Skip to main content
Fanatics logo

Fanatics reviews & trust report

Fanatics is a leading online retailer specializing in licensed sports merchandise. The company offers a wide range of products, including apparel, accessories, and collectibles for fans of various professional and collegiate sports teams. By partnering with major leagues such as the NFL, NBA, MLB, and NCAA, Fanatics ensures that customers have access to the latest and most popular sports gear available in the market. The primary customers of Fanatics are sports enthusiasts looking to support their favorite teams through high-quality merchandise. The company's user-friendly website, www.fanatics.com, provides a seamless shopping experience, making it easy for fans to find and purchase the products they love. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, Fanatics continues to serve a diverse audience of sports fans across the globe.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview100 customer reviews

Fanatics has a poor customer experience.

Fanatics receives a significant amount of criticism from customers, primarily due to poor customer service and issues with order fulfillment. Many reviewers express frustration over orders being canceled or delayed without clear communication, with some waiting over a month for items that never arrive.

Read full summary

The return policy also garners negative feedback, as customers are often surprised by unexpected fees and unhelpful support when trying to resolve issues. Despite these complaints, a small percentage of consumers appreciate the quality and affordability of certain items, noting that their orders arrived sooner than expected. However, the overwhelming sentiment leans towards dissatisfaction, with many declaring the company unreliable and advising others to avoid it. Overall, Fanatics struggles to meet customer expectations, leading to a predominantly negative perception.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
2.1/ 5
Mostly negative
Recent reviews: 25% happy · 71% unhappy

Best for

  • Fast & efficient
  • Quality
  • Customer service

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Refund
  • Returns
100 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
2.1
100%
2.1 / 5 overall
100 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
2.1
12-month avg
2.1
All-time
2.1
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0May 25JunJul 25Category avg 4.0May 25: 2.7 from 58 reviewsJun 25: 1.2 from 39 reviewsJul 25: 1.0 from 3 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
May 252.758
Jun 251.239
Jul 251.03

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 100 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 25 positive reviews

  • Fast & efficient24%
    6 mentions
  • Quality24%
    6 mentions
  • Customer service20%
    5 mentions
  • Selection16%
    4 mentions
“I love the selection of merchandise and also how fast shipping is”
On “Fast & efficient” · May 31, 2025

Top complaintsof 71 negative reviews

  • Customer service35%
    25 mentions
  • Refund24%
    17 mentions
  • Returns21%
    15 mentions
  • Shipping20%
    14 mentions
“I tried to call the customer service and I met agents that barely speak english and they had no idea why this happens”
On “Customer service” · Jul 4, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Clothing Stores.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Fanatics logo
Fanatics
2.1 out of 5 (poor)100
4.9 out of 5 (good)397
2.0 out of 5 (poor)295
4.9 out of 5 (good)125
3.0 out of 5 (fair)100

Bottom line: Fanatics is #4 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On service, Red Run scores higher (5.0 vs 1.8).

Reviews

100 reviews of Fanatics. Filter by what matters to you.

2.1ⓘ

Customer reviews (100)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
JP
JP
1 review

Bought a set of 2 Cowboys glasses (20…

Bought a set of 2 Cowboys glasses (20 oz). The designs started washing off within the first week. Six months later, in June, I have a crystal clear set of glasses. During the same purchase, I got a single Dallas Mavericks 20oz glass. It looks great!

Report
Austin Turner

I’d give it 0 stars if i could Fanatics…

I’d give it 0 stars if i could Fanatics gave me an offer for $250 fancash if i get 1,000 and did not honor it. This is the third time Fanatics tried to scam me in the year and a half i held an account. Would not recommend to anyone

Report
matthew
matthew
1 review

This shirt is by far the worst quality…

This shirt is by far the worst quality t shirt I own. And I have plenty of t shirts I received for free that are 10+ years old and are much better quality. The red sox text is so small across the chest. It looks ridiculous. MLB needs to go back to majestic.

Report
customer
customer
1 review

Are they fraudsters?

No idea who this company but I am getting emails from them about an account I didn’t set up. Their chatbot doesn’t work, their customer services email doesn’t accept emails and their UK number is closed at 11am on a Friday saying ‘call back during working hours’. Are they associated with fraud? I’ve asked them via email and site to remove my email from their servers and confirm I have no account or liability for payments but everything bounces back. I have no way to reach them. This is either fraud or honestly the worst communications framework I’ve seen in decades.

Report
Elias Salim Cachoua

Realice un pedido el dia 13 de mayo y…

Realice un pedido el dia 13 de mayo y se supone que me debió llegar el dia de ayer. No hay forma de contactar a la gente de servicio al cliente y además cuando me meto a checar donde esta mi pedido me sale que esta en el mismo lugar desde que hice el pedido

Report
Leon
Leon
1 review

Said 2 Business Days for shipping on…

Said 2 Business Days for shipping on the pay page. Billed my CC. Get an email saying it would be 29 days. Contacted them to cancel. and they would not do it. Have to wait for items, then ship back to them before the refund is issued. Brutal.

Report
berradia
berradia
1 review

colis saisi a la douane

colis saisi a la douane , la boutique ne reponds pas au email puis injoignable par tchat et tel

Report
Honey Issweet

My autistic son ordered a large order…

My autistic son ordered a large order of stuff almost $300 from this fraud of a company without me knowing it and when I saw the notification early the next morning, I immediately tried to cancel it and I chatted, chatted, chatted, chatted and chatted and spoke to multiple people and they all gave me a different response. When I call two of their incompetent CSR and told both I needed to cancel the order and they asked for the information and I provided it to them and they both said that the order was canceled, they both lied, it wasn’t canceled! This is a company that needs to be brought down/forced to go under! Taking advantage of people and lying about what they are doing and know they are not doing as they told the customer! This company doesn’t deserve one star!

Report
Brian Ferebee

Damaged Signed Photo

I purchased a signed photo from Fanatics’ website. It took too long for it to get to me, and when it did get here it was damaged. There are multiple permanent creases in the photo. Of course it was packaged in a thin flexible envelope with no padding or protection. When I reached out to customer service, they said that it was a different department that handles signed memorabilia and they close at 4:30pm. This whole process has been disappointing. Updated Fanatics reached out to me to let me know that I could return the signed picture, but they were now out of replacements. I was also going to have to pay for shipping to send the picture back to them and I would not receive a 100% refund. And, the refund would take weeks after they receive the memorabilia back. What in the world is going on at Fanatics? They did not resolve the issue.

Report
Dora Stanich
Dora Stanich
1 review

Fanatics does not easily allow for a RETURN!!!!

Fanatics does not easily allow for a return. Too many hoops to jump through, too many rules. Once your item has been delivered it is no longer on the site as an order number. Entering the order number is the only way to print out a "return label"!!!!!!!!! CHEATERS.

Report
Natalie Karimi

Ich habe einen der Titelgürtel bestellt…

Ich habe einen der Titelgürtel bestellt für über 500 Euro. Der Versand war ebenfalls nochmal um die 30 Euro, heute kommt das Teil an, in einem total verbeulten Karton (klar da kann der Shop erstmal nichts für) allerdings ist dieses teuere, schwere Teil nur in einem dünnen Stoff und einer Folie eingewickelt. Das kann doch nicht deren Ernst sein? Kein Geld für Posterpapier oder so? Der Gipfel ist, sowohl der Chat als auch die email Kontakt Aufnahme geht nicht wegen „Fehler“ und „Inaktivität“ lächerlich echt.

Report
gianluca rossi

Fatti diversi ordini

Fatti diversi ordini, almeno 3 tutti i pacchi sino andati persi,non consegnati. mi hanno contattato ma sempre 3/4 giorni dopo per mail. Non esiste un numero di telefono non esiste una chat (non funziona mai) non esiste un codice sconto (non funziona) insomma ti costringono a acquistare da altre parti. Non consigliato al 100% state alla larga

Report
Maxime
Maxime
1 review

Par quoi commencer ?

Par quoi commencer ?! N’acheter pas sur ce site. En cas de problème, impossible de contacter le service client. Le numéro de téléphone ne fonctionne pas, le chat en ligne est inopérant et je n'ai reçu aucune réponse suite à mes demande envoyée via le formulaire de contact. Je commence sérieusement à me demander si je ne suis pas victime d'une arnaque !! Ma femme a réceptionné ma commande en même temps que d'autres colis. Lorsque j'ai ouvert le mien, j'ai immédiatement remarqué son poids anormalement léger. En l'ouvrant, j'ai eu la désagréable surprise de constater qu'il était complètement vide. Il s'agissait d'une commande pour le GP de Barcelone et j’ai dû racheter les maillots sur place. Perte de temps et d’argent et aucun DAV de la part de Fanatics, scandaleux. J’aurais dû regarder les avis plus tôt

Report
MK
MK
1 review

Worse company ever They cancel orders…

Worse company ever They cancel orders out of the blue without checking first with the customer Terrible customer service with hours and hours in queue It’s so bad

Report
Avocat
Avocat
1 review

Commande passée pour deux articles.

Commande passée pour deux articles. Ils arrivent séparément avec plusieurs jours de décalage et le short étant bien trop grand je décide de le renvoyer. En violation de toutes les lois françaises et européennes sur la vente à distance et notamment sur le droit à rétractation ils font payer le retour 12,50 euros. Mais le pire c'est qu'une fois que vous avez payé cette somme et retourné l'article, plus d'un mois plus tard toujours pas de remboursement... Bref des escrocs. Leur pdg est connu pour sa fête en blanc dans les hamptons et en achetant sur son site vous ne faites rien d'autre que financer ses frasques. Fuyez.

Report
kimberly mitchell

My husband bought us shirts

My husband bought us shirts, blanket, hats, and sweatshirts. We wore them once and washed (in cold) the shirts look so bad you cannot wear them. The ink is faded/ washing off. Very disappointed and to expensive for that to happen. Well they contacted me and said they will refund my money. Fingers crossed they want to make this right. Still no refund. I need to find a new place to buy from.

Report
Justin Swink
Justin Swink
1 review

Merchandise

Trash. Will never order from them again. Ordered ahead of time and still got shafted would I recommend them hell no. Not for any product. Not to mention they send email like their offering me some big discount for my inconvenience and it's the same code their using for a complete 25% off with busch code. LMFAO. Pathetic complete and utter failure on this company to get any future business from me or my family

Report
Chris
Chris
1 review

Quality at its lowest level even for…

Quality at its lowest level even for the £105 premium jersey. Be warned, two failed jerseys and now I’m just stuck with it within 5months of ownership. My girlfriend order me a jersey from fanatics for Christmas, received it and opened it to realise that the jersey number was peeling. I got in contact with fanatics who said they wouldn’t send me a new one as a replacement, but they would refund if I sent mine back and I had to order again through the website. This meant that the discounted price we originally paid was gone (40% off), we had to order at full price (they did offer 25% discount code after I pushed for it) if we wanted a new one for an issue of their quality, other companies would just have us send the other back and send a new one, this was not the case so I ended up paying more. I now have the new one I paid more money for and after its first wash at the exact recommendation on the garment of 30 degrees C inside out, the name on the back of the jersey has faded and colour smudged. As this was after the 45days since I ordered they have nothing to offer in terms of a replacement or full refund if I send it back. I’m just left so shocked by this quality and practice and will never pay for anything from fanatics again. Shame on the NFL and Fanatics for letting this be how they do business.

Report
Georgina Scott

Fraudulent seller

I've been buying from them the past 2 years for my Villa merchandise. They had an away sale in March so I ordered a Marco Asensio shirt. It's on the site pre-printed and I didn't add anything to it. Arrived and was way too small for a ladies 2xl - also had a dirty mark on it. I tried to start a returns process but was told I can't return a "personalised" item? I didn't personalise it though - I just ordered what was advertised. £55 down the drain for a top I can't wear. Would give minus 5 stars if I could as I've been totally cheated on this purchase. My advice? Don't use them!

Report
Amy Mandelbaum

THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE …

THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE AND REFUND POLICY. DO NOT BUY FROM THIS WEBSITE. Purchased a jersey for my husband, they sent the wrong size. I returned it and took a gift card as refund because I was reordering in the correct size. Correct size came and was made poorly. Returned for a full refund and got a gift card. I did not request a gift card. I requested a full refund, they refuse. I am now stuck with a $200+ gift card and no one will speak with me or respond to me from Fanatics. I HIGHLY advise potential customers to avoid this site. Poor quality and AWFUL customer service and return policy.

Report

Alternatives to Fanatics

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.