Fanatics is a leading online retailer specializing in licensed sports merchandise. The company offers a wide range of products, including apparel, accessories, and collectibles for fans of various professional and collegiate sports teams. By partnering with major leagues such as the NFL, NBA, MLB, and NCAA, Fanatics ensures that customers have access to the latest and most popular sports gear available in the market.
The primary customers of Fanatics are sports enthusiasts looking to support their favorite teams through high-quality merchandise. The company's user-friendly website, www.fanatics.com, provides a seamless shopping experience, making it easy for fans to find and purchase the products they love. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, Fanatics continues to serve a diverse audience of sports fans across the globe.
Fanatics receives a significant amount of criticism from customers, primarily due to poor customer service and issues with order fulfillment. Many reviewers express frustration over orders being canceled or delayed without clear communication, with some waiting over a month for items that never arrive.
Read full summaryShow less
The return policy also garners negative feedback, as customers are often surprised by unexpected fees and unhelpful support when trying to resolve issues. Despite these complaints, a small percentage of consumers appreciate the quality and affordability of certain items, noting that their orders arrived sooner than expected. However, the overwhelming sentiment leans towards dissatisfaction, with many declaring the company unreliable and advising others to avoid it. Overall, Fanatics struggles to meet customer expectations, leading to a predominantly negative perception.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
★
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
2.1
100
100%
● Low
2.1 / 5 overall
=
100 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.
Last 3 months
2.1
12-month avg
2.1
All-time
2.1
Category avg
4.0
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
May 25
2.7
58
Jun 25
1.2
39
Jul 25
1.0
3
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 100 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 25 positive reviews
Fast & efficient24%
6 mentions
Quality24%
6 mentions
Customer service20%
5 mentions
Selection16%
4 mentions
“I love the selection of merchandise and also how fast shipping is”
On “Fast & efficient” · May 31, 2025
Top complaintsof 71 negative reviews
Customer service35%
25 mentions
Refund24%
17 mentions
Returns21%
15 mentions
Shipping20%
14 mentions
“I tried to call the customer service and I met agents that barely speak english and they had no idea why this happens”
On “Customer service” · Jul 4, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Clothing Stores.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
I love the selection of merchandise and also how fast shipping is. My only complaint is that I ordered a custom Jersey, and the item is defective. The sleeves are way too short and tight, to the point where the Jersey is unwearable. Unfortunately, custom items and items with tags removed cannot be returned. So I'm stuck with a $140 Jersey that I can't wear.
Quality at its lowest level even for the £105 premium jersey.
Be warned, two failed jerseys and now I’m just stuck with it within 5months of ownership.
My girlfriend order me a jersey from fanatics for Christmas, received it and opened it to realise that the jersey number was peeling. I got in contact with fanatics who said they wouldn’t send me a new one as a replacement, but they would refund if I sent mine back and I had to order again through the website. This meant that the discounted price we originally paid was gone (40% off), we had to order at full price (they did offer 25% discount code after I pushed for it) if we wanted a new one for an issue of their quality, other companies would just have us send the other back and send a new one, this was not the case so I ended up paying more.
I now have the new one I paid more money for and after its first wash at the exact recommendation on the garment of 30 degrees C inside out, the name on the back of the jersey has faded and colour smudged. As this was after the 45days since I ordered they have nothing to offer in terms of a replacement or full refund if I send it back.
I’m just left so shocked by this quality and practice and will never pay for anything from fanatics again. Shame on the NFL and Fanatics for letting this be how they do business.
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
I've been buying from them the past 2 years for my Villa merchandise. They had an away sale in March so I ordered a Marco Asensio shirt. It's on the site pre-printed and I didn't add anything to it.
Arrived and was way too small for a ladies 2xl - also had a dirty mark on it. I tried to start a returns process but was told I can't return a "personalised" item? I didn't personalise it though - I just ordered what was advertised. £55 down the drain for a top I can't wear.
Would give minus 5 stars if I could as I've been totally cheated on this purchase. My advice? Don't use them!
THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE AND REFUND POLICY. DO NOT BUY FROM THIS WEBSITE.
Purchased a jersey for my husband, they sent the wrong size. I returned it and took a gift card as refund because I was reordering in the correct size. Correct size came and was made poorly. Returned for a full refund and got a gift card. I did not request a gift card. I requested a full refund, they refuse. I am now stuck with a $200+ gift card and no one will speak with me or respond to me from Fanatics. I HIGHLY advise potential customers to avoid this site. Poor quality and AWFUL customer service and return policy.
order the wrong shoes by mistake Philadelphia eagles women's shoes less than an hour after I ordered the shoes. I realized they was women. They told me that they had to ship the shoes to my house. That's ridiculous. The shoes did not leave the warehouse for two days later, this is the worst worst company in the world 🌎 I would never ever ever order anything Else from this brain dead company , I will go to there competitors It really don't make no sense. The policies must change. This is definitely the worst company I ever dealt with in my life. I am 58 years old. No one from my friends my family my eight children would never ever order from fanatics. The name said at all crazy ass company
Edit: since they even replied as if they didnt read this - you can see for yourself the lack of critical thinking. Nobody would shop there again after this experience. And yeah you refunded my money because you failed to send me a shirt without a hole in it 7 different times. Your coupon is not adequate.
These people are idiots. For real. You have to know what you are doing to be this stupid.
I order a shirt. They send me one that has been pressed into their shipping bag, causing it to be ripped at the bottom.
They tell me to send it back for replacement.
A week later, they email me and cancel my order saying the shirt is out of stock. No apology, no explanation, nothing.
Then 3 supervisors tell me they actually do have one available.
3 different times they cancel my order again automatically.
After 3 months, they receive another shipment, don't follow through on anything they've promised me, and their support refuses to honor their coupon for all this and lies and tells me she can't let me speak to a supervisor.
After being rude enough that the customer service let's me speak to a supervisor, because the only way to get them to do anything is to literally yell, while they tell you to stop, but actually do what you asked finally. Ridiculously stupid.
And after all that, they send me a shirt with the exact same rip in it.
Either you ruined all your shirts the same way or you intentionally did all of this and sent me back the same one you had ruined.
Eff you. Your company is the worst and you deserve to go under completely.
There are independent people who sell merchandise. Fanatics is too stupid to do it well despite having billions of dollars and all the licenses that nobody else has. Incredible how incompetent this company is.
ATTENTION ARNAQUE!
Attention a ce site se sont de purs charlatan et sans doute une escriquerie se cache derriere tout ca. Jai passé commande sur leur site et dans un premier temps je nai recu aucun colis alors que le suivi indiqué colis livré a l'adresse, je l'ai ai donc contacté par mail et au bout de nombreux message de ma part il me repondent en disant que le colis a ete déposé dans un point relais, je m'y rend et je trouve effectivement un colis a mon nom... En arrivant chez moi suprise le colis est complètement vide !
Je demande des explications, on me pretexte une enquête et de patienter au bout d'une semaine on me dit : "le transporteur confirme que les articles etaient bien a l'intérieur du colis, donc aucun remboursement possible, au revoir" suite a quoi je leurs demandent des preuves qui bien entendu n'arriverons jamais.
Bref, j ai porté plainte contre eux, une enquete va etre ouverte pour escroquerie et je me suis rapproché de ma banque pour chargeback.
SURTOUT FUYEZ ! Grosse ARNAQUE !!
Fanatics is a great Company, an all the clothes I purchased, for my Friend, He lives them...The Quality is very nice, an wash up nice too. You need to order there clothes an apparel...very nice!!!
Ein Stern ist leider noch zu viel für diesen Laden!
In diesem Leben werde ich dort nicht mehr bestellen!
Inkompetenz trifft auf arrogante Dreistigkeit bei Retouren und Rückzahlungen. Bestellt lieber anderswo.
Ordered a cubs shirt for an early gift for Father's Day because we were making a trip to see the cubs play in Ohio. Well the shirt was returned to the company because the delivery truck couldn't deliver. (Never heard of them) so I contacted customer service they put my order back in with free 2 day so I would get it by our departure date. Never received it. It was returned AGAIN because the person in customer service did something wrong. So while talking to the last customer service person they said I could reorder it they could not. They offered me 30% coupon fir my trouble.like I will never use this company again. So I told them I wanted a full refund and I wanted a supervisor to call me tomorrow so unfortunately my husband will not have the new shirt I wanted him to wear to the game.
Fanatics is a leading online retailer specializing in licensed sports merchandise. The company offers a wide range of products, including apparel, accessories, and collectibles for fans of various professional and collegiate sports teams. By partnering with major leagues such as the NFL, NBA, MLB, and NCAA, Fanatics ensures that customers have access to the latest and most popular sports gear available in the market.
The primary customers of Fanatics are sports enthusiasts looking to support their favorite teams through high-quality merchandise. The company's user-friendly website, www.fanatics.com, provides a seamless shopping experience, making it easy for fans to find and purchase the products they love. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, Fanatics continues to serve a diverse audience of sports fans across the globe.