Skip to main content
America Car Rental logo

America Car Rental reviews & trust report

America Car Rental is a leading car rental service provider in Mexico, specializing in offering a wide range of vehicles for both leisure and business travelers. With over 20 years of experience in the industry, the company operates in major tourist destinations such as Cancún, Playa del Carmen, Tulum, and Mexico City, ensuring convenience and accessibility for its customers. The company is committed to providing competitive rates on its fleet of well-maintained cars and SUVs, which come with a variety of insurance options, including 0% deductible for loss and collision damage coverage. America Car Rental aims to deliver a seamless rental experience by offering services year-round, including flexible booking and customer support, making it a reliable choice for anyone looking to explore Mexico's top destinations.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview618 customer reviews

America Car Rental has a positive customer experience.

America Car Rental receives high praise for its excellent service and attentive staff, with many reviewers highlighting the professionalism and friendliness of employees like Claudia and Marianela. Customers appreciate the efficient process, noting that vehicles are clean and ready on time, contributing to a positive rental experience.

Read full summary

However, some negative feedback emerges regarding issues with service reliability, particularly concerning financial disputes, such as claims of being charged for damages without proper accountability. Despite these concerns, the majority of consumers express satisfaction with their rentals, emphasizing the quality of service and the overall pleasant experience. Overall, America Car Rental is viewed positively, with a strong emphasis on customer care.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
2 of 2 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.6/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 88% happy · 11% unhappy
Momentum · 6 months
+13%
Improving vs the 6 months before · was 3.7

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Friendly staff
  • Helpful support

Watch out for

  • Charges
  • Scam
  • Payment issues
618 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.6
100%
4.6 / 5 overall
618 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Sep 2025.

Last 3 months
4.0▼ 0.3
12-month avg
4.0
All-time
4.6
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Oct 24NovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSep 25Category avg 4.0Oct 24: 3.0 from 2 reviewsNov 24: 2.0 from 4 reviewsDec 24: 2.9 from 8 reviewsJan 25: 1.8 from 5 reviewsFeb 25: 2.5 from 8 reviewsMar 25: 4.6 from 39 reviewsApr 25: 4.3 from 16 reviewsMay 25: 4.3 from 15 reviewsJun 25: 4.5 from 16 reviewsJul 25: 3.7 from 18 reviewsAug 25: 4.4 from 19 reviewsSep 25: 4.0 from 8 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Oct 243.02
Nov 242.04
Dec 242.98
Jan 251.85
Feb 252.58
Mar 254.639
Apr 254.316
May 254.315
Jun 254.516
Jul 253.718
Aug 254.419
Sep 254.08

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 439 positive reviews

  • Customer service6%
    25 mentions
  • Friendly staff3%
    11 mentions
  • Helpful support2%
    9 mentions
  • Easy to use2%
    8 mentions
“Perfect service from Marianela”
On “Customer service” · Aug 30, 2025

Top complaintsof 57 negative reviews

  • Charges23%
    13 mentions
  • Scam19%
    11 mentions
  • Payment issues19%
    11 mentions
  • Customer service16%
    9 mentions
“My experience started out pretty decent they did come and get me from the airport took me didn’t wait long to receive...”
On “Charges” · Sep 1, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Car Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
America Car Rental logo
America Car Rental
4.6 out of 5 (good)618
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,000
3.4 out of 5 (fair)1,000
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.6 out of 5 (good)998

Bottom line: America Car Rental is #4 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On booking, Lava Car Rental scores higher (4.6 vs 1.0).

Reviews

500 reviews of America Car Rental. Filter by what matters to you.

4.6ⓘ

Customer reviews (618)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Featured

Pesimo servicio y me robaron el dinero…

Pesimo servicio y me robaron el dinero de una llanta que tuve que cambiar, jamás se hicieron responsables

Report
Kevin
Kevin
1 review

My experience started out pretty decent…

My experience started out pretty decent they did come and get me from the airport took me didn’t wait long to receive a car but upon returning the car I did have to wait to go to the airport my main concern was that they put my deposit through and they also double charged me I have purchased my vehicle through priceline.com along with my flight they also charge me the exact same fee that Priceline charge me plus a $300 deposit they put everything through and never gave me back my deposit to clerk they lied to me and told me that the fee cost for the tolls was $36 they charged me two times for that I’m still fighting this day to try to even get my deposit back please please be leery of this company the one in Houston is a scam!!!

Report
LesterShaw
LesterShaw
1 review

NEVER Book a Car Rental From America or Economy

We booked a car rental reservation ( customer name Lester Shaw- Economy Rentals) on-line through "Priceline". Our reservation total came to $715.90 "including" full insurance. When we arrived to pick up the car at the Guadalajara, Mexico airport the America agent (who also does rentals for "Economy Car Rentals") the young agent did not speak English. She told us in Spanish that the $715.90 was only to make the reservation, and that she could not allow the actual rental of the car for less then $1,695.00 USD. Of course we showed her the reservation with the "Final Full Price" of $715.90, but she said she did not know or care what "Priceline" quoted. She was extremely rude! We left without renting the car! We will make a complaint to Priceline as well.

Report
byron moreno
byron moreno
1 review

Garbage DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FOR THIS…

Garbage DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FOR THIS COMPANY I arrived at Santo Domingo Dominican republic at 2am thinking after many emails I was gonna meet someone at the door with my rental and all of that I wanted for 3 hours remind you it is 3am in a foreign country where I know noone ... I then asked to see where this rental place was nd a police officer tells me it's outside the airport I grabbed a taxi 10 mins out leaving my family at the airport yo f8nd out what was going on when I arrived there were 2 guys there where they were almost asleep I then presented my self he says ID I gave them my US ID nd they said not enough but then the other guy at the computer says oh we don't have anything for you the company will give u money back I'm sorry you have to leave and that's it ... what type of company is this I don't know NO RENTEN NADAA THIS COMPANY IS A FRAUD

Report
Lucreshia Curtis

Scammers in Miami, Florida

First and foremost, their employee MIGUEL is too good of a worker to be hired by a corrupt company. He was patient and amazing with myself and the other seven people that had the same problem. Priceline and Expedia are in cahoots with this company to scam renters out of more money when using the third party app. They encourage you to use your own insurance but never mentioned that America Car rental has an unrealistic number set for coverage. 500,000.00 liability is what they require to use personal insurance to rent a Nissan Sentra! I purchase Priceline coverage and they didn’t accept that either!!! Then they’ll hold a deposit on a major credit card and wait until they charge you to say it takes 25 DAYS to put your funds back on your card. The most insulting part besides the female short with dark straight hair (Hispanic) RUDE worker is. The insurance you purchase from them doesn’t even give you the liability coverage that they’re asking for SMH. This place needs to be shut down!

Report
Edwinia Harden-Finley

America car rental on JFK in Houston Texas

First of all, we were given the wrong address by the time we got to America Car Rental in Houston Texas. The guy was there by hisself didn’t understand anything we were saying gave us one car that was so raggedy. We had to tell him no a second car was better looking, but the backseat had everything spilled in it. We were in a hurry so we had to go ahead and take that car, but the whole time we drove in it kept saying the engine needed to be checked , pre-collision system was down. The lights was malfunctioning. I wouldn’t recommend a dog to rent a car there. Tried to charge me toll fees and airport fees.

Report
Ana Sofia Castillo Schmitz

Pésimo servicio me senti engañada

Pésimo servicio, me dieron el peor coche al final que porque no tenían segun otro y ni aceite tenía de pura magia me pare a la gas en la semana para revisar niveles y me comentaron que no tenía aceite, contrate seguro mayor y al parecer no cubría un rasponcito y me quieren cobrar 6mil pesos casi por algo que sale con polish y cuesta máximo 2mil, pero me dicen que quieren remplazar la pieza entera, me sentí engañada y terminé con muy mal sabor de boca del viaje, únicamente acepte ese coche tan feo porque iba por trabajo y me urgia empezar a moverme. En la vida vuelvo a rentar en esta compañía. Como dicen, lo barato sale caro...

Report
W VDH
W VDH
1 review

Very difficult communication

I booked a family car but received an open pickup (proposal of America car rental). The ferry doesn't accept pickups and now I need to change my car in Tulum. However this already takes 2 weeks to arrange, they want me to pay twice,and the communication of America Car Rental is very poor, they wait days to answer.

Report
Douglas Snyder

Worst car rental company in Puerto Vallarta Mexico

Never trust this car rental car company. It’s a bait and switch company, of the worst order. Waisted 3 hours and Two Uber ride share money, looking for legitimate car rental company first day in Puerto Vallarta 6-30-2025. These people are rip off artist, pure and simple, booked through orbit.com. Book through orbit, which is complicit with a car rental company. Worst experience, at the beginning of my first part of my first Puerto Vallarta vacation.

Report
Eduardo Carlos

El peor servicio

El peor servicio. Pedí una auto grande para 12 personas y 2 pequeños. Cuando llegue al aeropuerto de guadalajara ni la cara quisieron dar los agentes, tuve que llamar para que según ellos me dieron la fabulosa opción de darme 2 nissan march para que llevaría a 12 adultos y 2 niños es enserió? No respetan tu reservacion, si haces una reserva con una compañía como esta es para tu tranquilidad no para que te cause mas estres en un viaje familia. De mi parte no les recomiendo rental con esta compañía de mi parte no cometeré el mismo error.

Report
Pete Martin
Pete Martin
1 review

DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FROM AMERICA CAR…

DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FROM AMERICA CAR RENTAL. Not sure how they scored above 2 STARS here because they honestly deserve a negative star review. They are a bait & switch opperation. YOU’VE BEEN WARNED!!’

Report
Yvette Rodriguez

This was the absolute worst experience…

This was the absolute worst experience I’ve ever had renting a car. Simply because I declined insurance (as I had my own) and tolls, the clerk added over $100 in bogus surcharges. He literally made this rental impossible. And he did so for at least 7 other people here that were also waiting. If we didn’t agree to pay ridiculous extra charges - we weren’t getting a car rental. So many of us were left stranded! Having to return to the airport to make alternative plans. SAVE YOURSELF THE HEADACHE AND GO ELSEWHERE. They will rip you off or leave you stranded. Terrible business practices- no ethics! They should get fined for this bait and switch they have going on! I had a reservation and the amount more than doubled… SHAME ON YOU AMERICA CAR RENTAL!! No wonder- it’s a company based in Mexico operating in Orlando Florida- what can you expect???

Report
Hannah P
Hannah P
1 review

DO NOT USE America Car Rental ORLANDO they are CROOKS!

I paid for a car package from Priceline with America Car rental out of Orlando MCO. I must report they are a very bad company. No one should offer their car rental services! Their location is far from the airport and when we got there, they wanted an additional $479.00 from us for car insurance. I have a letter of car insurance coverage from Citibank visa of up to $50K and also our own Geico car insurance and they refused to let us decline their exorbitant car insurance coverage. It is our right to decline it if we are providing our own insurance. However, they would not give us the car unless we paid it. It was also 96 degrees and we are elderly and they pushed us outside and refused to take us back with their shuttle to the airport, which was far away.. They were extremely rude, threatening, and nasty and were also doing the same thing to another lady who came before us, she also was refused the car unless she paid for their ridiculous coverage. You really should know about this vendor. They are shady and threatening and really crooked. I have made a charge back on my credit card already with visa to get reimbursed. But they should not be sent anymore business. They are bad humans.

Report
Jorge Avila
Jorge Avila
1 review

Es una porquería de agencia

Es una porquería de agencia Espere casi 2 horas para que me pidieran un montón de requisitos incluyendo que muestres tus redes sociales Me pidieron comprobante de domicilio se los mostré y que no que querían otro más y pues solo traía uno y por esa razón no me restaron el auto Me trataron peor que a un delincuente, No pierdan su tiempo ni hagan corajes de a gratis!!! Busquen otra opción porque esta América car renta es la peor sin duda!!

Report
ASGENG
ASGENG
1 review

Warning

Warning: Would NOT recommend going with this car rental company. When I showed up to pick up my car at SJD airport in Cabo, Eduardo O.F. told me that I needed to pay additional fees and that the price posted on Expedia was not "the real price." They then said I needed to pay the real price which was $100 more and that this was required to rent the car. Since I had already paid in full through Expedia, both for the car rental and extra insurance, and could not walk away (it was offsite at the airport and you needed to take a shuttle), I paid the $100 extra. When I got back home and followed up with Expedia, they said these were optional charges and that I had willingly paid for them. This is fraud. America Car Rental also gave me a car with pre-existing damage and tried to blame it on me when I returned the car. Luckily, I had taken my own videos and could prove it was already there. They were hostile and extremely unprofessional, telling me I couldn't take photos. The single worst car rental experience I ever have had. Furthermore, their automated reply below is not genuine because they are not really interested in "[improving my] experience with [them]" or provide me with "a personalized attention" since both I and Expedia have reached out to them and they refused to "help."

Report
Lisa
Lisa
1 review

Do not recommend America Car Rental

Do not recommend America Car Rental, If I could rate it negative stars I would! First it is not at the Tampa Airport as stated, and then I provided valid insurance (I have progressive a nationwide insurance and on my contract it said purchasing their insurance was optional) through priceline, and when I went to pick up my car they would not accept I had to purchase their insurance for an additional 300.00. Rude, unfriendly employees. This company used to go under Sonic Car Rental I found out and you will see the same type of complaints! Stay AWAY!

Report
Rosa Elena Perez Hernandez

Muy mala experiencia tuvimos con un…

Muy mala experiencia tuvimos con un representante de América Car Rental (Sergio Chavarria) es la persona que nos atendió el día sábado 12 de abril del presente año en la terminal 2 llegamos por Volaris de Tijuana alas 6;30 pm aproximadamente le pedimos un servicio de renta de auto para una Urban éramos 9 personas queríamos 4 días de renta nos dió un precios de 12800 por los 4 días nos pareció un precio justo nos dijo que saliéramos a puerta 8 que ahí pasaría un transporte por nosotros y que le teníamos que dejar una comisión que ya estaba incluida en el precio nos pidió en efectivo 4000 pesos y el resto se pagaría en la oficina le dijimos que si que solo nos acompañará al lugar donde pasarían por nosotros y que ya estando en el transporte le daríamos el efectivo acordado en cuanto llegaron por nosotros le dimos el dinero la compañía donde nos llevaron no fué América Car Rental fué una compañía que está fuera del aeropuerto como a 20 minutos con nombre (Kron Ren Car) y pues al principio todo bien el problema empezó el día de hoy miércoles al entregar la Urban nos querían cobrar un rayón que ya tenía la camioneta y si no pagabamos no nos devolvían el depósito fue un trago amargo que nos hicieron pasar ya al final no nos cobraron porque motramos un vídeo que así estaba el rayón así que no se confíen de cualquier persona renten directo en la página de la agencia que sea de su agrado o la que mejor les convenga no confíen en nadie al llegar al aeropuerto de Cancún una mala experiencia

Report
Martin
Martin
1 review

Warning!!!

Warning!!!! Be careful with this rental company! Especially in Mexico! We rented a car in Cancun for 5 days, when we picked up the car they tried to sell us additional tire and window insurance which we refused to take. On the fourth day my wife went to church when she was going to drive back to our condo she noticed the car had a flat tire so she asked and paid someone to help her put on the spare ( she never drove the car while the tire had a flat) the next day we returned the car and they said the rim was damaged so they had to charge $500 dollars!! Seriously? I would be more than happy to pay for something I did but this is a complete scam!!! Please do your self a favor and don’t do business with these thieves.. Date of experience: March 10, 2025

Report
Armando Flores

Nos asignaron un auto chino blanco

Nos asignaron un auto chino blanco La experiencia muy mal con las llantas en pésimo estado no nos dimos cuenta de las condiciones y con un cinismo nos dijeron una ya tenía chipote pero las demás no. Y luego nos dijeron para que no compraron el seguro de dos mil pesos Las llantas no sirven para Monterrey

Report
Oluwabunmi Ogungbemi

Avoid this company like a plague.Price…

Avoid this company like a plague.Price was too good to be true. Car was an old Chinese make that was not what we asked for but for some reason only uses premium fuel meaning crappy car but expensive to use. We waited 30 minutes in Cancun airport before we were picked up, when we finally got to the office, they didn't have the automatic car we had reserved ready and wanted us to take a manual car. We only have an automatic license, so we had to wait another 45 minutes. The guy at reception was very rude and dismissive and didn't apologise once for their crappy behaviour from the start.

Report

Alternatives to America Car Rental

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.