Skip to main content
Goodfellows Estate Agents logo

Goodfellows Estate Agents reviews & trust report

Goodfellows Estate Agents is a property services company operating in South West London and North Surrey. The company specializes in sales and lettings, providing a comprehensive range of services for individuals looking to buy, sell, rent, or let residential properties. With a focus on the local real estate market, Goodfellows aims to assist clients in navigating the complexities of property transactions through expert guidance and support. The target customers of Goodfellows Estate Agents include homebuyers, sellers, tenants, and landlords seeking professional assistance in property management. By offering a user-friendly online platform, the company enables clients to access property listings, book valuations, and receive tailored services to meet their specific needs in the competitive real estate landscape.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview155 customer reviews

Goodfellows Estate Agents has a positive customer experience.

Goodfellows Estate Agents receives a generally positive reception from customers, with many praising the helpfulness and professionalism of their staff. Reviewers frequently highlight the excellent service provided by team members like Maria Castle and the Morden Lettings team, noting their responsiveness and efficiency in managing properties and addressing tenant needs.

Read full summary

Customers appreciate the smooth processes involved in buying and renting properties, often mentioning the supportive nature of agents like Kerry and Jonathan. However, some negative feedback emerges, with complaints about spam emails and unprofessional behavior regarding confidentiality issues. A few reviewers express frustration with their experiences, describing them as nightmares. Overall, Goodfellows Estate Agents is recognized for its strong service, despite some areas needing improvement.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
2 of 2 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.0/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 75% happy · 23% unhappy

Best for

  • Helpful support
  • Fast & efficient
  • Customer service

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Communication
  • Response time
155 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.0
100%
4.0 / 5 overall
155 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jun 2025.

Last 3 months
5.0▲ 1.0
12-month avg
4.4
All-time
4.0
Category avg
4.1
1.02.03.04.05.0Sep 24OctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJun 25Category avg 4.1Sep 24: 5.0 from 1 reviewNov 24: 3.0 from 2 reviewsDec 24: 5.0 from 2 reviewsJan 25: 3.0 from 2 reviewsFeb 25: 4.2 from 5 reviewsMar 25: 5.0 from 1 reviewApr 25: 5.0 from 6 reviewsJun 25: 5.0 from 2 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Sep 245.01
Oct 24—0
Nov 243.02
Dec 245.02
Jan 253.02
Feb 254.25
Mar 255.01
Apr 255.06
May 25—0
Jun 255.02

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 155 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 117 positive reviews

  • Helpful support30%
    35 mentions
  • Fast & efficient29%
    34 mentions
  • Customer service29%
    34 mentions
  • Professionalism23%
    27 mentions
“Having recently bought a property on The Rise through Goodfellows, I wanted to say we found Lynn, James and the rest...”
On “Helpful support” · Jun 24, 2025

Top complaintsof 36 negative reviews

  • Customer service22%
    8 mentions
  • Communication14%
    5 mentions
  • Response time11%
    4 mentions
  • Payment issues11%
    4 mentions
“I would like to share my recent experience with Goodfellows, Morden branch”
On “Customer service” · Nov 28, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Home Services.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Goodfellows Estate Agents logo
Goodfellows Estate Agents
4.0 out of 5 (good)155
2.6 out of 5 (poor)1,129
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,000
3.6 out of 5 (good)618
3.1 out of 5 (fair)596

Bottom line: Goodfellows Estate Agents is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Prime Property Management scores higher (4.1 vs 2.3).

Reviews

155 reviews of Goodfellows Estate Agents. Filter by what matters to you.

4.0ⓘ

Customer reviews (155)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Sachin Rawat
Sachin Rawat
1 review

Too many spam emails

atleast make unsubscribing to your email alerts easy

Report
Narcis Coman
Narcis Coman
1 review

Absolutely Awful Experience with…

Absolutely Awful Experience with Goodfellows If I could give zero stars, I would. Dealing with Goodfellows has been nothing short of a nightmare. From start to finish, their lack of professionalism and disregard for tenants’ concerns has been appalling. To begin with, communication is practically nonexistent. Emails and calls go unanswered for days, sometimes weeks. When they do finally respond, it’s with vague or dismissive answers that leave you feeling unheard and frustrated. The property I rented was not as advertised. Issues like faulty appliances, plumbing problems, and mold were present from day one, yet Goodfellows consistently failed to address them despite repeated complaints. Their so-called “maintenance team” is either overbooked, unqualified, or simply doesn’t care. To make matters worse, they are quick to charge exorbitant fees for anything and everything, often without proper explanation. When it came time to move out, they unfairly deducted a large chunk of my deposit for “cleaning” and “repairs” that were either unnecessary or pre-existing. It’s clear that Goodfellows cares only about their profits, not the well-being of their tenants. I wouldn’t recommend this agency to anyone. Save yourself the stress and look elsewhere for your rental needs.

Report
Aaminah
Aaminah
1 review

Extremely Disappointing with Senior Lettings Manager, Sharmilla

I would like to share my recent experience with Goodfellows, Morden branch. I cannot commend Augstein enough for his outstanding professionalism and courteous conduct during property viewings with my mother. He displayed remarkable etiquette, patience, and knowledge, making the process seamless and reassuring. My mother, who has been viewing properties on my behalf, has often remarked on how rare it is to meet an estate agent with such a high level of respect and professionalism. Our experience with the Senior Lettings Manager, Sharmilla, was deeply disappointing Despite offering a strong application for a rental property — including a guarantor who fully met all income requirements and a willingness to pay 12 months' rent upfront — my application was dismissed due to a perceived lack of on-paper income to cover the rent. *I’d like to add for context I’m currently privately renting, paying £1900.* Being dismissed by the branch manager is entirely unfounded given the financial backing provided. It was shocking to witness a senior manager fail to understand or acknowledge the legitimacy of such an arrangement, which aligns with standard lettings procedures. The purpose of a guarantor and upfront rent payments is to secure the financial obligations of a tenancy. Sharmilla’s outright dismissal raises serious concerns about her understanding of the legal framework, policies, and ethical responsibilities involved in lettings. The situation left us feeling frustrated and undermined. A senior manager in such a role has a duty to offer informed and reasonable service, yet the approach we experienced reflected poor understanding, a lack of empathy, and a failure to adhere to basic industry practices. If senior management operates at this level of incompetence, how can clients have any trust in the wider agency? While I am grateful for the exceptional service provided by Augstein and the rest of the team, the unprofessional conduct and mishandling by the Senior Lettings Manager were overwhelming and detrimental to our overall experience. I strongly urge Goodfellows to invest in management training, particularly in legal and procedural knowledge, communication, and client empathy. I hope this feedback is taken seriously, as the actions of senior management reflect directly on the reputation of the agency. Without addressing these issues, it will be difficult to place trust in Goodfellows as a reliable and professional lettings agency.

Report
Polly Milsom
Polly Milsom
1 review

Will steal your deposit

Goodfellows tried to steal our deposit. We had to submit a lengthy claim through my deposits in order to get it back. Horrible experience please do not rent with them.

Report
Sandu no pain_no gain

Never work with this company!!

Never work with this company!!! They are liars and thieves, also not giving you information about what they changing about your contract/deposit. We moved out from their property to find out after 3 months that they are holding our deposit without any reasons and also not protecting our deposit legally. So, if you dont want to be in the same situation as us, spread the word as they are disgusting and careless!!!

Report
Danielle Spellman

Just a quick one Andrea McDonald is a…

Just a quick one Andrea McDonald is a lowlife person I’m a single mum Have a 4 years old little girl she string me along for a year I had no heating bath and rising damp for a year I have all emails and damp specialist reports to proof She has known about this for a year and doesn’t care clearly not like anyone else me I you human beings what kind of woman would allow a single mum and four-year-old girl to have multiple chest infections living in damp? The damp specialist said it’s one of the worst cases he’s ever seen and told me to move out immediately and go to the council with his report This is the company called Goodfellas estate agents which is the property manager. I will upload every email photo and report from survey reports from all different people that they’ve sent and then to top it off they sent me a section 21 to make me and my daughter homeless , bit of a vice do not ever use Goodfellas estate agents ever !!!!!

Report
Renata Leutwiler Almeida Silva

Poor service

We have put our house to rent with Goodfellows. Their communication with costumers is very poor, they did not arrange many viewings, they did not say the truth a few times about some processes, they overpriced our rent and said they would guarantee it to be rented at that price in 2 weeks... Ot took 2 months and we had to decrease prices. I would never ecomend Goodfellows to anyone, nery pricey fees and very unreliable.

Report
RenrewPlayz
RenrewPlayz
1 review

Very disappointed with Goodfellows…

Very disappointed with Goodfellows Morden. Very unprofessional. Impossible to contact the right people, everyone just passes you on to the next person who doesn't want to deal with the problem. They were nice until money swapped hands, then they became robotic and impossible to deal with. Our washing machine was broken for 3 months during winter and we had to constantly contact them without being given a solution. I will never use Goodfellows again

Report
Ria Bhate
Ria Bhate
1 review

No communication

Very patronising, they will change what they say on every phone call and not communicate with you. They put the emphasis on the customer to continuously ring them to get updates and then when they answer the call go out of their way to make you feel like it’s your fault that you didn’t know the information that they hadn’t bothered to provide to you. Sylvia and Jane at the Heaton branch both told me completely different things and I have never once been updated on my situation without having to ring up and ask what was happening.

Report
sarah
sarah
1 review

Goodfellows Morden

Rude, racist, patronising, and bare faced incompetent bunch of lazy bones. They just throw their weight around. They are a shame to the Estate Agency profession. I don't know how desperate you will have to be to rent, buy, or sell through them. They either seriously under estimate your property's worth or exaggerate it. A family member who was working in the NHS had dealings with them and they only caused us hassle, were disrespectful, and simply would not give us time of the day even though we were putting our lives at risk at Covid times. Really despicable bunch. Specially the Morden branch in Surrey. Avoid, avoid, avoid.

Report
Claire M
Claire M
1 review

Rude

Rude, immature, patronising, inefficient and ineffective. Can barely bring myself to waste breath on them, but avoid at all costs. Do Goodfellows give any training at all to their estate agents? Zero evidence of respect or professionalism shown towards tenants. Several suspected contractual issues breaching legality.

Report
蓮葉
蓮葉
1 review

I would like to give a negative star to the Goodfellows for Sutton branch

I would like to give a negative star, if I could. This a very disappointing as the Sutton branch agent confirmed us (vocal and by email) on early June that the probate legal works was granted back in March of this year, ALL DOCUMENTS ARE DONE. Unfortunately we don’t know why the seller’s solicitor needed a month on 28 July (Friday after 5pm) to sent us the draft contract. During this time we call and email the agent several times to asked why we still have not received any documents and information from the seller’s lawyer. but we always can’t reach her and left a message or reply us needs a couple days. And when we received the draft contract were started the legal process then the title guarantee and information provided by the seller is very limited and many things needs us surveying by our self. When we arrange a date for the house surveyor and the asbestos inspections for test samples, the agent is always slow in reverting back to us. But about two weeks from receiving the draft contract, the estate agent called me to urge our lawyer to respond to the seller’s lawyer as soon as possible, otherwise they would put the house back on the market. She known us needed moving in this house in early September in the beginning but due to her arrangements are very bad and have not knowledge of this house before putting on the market, she is unreasonable and unprofessional. We wasted a lot of time and money. That’s are very uncomfortable with us. All in all, a bad experience.

Report
Reviewer
Reviewer
1 review

Inefficient at all

Worst estate agent that I have ever liaised with. They never called back when you send them interest through Zoopla/Rightmove. When I called them after a couple of days, they said they will arrange the viewing with the landlord and never called me back also. This wasn’t a one off experience. They were bad since my last house hunting back in 2007.

Report
Martin
Martin
1 review

Be very carefull

The just want your money, they refuse to help with problems, they never call you back, its not a good company to rent from as all up front getting you to rent then once you sign the contract they do not help you solve problems.

Report
Dale
Dale
1 review

Shameful Ignorance

If i could give 0 stars i would. 3 years with issues promised to be fixed before we moved in and still not done. They have the cheek to blame the landlord when they haven't even contacted them. My own vehicle damaged due to no inspection or anything. Matt in Sutton is always in a meeting and unavailable or on a phone. They ask for you to leave a message then ignore your requests. Cant get a flat repaired if they ignore you. Breached contract on 8 different occasions but still want their money. Shameful. Never live in Sutton under these criminals.

Report
Yashwanth
Yashwanth
1 review

I put 0 if I could. Worst Worst Agency(Heaton Manager)

I put 0 if I could. Worst agency I have seen in my life. Absolutely they don't want to solve the problems. I have moved recently to a house in NE6. Neighbour(Ground floor) is creating a lot of problems and we informed this to Agency(Heaton manager Linda and Sylvia) which they don't care and don't want to solve either. Instead of solving the issue, They are very very rude to me and asking me to pay the full amount if I leave. Seriously this is the worst worst agency I have ever seen in UK. Never ever recommend Goodfellows estate agents in heaton area.

Report
Deborah Simms

Discriminate against potential tenants

Awful agency, they discriminate against potential tenants with children and those who are on disability related benefits. When you explain to them that they are acting unlawfully they blame it on the landlords and/ or referencing companies. You tell them you can provide a deposit and rent in advance plus references but they don't care. Then they retain your details on file and don't even bother to contact you when you send enquiries about other properties. They are extremely prejudiced and discriminatory in their renting practices. Once again, they do not care if you are on full uncapped benefits DUE TO DISABILITY OR CARING FOR SOMEONE WITH A DISABILITY, they do not care if you can PROVE that you can afford the rent. Because all they care about is discriminating against vulnerable people.

Report
Lorna Dubois
Lorna Dubois
1 review

Incredibly unprofessional and rude

Incredibly unprofessional and rude. My family drove one hour to make an appointment (the only time they had apparently) at 9.45 this morning. They were left in the cold waiting outside, only to be told there was 5 minutes before the next appointment. The agent was in the property, knew the time of our appointment very well, and could have let them in or completed the first viewing in time. He offered no apology. It is completely unacceptable to be treated this way.

Report
C H
C H
1 review

I rented an apartment through them.

I rented an apartment through them. A very rude agent. They ask for home visit without given prior notice. 3 months before the tenancy end, they ask for our decision regarding continuous of renting and ask for our response ASAP. Later, they will contact you 3-4 times every week about home visit.

Report
S.M
S.M
1 review

I am highly disappointed with the Good…

I am highly disappointed with the Good fellows morden branch. We rented a property through them which was managed by the agent and landlord was in India. The day we entered the house kitchen roof started to leak .... they gave us nightmares in fixing the issue as they kept on telling landlord is not approving the request. Issue remained unresolved till the date ( after a year ) we moved out. Now even after moving out agents are not proving us with our checkout inventory report even after multiple calls and emails ( it's been over a month now) and not releasing the deposit again saying landlord is not responding. Please beware of this agency as you will pay your full rent still they will give you mental harassment. I am especially upset from Matt Clifford, who is not responding to our simple request of providing checkout inventory report and information regarding out deposit.

Report

Alternatives to Goodfellows Estate Agents

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.