Total Cards is a leading online retailer specializing in trading cards, board games, and collectibles. Established in 2012, the company has built a reputation for providing a wide variety of card games, including popular titles such as Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and more. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Total Cards offers over 20,000 reviews and has sold more than 1 million cards, indicating a strong presence in the gaming community.
The company's product range extends beyond trading cards to include accessories like premium sleeves and deck boxes, as well as a selection of LEGO sets, puzzles, and Funko Pops. Total Cards caters to gaming enthusiasts of all ages, ensuring a diverse inventory that meets the interests of both casual players and serious collectors. With convenient features like next-day delivery and free UK shipping on orders over £20, Total Cards aims to provide a seamless shopping experience for its customers.
Total Cards receives a mixed reception from customers, with a significant number expressing dissatisfaction. While some reviewers commend the fantastic service and quick delivery, noting excellent packaging and prompt responses to issues, the majority report serious problems with order fulfillment.
Read full summaryShow less
Many customers experience canceled orders under questionable circumstances, delayed pre-orders, and a lack of communication regarding stock availability. Complaints about inflated prices and poor handling of Pokémon TCG products are prevalent, with some labeling the company as "scammers." Additionally, issues with the trade-in process and refusal of returns further contribute to the negative sentiment. Overall, while there are positive experiences, the overwhelming number of complaints about order management and pricing leads to a predominantly negative view of Total Cards.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
★
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
2.3
85
100%
+0.5
● Medium
2.3 / 5 overall
=
85 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Nov 2025.
Last 3 months
2.8▲ 0.5
12-month avg
2.1
All-time
2.3
Category avg
4.0
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Dec 24
3.0
4
Jan 25
1.6
7
Feb 25
1.3
3
Mar 25
1.0
9
Apr 25
1.7
11
May 25
3.3
8
Jun 25
2.6
16
Jul 25
1.0
4
Aug 25
—
0
Sep 25
2.3
3
Oct 25
2.0
4
Nov 25
5.0
2
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 85 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 25 positive reviews
Delivery48%
12 mentions
Customer service48%
12 mentions
Fast & efficient44%
11 mentions
Prices & value36%
9 mentions
“Fantastic service, quick email response to a problem while ordering and then quick delivery with the product being ve...”
On “Delivery” · Nov 27, 2025
Top complaintsof 59 negative reviews
Customer service34%
20 mentions
Refund32%
19 mentions
Payment issues25%
15 mentions
Pricing24%
14 mentions
“Placed an order this evening only to have it cancelled on the false pretence that I had put in a cancellation request...”
On “Customer service” · Oct 8, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Electronics & Technology.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
They're scalpers with a shop. 10 days after Prismatic Evolutions releases they've got booster packs up for £9.95, presumably ripped from boxes that should've been sold to customers at RRP.
Scum of the earth, genuinely the worst TCG shop I've ever dealt with.
Almost 3 months and no order. Bad customer service
I ordered an "in stock" skeledirge premium collection and a paldean fates tin for Black Friday (way back in Nov 2024). I have been told many times they are "expecting stock in", but have had to chase constantly. No attempt at a resolution and Ryan in customer care stops replying as soon as you refuse store credit or to wait.
My product still shows as in stock for in store pickup, so why can't they fulfill the order? Still awaiting a response to that question or a refund. I'd be willing to change this review to reflect their actions should there be any.
I along with many others had a delayed Surging Sparks order having ordered 6 booster boxes on 2nd October (a month before release) and eventually receiving a week ago.
Although incredibly frustrating, I can’t fault the customer service from Ryan, responding to emails in good time even though there were little updates available. I have bought from Total Cards many times before and always had a good experience with them and so kept my pre order active.
All in all other than being delayed, which was out of their control, my order was not cancelled and it arrived at the price original paid for it (under £100 a box) although market price had rocketed.
Essentially doing what they should do, in an environment where many others are not.
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
With the current demand situation with prismatic evolution, this company is showing out of stock on their site,
Yet are using stock to sell on a live platform called what not for double/triple the amount.
Terrible exploitation from a business
Yes I'm another customer who placed a pre order that waited two months, missed out on a major Xmas present and ended up cancelling the order. This is the second time a pre order has not been delivered. Other sites have the item in stock. They probably raise revenue through orders they can not fulfill. Never order a pre order.
Disappointed their email didn't even apologise when they said they were processing a refund. Emailed them a week ago simply saying "The moment they arrive, we will ensure they are shipped out to you as quickly as possible."
Do they ever arrive one wonders.
Do not use.
These used to be alright but have recently degraded sadly. I've made dozens of orders with them but I won't be ordering anymore.
They regularly oversell products that they don't and won't have stock for so you end up waiting weeks if not months or infinitely for a delivery when you pre-ordered a product months before it's release.
The final straw for me is I now have orders with Total Cards with products that they claim to have in stock, and yet have been sitting unfulfilled for several weeks. I just can't trust this store to actually deliver on orders I make with them. I'd rather pay a little more elsewhere.
They've also started some rather predatory practices - if you look at their stock of new and highly demanded expansions for Pokemon, such as Prismatic Evolutions, you will notice they only sell them bundled with other products. They are using peoples demands for this expansion to sell off stock of other less-wanted products.
It's completely unacceptable. @TotalCards I would recommend you stop selling products you don't have, or hire more staff to fulfill the orders for products you do have if backlogs are literal weeks long.
Discusting, I pre ordered a Terapagos upc October 19th. Over lots of messages with Ryan, Alex and another it's obvious one doesn't check with the other before messaging. In the end I have ended up with no upc which was ment to be for Christmas. From seeing other comments this is a re-ocuring trait. To further from this clearly can see no respect for pre-order customers. But the worst is they lied about refund time in an email from Ryan I was told 3-5 days then an automated email saying 10 days then Alex tried to pass the blame onto bank processing.
I ordered a product from this company, to give as a christmas gift. I ordered this item (that was not cheap) on 23rd November. The website stated it was released in December. After not receiving any communication of dispatch, I decided to email them to ensure my order was received. It was then that they decided to tell me there was a delay in them receiving this item and they were hoping it will be received at some point in those first 2 weeks in December. I didn't think it was a problem, as these things do happen. But again, after no notification, I had to chase them again. Only for them to say they are still waiting. This time I requested they please keep me updated, as this is meant to be a gift and I needed to know if it would arrive in time. They did nothing.
I had to chase everytime, so I raised a complaint.
I wasnt able to give this product as a gift at christmas, in fact the individual got nothing apart from an apology and me having to explain it should be arriving soon
It is now 29th December, I see no hope in this product arriving this month!
I have requested a full refund now, so we will see if they are able to do that or show how truly incompetent they are.
I have gone on to order this product elsewhere, where funnily enough, it has already arrived (and was cheaper) and have given it to the individual who's gift it was, apologetically.
In future I recommend Total Cards make it very clear on their website that delays can occur, which are out of their control, but should state they will do everything in their power to ensure this does not happen.
The most frustrating thing has been the poor communication. Emails should be issued to those people whose orders are affected. Even if it is a generic email and only advises they are still waiting. Any communication is better than none. This will also likely reduce the amount of complaints they receive. Which I have investigated and looks as though they get a lot, but down play it on websites, such as this. As you can see from the top of the page, they are showing misleading information and the star rating may not be correct. I can tell you now. There are a lot more complaints with this company than they show!
Total cards are just awesome, they always deliver quickly, even at busy times like Christmas, prices are competitive, and they always package everything with that little extra care and usually throw in a tiny little bonus too.
I pre-ordered a Prismatic Evolutions Elite Trainer Box from Total Cards and received an order number and order confirmation.
Subsequently, without any further communication, Total Cards cancelled my pre-order and issued a refund notification.
According to the refund notification, I now have to wait for up to 10 days for the refund to appear in my account.
I can only assume that they are overselling or planning to sell at inflated prices after release.
Be careful who you place pre-orders with.
These guys are really good. The prices are good, the service is amazing and they respond to all messages and emails super quickly. I now look at them over other providers who dont seem to be able to ship and cope during busy periods. I have placed several successive orders after the first one.
pre-ordered 6 booster boxes of the new Pokémon set and still have not received the item. I got a reply 6 days ago stating they had received stock and will get it out as soon as possible. Altogether it has been 10 days since release and still not received the item. I have spent a lot of money on this and now looking to cancel the order.
Pre-ordered 2 booster boxes of the new Pokemon set Surging Sparks. They arrived 4 days after release date but that wasn’t such a big issue for me. The issue was both boxes arrived damaged with big slits to the seal, one with a crushed corner. Not sure how/why there were slits on both but I can’t recommend this site for sealed collectors. Packaging wasn’t great - boxes were stacked on top of each other with almost no protection.
Do not use for enticingly priced pre-orders. Not enough ordered to fulfil commitments and no estimate for delivery despite the set being released in every shop 4 days ago.
Pre ordered the new Pokémon set for release and delivery on the 8th November. Today is the 9th with no sign of the item or any communication from total cards a with a reason or expected delivery day.
Very very frustrating considering I can't cancel the order and buy it elsewhere as I used Klana 3 pay and have already paid 2 out of 3 payments! Will not be using total cards for pre-orders in the future which is a shame as had good experiences up to this point.
*Edit
Changed to a 3* as I have now received my product. Can't give more as the least I'd expect for a pre-order is to get the item on release day!
Careful with mixing other products with pre orders!
I had ordered some card sleeves to go along with the new Yu-gi-oh set that was for pre order and it turns out total cards was withholding the order as the sleeves were on backorder and not in stock so my order got delayed which i only found out through their customer support which was incredibly helpful and i asked to have them replaced with other sleeves in stock so they could ship it asap which they did!
Thank you Ryan at Total Cards for sorting this out for me, I'll be back again for sure!
Replied to an 'in stock' email and got a response!
Replied to an 'in stock' email that wasn't in stock with some snarky comment and actually got a reply from Ryan, monitoring the inbox... Thanks Ryan, I take back my grumpy Monday morning attitude.
Pre-ordered a MTG product in March, for release in June, but the product never arrived. I've chased for months but never had a firm answer on whether I'd actually receive the product. I can't cancel and order from another company now as the price has almost doubled since the initial order date in March.
I can't recommend Total Cards to anyone and I won't be using them again as I've had much better service from other providers.
I ordered some Pokémon collection boxes and when they arrived they were not as described on the web site. They wanted me to pay for the return postage, even though the product was mis-advertised. They finally agreed to pay for return postage but gave me an invalid return postage label. I am still trying to get this resolved. They make it very difficult to get hold of someone by phone and seem to hide contact details on their web site. This is not how a honest and transparent company should be doing business in my opinion and not a good customer experience. I will not be using them again.
Total Cards is a leading online retailer specializing in trading cards, board games, and collectibles. Established in 2012, the company has built a reputation for providing a wide variety of card games, including popular titles such as Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and more. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Total Cards offers over 20,000 reviews and has sold more than 1 million cards, indicating a strong presence in the gaming community.
The company's product range extends beyond trading cards to include accessories like premium sleeves and deck boxes, as well as a selection of LEGO sets, puzzles, and Funko Pops. Total Cards caters to gaming enthusiasts of all ages, ensuring a diverse inventory that meets the interests of both casual players and serious collectors. With convenient features like next-day delivery and free UK shipping on orders over £20, Total Cards aims to provide a seamless shopping experience for its customers.