driver. When I complained at 8.10pm that I no longer wanted a delivery of frozen food that has been inside a hot smelly DHL lorry all day (maybe longer), I received a message from DHL at 8.33pm saying they tried to deliver my order but they could not get access to my home. This is a complete lie, as my ring doorbell could verify. I did use bad language because this disgusting company pushed me to my limits with their lies and BS. DR couldn't care less - just spouting a load of scottish sorry nonsense. DHL certainly couldn't care less and I am sure their drivers all took a piece of my order home with them. Don't give money to either of these companies - they don't care and they don't deserve it. And their response is a Scottish Folk Tale - the resolution was a refund that will take 3 days to be back on my debit card, whilst I waited 5 days for an order never to be received. Go back to sleep.

Report

Alternatives to Donald Russell

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.