Skip to main content
Car City logo

Car City reviews & trust report

Car City is an auto dealer operating in Michigan and Indiana, specializing in providing financing solutions for individuals with bad credit, low credit, or no credit. The company offers a diverse inventory of vehicles, including sedans, SUVs, coupes, and trucks, ensuring customers have access to a wide selection to meet their needs. Each vehicle is backed by a 6-month/6,000-mile warranty and a money-back guarantee, reflecting the company's commitment to customer satisfaction. Customers can easily apply for financing through Car City's online platform, which also allows them to view a curated list of vehicles within their approved price range. The company offers flexible shopping options, including the ability to pick up vehicles at one of their many locations or have them delivered directly to their homes within the service areas. Car City aims to simplify the car-buying process for those facing credit challenges, making vehicle ownership more accessible.

www.carcity.com (opens in a new tab)Vehicles & Transportation
Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview526 customer reviews

Car City has a positive customer experience.

Car City receives a mix of feedback from customers, showcasing both commendable service and significant concerns. Many reviewers praise the staff for their helpfulness and dedication, highlighting experiences where employees like Jordan and Brian went above and beyond to facilitate smooth transactions and provide excellent customer service.

Read full summary

However, a substantial number of complaints focus on the quality of the vehicles sold, with customers reporting issues such as receiving damaged cars and ongoing mechanical problems shortly after purchase. Some express frustration over the lack of support from staff once the sale is completed, indicating a disconnect between initial service and post-purchase care.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.2/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 81% happy · 14% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Helpful support
  • Friendly staff

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Warranty
  • Pricing
526 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.2
100%
4.2 / 5 overall
526 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
5.0▲ 4.0
12-month avg
2.2
All-time
4.2
Category avg
4.2
1.02.03.04.05.0Oct 24NovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.2Oct 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewNov 24: 3.0 from 1 reviewDec 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewMar 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewJul 25: 5.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Oct 241.01
Nov 243.01
Dec 241.01
Jan 25—0
Feb 25—0
Mar 251.01
Apr 25—0
May 25—0
Jun 25—0
Jul 255.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 403 positive reviews

  • Customer service25%
    99 mentions
  • Helpful support19%
    75 mentions
  • Friendly staff14%
    57 mentions
  • Fast & efficient10%
    42 mentions
“I did my entire process online and received great customer service more importantly everything was timely”
On “Customer service” · May 29, 2024

Top complaintsof 71 negative reviews

  • Payment issues37%
    26 mentions
  • Warranty18%
    13 mentions
  • Pricing17%
    12 mentions
  • Customer service15%
    11 mentions
“‼️⚠️ stay away from them ‼️⚠️‼️ motor one sold me a car I paid cash it has since been totalled from hail damage and...”
On “Payment issues” · Mar 5, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vehicles & Transportation.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Car City logo
Car City
4.2 out of 5 (good)526
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,999
4.1 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
3.6 out of 5 (good)1,000

Bottom line: Car City is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, BJS Home Delivery scores higher (4.6 vs 2.8).

Reviews

500 reviews of Car City. Filter by what matters to you.

4.2ⓘ

Customer reviews (526)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
James Montgomery

Car City will put you in a vehicle that will kill you!!!…

Car City will put you in a vehicle that will KILL YOU!!! Let me start by saying that I am a Disabled Veteran on a pension. In April of this year,2021,I had gotten a 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude 2.4L from Grand Rapids Michigan Carcity lot delivered to Muskegon Michigan car lot. The driver had to notice the almost out of control shimmering death trap he had delivered. So let me break it down for you...since April of this year 2021. I have had it in the Service Garage 4 times. Each time I came out of pocket. What had pushed me to the edge you ask? Tire blew while my FAMILY WAS IN THE CAR! It blew because the back aliment wore down the inner tire on both sides. I never knew, BUT CARCITY DID AND YET HANDED ME THE KEYS!!! Look,these are brand new tires and still look brand new,except the totally wore down inner tire that on both sides have exposed belts and thin rubber. CARCITY KNEW THIS!!! THEY PUT ME AND MY FAMILY IN THAT DEATH TRAP!!! After contacting Carcity and pretty much being told that I'm on my own on a vehicle that I pay close to $700.00 a month for. These are the kind of people that are monsters. So if your thinking about signing with these people, I encourage you to please protect yourself and your family by not doing so. It's not worth it. Look elsewhere if you value the lives of your family. I almost lost mine...

Report
Daniel Boonstra

Do not go there they cheat you sell U…

Do not go there they cheat you sell U replace with nother car they tell U take it or lose your deposit

Report
Jason Mills
Jason Mills
1 review

The company has a false advertising…

The company has a false advertising campaign, 39 dollars down isnt correct i was told 2000 or no deal

Report
Lea Pionk
Lea Pionk
1 review

TERRIBLE… stuck and stranded far from home

TERRIBLE! My daughter purchased a vehicle the salesman/manager stated they only start their vehicles once a week and the car she was purchasing started a by little rough, so it needed a new battery, but all the fluids were checked and oil changed so she would be good for awhile. She went to this locations service provider and had to make an appointment so she did. Ironically they couldn’t get in for several days. She went to her appt at 9 am… at 6 pm they still hadn’t touched her vehicle and closed leaving my daughter without repair. The manager blamed my daughter because she couldn’t leave it there, knowing she needed a ride home and to pick up her 1 yr old. But offered my daughter gas money because she would have to come up a second time. The alternator was bad… the manager from the service provider that car City sent my daughter To stated to my daughter and I that they were never told about the car over heating or anything and informed her there was no coolant in it. A few days later, the vehicle over heated, tranny skipping, power steering became bad, and wouldn’t run and left her stranded. The manager instructed my daughter to get it to car city so it can be looked at….I called and demanded car city to send a tow truck and the response from the manager/salesperson after telling him where the car was in this small town was 4 times was “I don’t know where that is I need a physical address and the key”. Minutes later I called back and after trying to tell him the requested info..he said a tow truck was on its way. This salesman/manager was rude, unprofessional, not helpful, sarcastic, demeaning, insultive and was caught telling lies several times my daughter wanted to return the car after the first week because it had nothing but problems since she trusted the salesman/manager and left the lot with it. She was told she could not return the vehicle . It took about 3 days to get a rental vehicle to my daughter, another salesman had her sign a paper just because “ you can’t get a service car unless your car was i. The shop, and yours is”. The day after she got the service car , the wheel bearing went out, the tranny stuck in 1st gear and she is stranded with her son 300 miles from home on a Saturday morning 930am . Called the salesman/manager and he was no help… gave a number to the warranty manger Alan and here she is, still waiting on a return call, its Sunday … car won’t start and car city just left her ….I have made contact with the sales person/manager several times, I’ve even called and spoke to managers from other stores…. No help from any of them…. My lawyer is going to have fun with this.

Report
Jeff Schmuker

Over $600 a month for a $6000 dollar…

Over $600 a month for a $6000 dollar vehicle 🚗 enough said. My fiancé got a car with them and she realized she was getting completely ripped off so we left that piece of crap in their Parking lot now they want to garnish her wages. Good luck chuck!!

Report
Toni Spitzer
Toni Spitzer
1 review

Been with Car City since 2017.

Been with Car City since November 2017. Need different vehicle, so traded in one for caravan. June 11,2021. Broke down and was stranded June 18th. Now van needs$850 work and it's in the shop. Perhaps mechanics and dealers need to really know the cars before putting a family in one. In 2017 we first picked a van we took back there very next day and got a Road worthy van. Loved that one. But 2 out of 3 vans have not been ready for the road off that lot. Not sure what i should do.

Report
Nikki Tice
Nikki Tice
1 review

Not again

If i could i would give them no stars. I bought a van and have paid 4 payments and had it like 2 weeks the rest of the time its sat at the shop. Never ever again i dont even want it back. I could go on and on with the problems . All bull****

Report
Dandeniyevijitha

This god car city enjoy the,smart

This god car city enjoy the,smart My experience and my friends experience very fany,

Report
Larelle John
Larelle John
1 review

Why sell a car with problem after…

Why sell a car with problem after problem bought a Mitsubishi sedan for $3000 you had it for 5000 I’m on a pension and it’s had water leak in the hole car you didn’t fix properly had the car for not even 3 months and the gear box went in it now I’m on a bus again because I’m still paying that 3000 dollars loan back and have no car at all it’s a joke how you can sell a car for that price and it didn’t last me that long won’t ever buy a car from car city ever again

Report
mark Collins
mark Collins
1 review

MY MOTOR & GEARBOX ALMOST COMPLETELY FELL OUT OF THE CAR THEY SOLD ME

I bought a used peugeot from smile autos whom operate from within car city in minchinbury nsw , before I bought the car the dealer installed a new clutch & I went over a speed bump about 7 weeks after I bought it & the motor & gearbox almost fell out of the car because the mechanic that fitted the clutch didn't put the nut on the gearbox mount , when the motor dropped it damaged the radiator & drive shaft was torn apart at the cv joint & flung around the engine bay destroying the drive shaft , I contacted the dealer & he said it's not his problem & told me to pis off then he hung up the phone on me , DONT GO ANYWHERE NEAR CAR CITY ESPECIALLY SMILE AUTOS EVERYTHING ABOUT THE PLACE IS DODGY , THEY ARE AN ABSOLUTE DISGRACE,

Report
Christina
Christina
1 review

Customer Service/Poor Vehicle

Customer Service was great. However same day I drive the vehicle home I got a service stablitrak, traction control service light and engine power reducing. Less than 24 hrs from purchase. Took it for an inspection and that shop didn’t go diagnostics but the battery had to be replaced. Have a schedule appointment next for a diagnostic. I’ve only had the car now 6 days. Ironically this was the issue I had with my other car that why I bought another one. Not sure if Car City does any in depth inspections before selling their vehicles. Not a happy customer. Maybe be going through an filing complaints and arbitration. I’m not going 48 months in a lease with a lemon. The reply following this review is a lie. Nobody called me or followed up that reply is a lie. Further evidence that this is a bad place to purchase a car. Tell me what the year make and model I’m referring to is? I have to take my car back to the shop on Friday for a ignition switch problem and who know what else they’ll find. Hopefully nothing. But the fact you said you thought it was resolved is messed up. Not genuine at all. Very disappointed, you should’ve not even replied if you go lie.

Report
kwame shannon

Car City is a HORRIBLE place to shop…

Car City is a HORRIBLE place to shop for a car. They intentionally sold me a car with a bad engine and told me they weren’t fixing it even though they gave me my car with a FULL WARRANTY !. Do not shop here you will waste your money and get ripped off!

Report
Tony Smith
Tony Smith
1 review

car city 3 years ago mistake

Bought a car from car city 3 years ago. While I liked the car the first 4 months I had it it went downhill. It started to leak about a quart of oil per oil change till it started to puke oil out. Turns out that almost every seal had to be replaced which the warranty they offer didnt cover a dime of it. Ps that was about $5000 in repairs alone. 2 years into owning it the radiator started leaking which was another 500$ repair. 2 1/2 years later it started to leak transmission fluid which was about $200 but the warranty finally covered something so it was only $100. Current time it now has a air bag light on which I got an estimate on it for about a $500 repair and my rear defrost stopped working... $300 quote on that. The car was out of comission for a total of 2 months to get fixed( my payment is just shy of $400 a month) it cost me almost $800 for the car to sit and get fixed. I'm not happy at all

Report
Betty Brenner

Worst car place ever

Worst car place ever, theydont care about anything but how money they can scam people out of, their cars are junk and overpriced ,,,,stayed away from them

Report
Wilson
Wilson
1 review

Really disappointed with the management…

Really disappointed with the management of my file. I advanced 200 GBP as a deposit with the garage after accepting the financing of the car. I signed all the necessary documents. In the end, more funding for reasons that are not very clear and, moreover, they don't want to reimburse my deposit. Really not at all serious. I will file a complaint with the competent authorities.

Report
Seth Engler
Seth Engler
1 review

Way to much money a month place is trash

Way to much money a month place is trash

Report
James Pierson

This company is doing false advertising…

This company is doing false advertising it's NOT $39 even tho they say no matter your credit score just income matters they shove it your face with your credit past and make you pay a huge down payment not even worth going too if they lie to the public

Report
P
P
1 review

The ad is 39 dollars down all credit types

The ad is 39 dollars down all credit types but once I applied I was told 2000 down with no explanation of why false advertising

Report
Demetria
Demetria
1 review

Dont get a car from them im pay for a…

Dont get a car from them im pay for a peace of trash 589.75$ is my car note only had the car four months and its been in the shop 3 months and now the car still needs work that there trying to make me pay for did i tell you this is a lease 👎 to car city they put u in cars that don't last your lease time bad move on my part wish i never did it... DON'T DO IT PEOPLE..... My name is Demetria Cope and i was not giving them a star the only way u can post is if u give them at least one ain't that something....

Report
Michelle
Michelle
1 review

Don't ever buy a car here had my car 6…

Don't ever buy a car here had my car 6 days took it in they had it a week said they fixed the problem drove away just to be left stranded they never fixed the problem they sale p.o.s cars now stuck with a car payment on a car not drivable. Haven't even made first payment

Report

Alternatives to Car City

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.