Skip to main content
Total Cards logo

Total Cards reviews & trust report

Total Cards is a leading online retailer specializing in trading cards, board games, and collectibles. Established in 2012, the company has built a reputation for providing a wide variety of card games, including popular titles such as Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and more. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Total Cards offers over 20,000 reviews and has sold more than 1 million cards, indicating a strong presence in the gaming community. The company's product range extends beyond trading cards to include accessories like premium sleeves and deck boxes, as well as a selection of LEGO sets, puzzles, and Funko Pops. Total Cards caters to gaming enthusiasts of all ages, ensuring a diverse inventory that meets the interests of both casual players and serious collectors. With convenient features like next-day delivery and free UK shipping on orders over £20, Total Cards aims to provide a seamless shopping experience for its customers.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview85 customer reviews

Total Cards has a poor customer experience.

Total Cards receives a mixed reception from customers, with a significant number expressing dissatisfaction. While some reviewers commend the fantastic service and quick delivery, noting excellent packaging and prompt responses to issues, the majority report serious problems with order fulfillment.

Read full summary

Many customers experience canceled orders under questionable circumstances, delayed pre-orders, and a lack of communication regarding stock availability. Complaints about inflated prices and poor handling of Pokémon TCG products are prevalent, with some labeling the company as "scammers." Additionally, issues with the trade-in process and refusal of returns further contribute to the negative sentiment. Overall, while there are positive experiences, the overwhelming number of complaints about order management and pricing leads to a predominantly negative view of Total Cards.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
2.3/ 5
Mostly negative
Recent reviews: 29% happy · 69% unhappy
Momentum · 6 months
+27%
Improving vs the 6 months before · was 1.9

Best for

  • Delivery
  • Customer service
  • Fast & efficient

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Refund
  • Payment issues
85 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
2.3
100%
2.3 / 5 overall
85 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Nov 2025.

Last 3 months
2.8▲ 0.5
12-month avg
2.1
All-time
2.3
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Dec 24Jan 25FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNov 25Category avg 4.0Dec 24: 3.0 from 4 reviewsJan 25: 1.6 from 7 reviewsFeb 25: 1.3 from 3 reviewsMar 25: 1.0 from 9 reviewsApr 25: 1.7 from 11 reviewsMay 25: 3.3 from 8 reviewsJun 25: 2.6 from 16 reviewsJul 25: 1.0 from 4 reviewsSep 25: 2.3 from 3 reviewsOct 25: 2.0 from 4 reviewsNov 25: 5.0 from 2 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Dec 243.04
Jan 251.67
Feb 251.33
Mar 251.09
Apr 251.711
May 253.38
Jun 252.616
Jul 251.04
Aug 25—0
Sep 252.33
Oct 252.04
Nov 255.02

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 85 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 25 positive reviews

  • Delivery48%
    12 mentions
  • Customer service48%
    12 mentions
  • Fast & efficient44%
    11 mentions
  • Prices & value36%
    9 mentions
“Fantastic service, quick email response to a problem while ordering and then quick delivery with the product being ve...”
On “Delivery” · Nov 27, 2025

Top complaintsof 59 negative reviews

  • Customer service34%
    20 mentions
  • Refund32%
    19 mentions
  • Payment issues25%
    15 mentions
  • Pricing24%
    14 mentions
“Placed an order this evening only to have it cancelled on the false pretence that I had put in a cancellation request...”
On “Customer service” · Oct 8, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Electronics & Technology.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Total Cards logo
Total Cards
2.3 out of 5 (poor)85
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,060
4.1 out of 5 (good)1,060
4.7 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000

Bottom line: Total Cards is #5 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, DigitalLicense scores higher (4.9 vs 2.1).

Reviews

85 reviews of Total Cards. Filter by what matters to you.

2.3ⓘ

Customer reviews (85)

1 review in the last 12 months

Write a review
Ryan
Ryan
1 review

Unprofessional and full of bad practices

Avoid this place. Never order online from them. Business is very poorly managed, by people who are clearly only in it for money. Regular staff are alright but are at the mercy of horrendous management, it’s a recipe for disaster. Recently pre-ordered some pokemon cards at regular price, only to be emailed by the company days later stating that they made a pricing error and need me to pay the difference. Normally I’d think “eh, bad company” and move on, but their email responses have been so unprofessional, pushing all blame onto the customers and going so far as to gaslight them?! Genuinely, stay away from these guys. It shouldn’t be supported. Should they leave a response here attempting to clear their name, don’t believe it. It’s a wolf in sheep’s clothing.

Report
Simon
Simon
1 review

Both in the shop and on their whatnot…

Both in the shop and on their whatnot streams I’d recommend avoiding. As a business they clearly prioritise £ over customer experience. Ultimately better shops and more customer friendly streamers out there who encourage repeat custom by not mis-leading viewers. They blocked me on whatnot to avoid this review going on there. Avoid

Report
Ge
Ge
1 review

Does not deliver preorders on release date

What's the point in taking money for preorders and then not bother fulfilling for release date specified on the website? Avoid.

Report
Scott
Scott
1 review

The worst trading card company I have…

The worst trading card company I have ever purchased from. The website is useless. The notifications re new stock is false and I attempted to order the exact same minute an item became available on the site, I had it in my basket and when I went to pay it then send item is out of stock even though it had only became available the minute I ordered it. RIDICULOUS SERVICE PROVIDED FROM THIS WACK COMPANY.

Report
Consumer
Consumer
1 review

IMPORTANT FOR READERS

IMPORTANT FOR READERS: Their responses to everyone regarding this specific situation have been lies. This “store policy” of limits on booster bundles was NOT there when I placed my order back in November 2024. Gaslighting your customers is actually crazy. If there ACTUALLY was a limit, you would not be able to add more than one to your basket, let alone check out and pay. And them claiming to make the stock available at MSRP at their gaming centre like they’re some sort of saviour is funny.If they do end up doing this, it’s likely just to save face after the backlash. If that’s the case, why was the same item on your website marked up recently? And why are you selling individual packs on whatnot for £8.95? Onto my story: Placed a preorder well over 5 months ago, which included 4 Pokemon Prismatic Booster Bundles. £23.95 each. Last month, my order was fulfilled but with only one of the four items - saying only “some of your items have shipped”. No mention of cancellation or anything. Fast forward, today I receive an email that saying those extra items have been refunded - a whole 5 months after placing the preorder and a month after the release date of those specific items. Their reasoning was “product limit of one per cutomer”. This is completely untrue as there was no limit at the time and they sold the same item for a marked up price on their website just a couple weeks back. They’re using this excuse as they see the product is sought after and don’t want to sell for retail price. Scalper behaviour. The recent boom in Pokemon has shown which retailers actually value their customers and which ones take advantage of them. I will not be returning even if they sell these products at MSRP again as this experience has shown me they’re no different to scalpers.

Report
Joe Rogers
Joe Rogers
1 review

Abysmal communication, outright lies and trying to pass the blame onto customers for their misleading webpage

Absolutely awful business that communicates terribly with customers. Nowhere on the website does it mention potential shipping delays and further, when at checkout and making payment states the order will be delivered on a day that simply will not happen. The webisite also states that they deliver "7 days a week, express shipping every day" I will never use their services again. Your reply is an abject joke Ryan. "especially when the estimated delivery date shown at checkout didn’t account for this" As for this, at no point during the checkout process does your webpage state that these delivery times are "estimates" this is an outright lie from yourself. Your webpage specifically said that delivery would be today, Friday. There is never any mention of an "estimated" delivery. Your website is simply just misleading customers. Also I did not place my order during a "holiday" as you incorrectly stated in quotation from the delivery page, in your reply to my trustpilot review. This is another outright lie. Furthermore, express delivery was offered for free by yourselves due to the large amount my order came to.

Report
Sam
Sam
1 review

Preordered a Pokemon Product and waited…

Preordered a Pokemon Product and waited for 5 months for release. Never arrived so checked in a week later and they said it was in the process of being refunded. They sent me 1 out of the 10 case product I ordered. Promised a refund that took over a month to return to me. Rubbish, Rubbish Company. AVOID AVOID AVOID. Go to Chaos cards or Magic madhouse, much better companies.

Report
Generals Mark

Do not go to this shop

Do not go to this shop. The experience I had is a joke and I wish I never started with them. They make promises regarding stock and then sell it all on whatnot. They refuse customers to purchase stock at various times and make up silly rules. No manager is ever available to speak to when you need further help. Plus the turnover of staff is ridiculous which says it all.

Report
Jh
Jh
1 review

Avoid!

Spent £5500 with them, got 555k reward points and mythic tier (you'd think they want to help good sized buyers) as they've had next to no stock in sealed english packs, they've devalued my points by 33% because i didn't spend them within 30 days.... There' s been no stock to spend them on!! Even as of today 31.03.25, all 5 featured sets on the website have Zero stock for me to be able to use points. Ryan in customer service was useless, better off shopping elsewhere for loyalty.

Report
Philip Mountford

Preorder

So Ive preordered an ETB and the release date is today and Ive had not dispatch email, and nothing has turned up. My partner ordered one for herself which has turned up, as the website states one per customer. Email them to ask whats going and this is what i get back. "​I will look into this, as I know that the team are working through duplicate orders from people who have used the same billing address or shipping address. I know that there was a limit of 1 per household so this might be the case" I have no idea where this "1 per household" has come from as I can go on the website now and it states one per customer. T&C's state limitations on products are on the product page which is one per customer. Dont think their allowed to change what the limitations are on release day, goes against their terms and conditions.

Report
customer
customer
1 review

These people don't know what a pre-order is.

I've pre-ordered from Total Cards a couple of times now. My expectation when I pre-order from anywhere, is that stock arrives in their warehouse before launch, they box it up and post it with the aim of it arriving with me on launch day. I only expect to be contacted if there's a delay, or when my items are dispatched. Every time I've pre-ordered from Total Cards, I get radio silence for several days post launch at which point I'm then forced to email them reminding them that my pre-order exists, I then get an automated dispatch notification later that day and receive my items a few days later. I've got a pre-order in right now, launch day is today, and guess how many updates I've got in my inbox? None. Guess how many boxes of cards are on my doorstep, that's right, also none. It is not my job to keep reminding you that my order exists, and after this it won't matter, because I'll be buying elsewhere. EDIT: I see Ryan below is perfectly capable of typing up a detailed description of why my order isn't here, in a Trustpilot review. Maybe Ryan could put those skills to use emailing his customers, before we have to resort to leaving 1 star reviews and taking our business elsewhere?

Report
Chris Frost
Chris Frost
1 review

Ordered 4 prismatic booster bundles…

Ordered 4 prismatic booster bundles when there was no limit on how many to order. They kept my money for months and when it was release day they only sent me 1 and refunded me for the other 3. Saying only 1 per person. They didn't uphold the original agreement for which I paid. Absolutely terrible site. Not trusted anymore.

Report
Simon
Simon
1 review

Avoid, go to Chaos or doublesleeved instead

Ordered 16x boosters, received 15 but didnt want to make a fuss over 1 pack as i was happy enough to get them seeing as they are not a standard release, I then wasnt notified of product releases after signing up for them, then started getting notifications at random hours telling me that products have come back in stock, emailed them to explain this, got an “apology” 4 nights on the trot at 3 -4am ive had email notifications that were false. They do t seem interested in customer service and have cancelled a lot of preorders at rrp in order to then sell on whatnot at an inflated price, they have essentially become scalpers and try to justify it with a store front,

Report
Koi B
Koi B
1 review

Don’t ever leave reviews but thought I…

Don’t ever leave reviews but thought I needed to with this. I pre ordered prismatic evolution booster bundle last November limit was 20 per order. Today I have just been told I would only be getting 1 because that was the limit per customer, but that wasn’t the case in November funny that the now they are worth more than double that they’ve done this. I’ve essentially gave them a £500 loan for 5 and half months interest free now think how many other people this has happened too. The worst thing is I had to chase this up myself to see what was happening with the order to then be told 10 days after scheduled release date and on the second time of contacting them this was 1 limit per customer and would be getting a refund for the rest, told them cancel full order . I hope when the Pokemon boom dies down, which it will people remember the ones who pulled these types of stunts under the guise of ‘distribution issues’ but have no issues with stock when fleecing consumers on platforms such as Whatnot.

Report
David
David
1 review

Shameless company canceling pre-orders…

Shameless company canceling pre-orders because they need the stock so they can scalp customers at inflated prices on their live stream. Hard avoid.

Report
Robbie McKay
Robbie McKay
1 review

Meant to be a reputable company but is…

Meant to be a reputable company but is scalping Pokemon products even in the preorders. Ridiculous

Report
scott
scott
1 review

Don’t waste your time.

Don’t waste your time. I placed an order on the 27th hoping to secure the 3 Promo cards, I emailed afterwards just to confirm if my order would include the 3 promo cards they had advertised when you spend £100 or more. Ryan is pretty useless and isn’t willing to find out, the customer service is shocking. How hard could it have been for him to give me a yes or no, I would have still followed through with my order regardless. I just wanted to know if I’d receive the promos or not so I could secure them from other sites if need be! On 2 occasions I asked Ryan to see if my order would include them and both times his response was “Unfortunately, as I am part of the support team, I don’t handle this directly” Surely you can find out? Surely you all work in the same building? Surely you can ask the question? Lazy customer service! Order cancelled and customer now lost.

Report
Sam Crichton
Sam Crichton
1 review

EXPECT LONG DELAYS (3 month delay and cancelled))

EXPECT LONG DELAYS (Products are on Back order) Not clearly displayed that products are on back order and not in warehouse when you buy them. Had to wait 3 months for my product and when I asked for compensation due to the delay they just cancelled my order and provided a refund of the origional price. This is just stupid when you consider the product is now 3x the price on the secondary market and that supposedly buying these products in November would guarantee the gifts arive by christmas. DO NOT ORDER PRODUCTS if you need them by a certain deadline or as a gift. No guarantee of timeline and completely reliant on their supposedly extremely slow suppliers.

Report
Ivo Paskov
Ivo Paskov
1 review

Horrable

Horrable, absolute disaster, unbelivably slow. I have purchased items from this shop many times and it just gets worse and worse as time goes on. No extra stickers anymore, no good communication and devastatingly long delays for delivery. 2 days delivery? How about an almost whole month of waiting for 2 pack sleeves that were 'being waited on backorders' just to delay my whole order of items over 20 pounds, 3 different emails of me asking them what's the reason for that delay and them sending me the same copy-pasted answer, just to make me change the order for items they have on stock for little bit less than the amount I paid, not accepting to return my money back aaaand not even giving me any extra booster or extra card sleeve pack or a sticker or a grain of rice for that matter (not to mention that I didn't pulled anything good). Absolute horse crap site, I will never buy again and believe that they owe me money for all my waiting and delay they caused. Liars and unreliable service. Search for a different site

Report
Alex
Alex
1 review

Scalpers with a shop

They're scalpers with a shop. 10 days after Prismatic Evolutions releases they've got booster packs up for £9.95, presumably ripped from boxes that should've been sold to customers at RRP. Scum of the earth, genuinely the worst TCG shop I've ever dealt with.

Report

Alternatives to Total Cards

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.