Skip to main content
Effy Jewelry logo

Effy Jewelry reviews & trust report

Effy Jewelry is a U.S.-based jewelry manufacturer and retailer, specializing in handcrafted pieces that blend artistic design with quality craftsmanship. With over three decades of experience, the company offers a diverse range of jewelry, including rings, necklaces, and bracelets, catering to customers seeking unique and meaningful gifts for various occasions. The brand is particularly popular among individuals looking to express their sentiments through jewelry, whether for special occasions like Valentine's Day or for everyday wear. Effy Jewelry emphasizes the importance of family and community in its operations, ensuring that each piece reflects a commitment to creativity and excellence. Customers can explore a variety of collections, including new arrivals and themed gift guides, on their website at www.effyjewelry.com.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview108 customer reviews

Effy Jewelry has a positive customer experience.

Effy Jewelry receives a mix of praise and criticism from its customers. Many reviewers appreciate the beautiful selection of rings and the helpfulness of staff like Conquela, who is frequently mentioned for her exceptional service.

Read full summary

Positive experiences highlight the quality of the jewelry and prompt customer service responses, with some customers noting successful resolutions to their issues. However, a significant number of complaints focus on product quality, with several consumers reporting stones falling off rings shortly after purchase. Additionally, frustrations arise from poor customer service experiences, including unresponsive communication and difficulties in processing returns. Overall, while Effy Jewelry has its advocates, the concerns regarding product durability and customer support cannot be overlooked.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
3.6/ 5
Mostly positive
Polarized: 63% happy · 34% unhappy
Momentum · 6 months
-15%
Declining vs the 6 months before · was 3.8

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Helpful support
  • Quality

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Pricing
  • Returns
108 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
3.6
100%
3.6 / 5 overall
108 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Aug 2025.

Last 3 months
2.7▼ 1.0
12-month avg
3.6
All-time
3.6
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Sep 24OctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJulAug 25Category avg 4.0Sep 24: 3.8 from 24 reviewsOct 24: 3.0 from 10 reviewsNov 24: 3.5 from 6 reviewsDec 24: 4.1 from 7 reviewsJan 25: 2.8 from 5 reviewsFeb 25: 4.8 from 13 reviewsMar 25: 4.2 from 6 reviewsApr 25: 3.7 from 7 reviewsMay 25: 3.5 from 10 reviewsJun 25: 3.2 from 12 reviewsJul 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewAug 25: 2.1 from 7 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Sep 243.824
Oct 243.010
Nov 243.56
Dec 244.17
Jan 252.85
Feb 254.813
Mar 254.26
Apr 253.77
May 253.510
Jun 253.212
Jul 251.01
Aug 252.17

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 108 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 68 positive reviews

  • Customer service34%
    23 mentions
  • Helpful support21%
    14 mentions
  • Quality18%
    12 mentions
  • Website & app15%
    10 mentions
“I had an issue with my ring and their customer service was amazing”
On “Customer service” · Aug 22, 2025

Top complaintsof 37 negative reviews

  • Customer service41%
    15 mentions
  • Pricing32%
    12 mentions
  • Returns30%
    11 mentions
  • Payment issues27%
    10 mentions
“Very disappointed in how this reputable company handled this transaction, very bad, I would not recommend to buy jewe...”
On “Customer service” · Aug 28, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Jewelry.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Effy Jewelry logo
Effy Jewelry
3.6 out of 5 (good)108
1.3 out of 5 (poor)1,000
2.9 out of 5 (fair)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)397
2.6 out of 5 (poor)368

Bottom line: Effy Jewelry is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Red Run scores higher (4.9 vs 2.1).

Reviews

108 reviews of Effy Jewelry. Filter by what matters to you.

3.6ⓘ

Customer reviews (108)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
How CrowdTrust scores reviews

Polarized pattern: few middle ratings. 63% of recent reviews are 4–5★ and 34% are 1–2★.

pj
pj
1 review
Featured

Refuse to value any free items they give

After returning from a cruise and having spent 10k on multiple pieces of jewelry we realized we only got a receipt not a replacement value or appraisal. We reached out and got an appraisal for all but two items. They had provided two free items to us and initially said they didn't sell them, but they are clearly listed on their website not a huge value (probably around 400 for both pieces) but why refuse to provide an appraisal or retail value on the pieces? Are they that ashamed of the free times they give out? We had planned to join their private cruise and purchase additional jewelry but now will probably reconsider.

Report
Catherine Tipton

Do not trust Effy with their promises

I purchased a ring on my first cruise. I was able to wear it for 10 days before a stone fell out. They replaced the stone and I had it back in 6 weeks. I was able to wear it for 8 days, and then another stone fell out. They took 3.5 months to repair it. They said the problem was when it was sized, it is heated and that loosens the stones so they had to make another one. They also said they were going to refund me $200. I received the ring back about 6 weeks ago and have not had any issues yet. However I still have not received the refund I was promised in December. I have contacted the company and the only response I received was that they escalated it.

Report
Hockeypuck
Hockeypuck
1 review

We have learned our lesson

We have learned our lesson, but the very worst place to purchase jewelry is on a cruise ship. The hard sell and persistence of sales associates, and bringing out the almighty calculator, should be a sign to walk away.

Report
Palm Beach
Palm Beach
1 review

Poor response from EFFY NY

I've been purchasing EFFY jewelry for a number of years. Recently, I received my gemstone bracelet loose inside a plastic zip bag. I emailed EFFY New York and asked if they would send a felt pouch or if I could purchase a pouch for my bracelet. I received an email from EFFY stating that they do not sell the pouches and no, I could not receive one. Spending my money on a gemstone bracelet only to receive it inside a plastic bag was one insult, but for EFFY to respond with a closed door made me decide to stop buying from EFFY.

Report
K L
K L
1 review

I purchased an Effy watercolor bracelet…

I purchased an Effy watercolor bracelet on a cruise. The first time I wore it, the clasp came undone. I sent it back for Repair, and it was basically returned in the same condition. The clasp was a box clasp. It would not snap shut and would fall out and the safety on the side was very flimsy and would not stay closed. I sent it back a second time and a safety chain was added. The clasp tongue was very thin and would not stay shut. I called Effy and they told me they would give me a Cash credit towards a new purchase but the price had doubled, and they were only gonna give me back a credit for the price I paid. There was not much I could purchase at that price so I took it to a real jeweler who couldn’t believe that Effy would not fix that clasp. The jeweler told me that the tongue was too thin and it would not hold so they rebuilt the clasp and added two figure 8 safeties on the side that snap shut perfectly. I am very disappointed that Effy would sell a beautiful piece of jewelry with a crappy clasp.

Report
Michelle
Michelle
1 review

Lost Ring During Resizing and Non Responsive Afterward

I love the jewelry I have bought from Effy - it is beautiful! My complaint is with the service department. I mailed two rings in for resizing and followed the instructions. I received an email with shipping info for one of them. I called to inquire about the other ring and was told they were shipped together. The second ring did not arrive so I called. After being transferred several times, I was told someone would call me back. They emailed instead and said my ring would be mailed. Again, it never arrived. I called again and was told that my ring could not be located. It was finally sent back to me and had not been sized. I emailed 6-8 times and never received a response. I completed the contact form and have now received a label to ship it back again. Fingers crossed that I see my ring again!

Report
Happytrails
Happytrails
1 review

Stones keep falling out

My husband purchased a Effy diamond ring from Belk. I was washing my hands and noticed a diamond missing and fortunately found it in the sink. My husband returned it to Belk and it was sent for repair. It had to be sent back to the company and it took a good while to get it back and we were charged about 400.00 for the repair. No problem I love the ring and all was good. I had it back only a few months and looked down one day and stone was missing again. Now company is refusing to fix it so we were told by Belk representative. Belk is offering to replace with another ring at the price we paid for the Effy but all I want is my original ring fixed. Buyers beware if Effy will not stand behind their craftsmanship then you would be better off buying from a brand that will stand behind their work. Be assured I never wore my ring doing anything that would cause the diamonds to just fall out. As much as I love it I will never purchase anything made by them again. This just breaks my heart because this was a very special ring to me.

Report
Carolyn Beacon

The color of the tanzanites in the…

The color of the tanzanites in the bracelet I ordered wasn’t even close to the color of the bracelet on the Effy website. I’m still waiting for authorization for a return and exchange or refund. Very disappointing.09/25/2024

Report
Lauren Chamberlain

Beware of pricing

I purchased the emerald and their original and diamond MSRP WAS originally 19,500.00. Then when I got home the MSRP had changed to 11,100. Big drop right? Then I had an appraisal done. Wasn't I a little shocked when I found out it appraised at 8,200. That's a whole lot different than 19,500 or 11,100. They make you think your getting this incredible deal when in fact, you're not. I just feel incredibly betrayed. All I can suggest is to get on the phone and make sure you can find a certified high 🔚 GEMOLOGISTS.BBB Certified. IT IS STUNNING PIECE BUT THE OVER, 6,000.00 plus would look much better in my bank account. choose wisely I found one identical necklace for,6,000.00 on Ebay. Look elsewhere. Be careful my careful

Report

Alternatives to Effy Jewelry

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.