Skip to main content
JR Cigars logo

JR Cigars reviews & trust report

JR Cigars is an established online retailer specializing in a wide selection of premium cigars and cigar accessories. The company offers an extensive inventory that includes well-known brands, limited editions, and unique blends, catering to both casual smokers and seasoned aficionados. Customers can explore a variety of products, including cigars, humidors, and smoking accessories, all available for convenient online purchasing. The target market for JR Cigars includes cigar enthusiasts, gift buyers, and individuals seeking quality smoking experiences. By providing detailed product descriptions and customer reviews, the company aims to enhance the shopping experience and assist customers in making informed choices. With a focus on customer satisfaction, JR Cigars strives to meet the needs of its clientele by offering competitive pricing and reliable shipping options.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview86 customer reviews

JR Cigars has a poor customer experience.

JR Cigars receives overwhelmingly negative feedback from customers, with a significant number expressing frustration over poor customer service and order fulfillment issues. Many reviewers report receiving incorrect or incomplete orders, with some even receiving empty boxes.

Read full summary

Complaints about the quality of cigars are common, as customers mention receiving dried-out products or items that do not match their expectations. While a few consumers appreciate the fast delivery and have had satisfactory experiences, these positive remarks are overshadowed by the majority of negative reviews highlighting problems with shipping delays and unresponsive customer support. Additionally, concerns about pricing tactics and loyalty program changes further contribute to dissatisfaction.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
1.7/ 5
Mostly negative
Recent reviews: 15% happy · 83% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Delivery
  • Fast & efficient

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Shipping
  • Pricing
86 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
1.7
100%
1.7 / 5 overall
86 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
1.3▲ 0.3
12-month avg
1.5
All-time
1.7
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Aug 24SepOctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.0Aug 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewSep 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsOct 24: 2.3 from 3 reviewsNov 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsDec 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsJan 25: 5.0 from 1 reviewFeb 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewMar 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewMay 25: 1.3 from 3 reviewsJun 25: 1.5 from 2 reviewsJul 25: 1.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Aug 241.01
Sep 241.02
Oct 242.33
Nov 241.02
Dec 241.02
Jan 255.01
Feb 251.01
Mar 251.01
Apr 25—0
May 251.33
Jun 251.52
Jul 251.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 86 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 13 positive reviews

  • Customer service69%
    9 mentions
  • Delivery62%
    8 mentions
  • Fast & efficient31%
    4 mentions
  • Prices & value31%
    4 mentions
“I have completed two orders with JR Cigars with no issues”
On “Customer service” · Oct 23, 2024

Top complaintsof 71 negative reviews

  • Customer service61%
    43 mentions
  • Shipping31%
    22 mentions
  • Pricing15%
    11 mentions
  • Refund15%
    11 mentions
“just absolutely terrible customer service”
On “Customer service” · Jul 3, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Shopping & Fashion.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
JR Cigars logo
JR Cigars
1.7 out of 5 (poor)86
1.3 out of 5 (poor)1,000
2.9 out of 5 (fair)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)397
2.6 out of 5 (poor)368

Bottom line: JR Cigars is #4 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On service, Red Run scores higher (5.0 vs 1.5).

Reviews

86 reviews of JR Cigars. Filter by what matters to you.

1.7ⓘ

Customer reviews (86)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Harvey
Harvey
1 review

Been a customer for more than 10 years

Been a customer for more than 10 years, and have noticed a slow but steady decline in product, price and most notably customer service. Other than a customer friendly web site they are not a company I want to spend my money with.

Report
U C
U C
1 review

Do not purchase from this place

Do not purchase from this place. HORRIBLE customer service!! Cigars they sent Me didn't even match the description of the ones I ordered!. A Bait and Switch! Then in order to return them it can only be done by email and takes forever to authorize.. Then when finally approved you return them they receive them and never issue you a refund! Almost a month and still no refund Luckily I ordered through PayPal Had to file a claim and they issued me the refund. They actually mentioned that JR was lying about the refund..So buyer beware!!

Report
Gokcen
Gokcen
1 review

JR Cigars SUCKS

JR Cigars SUCKS! They trick you on the prices and charge you later. And when you want to return the item (right away, unopened package), they dont even respond your messages/mails/calls. After few WEEKS, yes WEEKS, they say `oh, we decline your request`. Dont ever buy from here, there are other cigar websites which has great customer services!

Report
Erich Lewis
Erich Lewis
1 review

Run, don't walk! Terrible service and cigars!

I ordered for the first time and the cigars were all dry. When I returned them, JR Cigars deducted money because I opened the package. How am I to discover the cigars are dry if I don't open the packages? I called customer service and was treated terribly. I will never order or recommend JR Cigars!

Report
Dave Thompson

Poor customer service.

JR has stopped selling to customers in the state of Wyoming. I have been unable to find out why. I even contacted my legislators who had no idea. I talked to several employees and a supervisor. All they could tell me was they had been given a email. I sent a email to customer service requesting a reason seven days ago with no response.

Report
Snakeeyes
Snakeeyes
1 review

jrcigars.com

jrcigars.com. And cigars.com are sister(same) company. Now the customer service is terrible, the orders are always missing items (some out of stock) The accounting and invoicing is a joke. They charge for the whole order, then you have to call and argue for the refund. What is going on? Find a better company.

Report
Batuhan
Batuhan
1 review

Really bad customer service experience…

Really bad customer service experience thanks to Dorothy H. I won’t be a buyer and no one from my circle will buy anything from here. You shouldn’t too.

Report
Gary F
Gary F
1 review

false advertising on website about…

false advertising on website about deals they say you were going to get something and it is missing from order . they tell you it is as supplies last. I ordered the very minute it appeared. so why put it up if you have no supplies. company was great always customer service related. now customer service is terrible. Mike's cigars much better company to deal with

Report
Shawn Holmes
Shawn Holmes
1 review

The company used to be about the…

The company used to be about the customers. Now it's all about the money. The company now refuses to allow there employees to tell you about deals. They want you to find them on your own. They are not renewing our memberships because they want more money

Report
Rich
Rich
1 review

Bait and Nothing

I received an email from JR Cigars last week with a special that included a 5 ct Infused gift set with certain orders. I went there and made a purchase. It showed up but with no gift set. I reached out and they said they may have run out (while supplies last). I asked well why would you send a note, email or call to let me know - I would have cancelled my order. Terrible customer service and disappointing....

Report
Drew Anderson

I order two boxes of Oliva Melanio V…

I order two boxes of Oliva Melanio V cigars on 09/06/23. They were having a good sale (30% off) on this brand of cigars. I had to call the order in because I could not log into my JR Plus account. I ordered the cigars and the customer service representative confirmed the order and I was emailed the order number. I was out of town that weekend and upon return, I had not received the cigars. I checked all my JR messages on my email and phone (I get 3-4 emails and 1-2 text messages from them daily) and no email stating that my order has shipped. I checked my credit card account that I use and it did not show any transaction. I called a JR Cigar service rep and she looked into it using my order number that I received upon purchasing. She said that it did not ship because the transaction failed. I asked why wasn't I notified so that we could get this resolved. She was unable to answer. She put me on hold and then return within a few minutes and said that it needed a manager approval and there was no manager on duty during that day (Saturday, 9/16/23) and told me to call back on Monday. On Monday, 9/28/23, I called again and was put on hold for several minutes. The service rep informed me that they were not going to honor the 30% discount on the two boxes of cigars because the sale ended. I did not take my anger out on the customer representative but I did plead my case on this injustice. If JR Cigars can send me 3-4 emails and 1-2 text messages daily, then why couldn't someone message me to let me know that the transaction did not go through? Also, how did I get an email stating that the transaction was approved and a customer order number was assigned to my purchase? I, kindly, asked the customer service rep to cancel my JR Cigars Plus membership and I requested a pro-rated refund since I joined in May 2023. She informed me that she put the request through but could not tell me if I would get any refund for cancelling my Plus membership. FYI: 2.23/5 rating on BBB

Report
Brittany Wimbush

Unauthorized charges on account/ shipping to unverified names

Had issues with name verification as this was a gift for my grandfather. Was told that he would have to upload his ID which posed an issue since he does not have a smart phone or access to a computer. A representative helped me over the phone and said that we could put the order in my name and still send to his address. She said she would cancel the original order I placed online and make the changes over the phone. Both "orders" were sent out one with my name and the other with the my grandmoms name on it which was "unverified". Called again for them to make it right since I was had over $150 worth of cigars taken out of my account. The representative not very helpful and said they could mail him a return slip to return the second box. So frustrated with the poor customer service, lack of ownership on their part for THEIR mistake! Still haven't received the return slip its been about a week and a half. Not sure how they sent out the one order when the name was never verified. Super fishy business practices if they aren't verifying and then charging my account twice for a second order I did not want. They are wasting my time making me keep calling in and having my grandfather take care of a return. So much for getting him a nice gift way more trouble than its worth. Will not be using this company again

Report
Miguel Miguel

JR cigar gets ZERO stars review from this customer.

JR cigar gets ZERO stars review from this customer. JR Cigars located in Burlington, NC has provided me the absolute worst customer service experience I have ever encountered. I placed an order with JR cigars for a sample box of cigars And paid extra for 2nd day UPS shipping. I spoke to a sales rep who shall remain nameless, and the sales rep assured me my order would be shipped promptly. I ordered these cigars for my brother who is gravely ill in a nursing home in NYC. I advised my brother that the cigars would be delivered on Thursday Aug. 3rd. My brother called me to advise me that he did not receive the cigars as expected. I promptly reached out to JR cigars in order to get the tracking number for the order I placed with them (JR cigars). Upon speaking with JR they advised me that my order did not shop yet because they did not receive my age verification (ID) yet. I questioned the rep as to why hasn't anyone reached out to me from JR and I was told that they don't do that. In other words I placed an order with 2nd day ups shipping and two days later the order still did not ship. JR cigars advised me that they do not follow up on customer order shipping problems. I asked the sales rep when would they advise me that my order has not shipped yet and the rep said maybe after 10 days they would let me know. I was told by JR rep that my order would be delivered on Monday and that there is nothing else they could do. I am sure JR has many happy customers and based on reviews they seem to have a quality product. My experience is they have very, very poor customer service follow up procedures in place and I will never order from JR cigars again.

Report
Mark Saxton
Mark Saxton
1 review

False promise on discount

False promise on discount. I needed a large order fora wedding. Looked at several online sites. Went to JR. Immediately got a pop-up window offering 25% savings in exachange for email address. Went through the hassle of getting signed up and received a flurry of text messages promoting various offers, but never got the discount. Called customer service. They said it only applies to subsequent order, except there won't be a subsequent order.

Report
selim.celem selim.celem

Went to the website on my phone

Went to the website on my phone, got bombarded with intrusive pop-ups which I couldn't be arsed to try and close.

Report
chris
chris
1 review

scam site

purchased and it said there was an error. my account was charged for $70 and received nothing . don’t buy

Report
Ruth Kennedy
Ruth Kennedy
1 review

Worse then Bad

If I could give this place a -star I would I ordered for my son in law got Christmas and when they came in everything was dried out and broken. I called they sent out a replacement order and waited again for the order to arrive and what to my eye I find everything was damaged just as bad if not worse then the first cigars that was ordered. How does a business stay open if they continue to send bad products out? I called and after being on hold for 45 minutes and talking to a supervisor I finally was told I would be able to get a refund. Now two weeks before Christmas I need for figure out something else for my son in law as a gift….

Report
Mike Farella
Mike Farella
1 review

Jr cigars

The company text me a coupon code it never works. I was told they have a problem with there system

Report
John
John
1 review

Ordered a box of cigars it was supposed…

Ordered a box of cigars it was supposed to come with a free bonus leather cigar holder as part of the deal. My box of cigars arrived. I never got the leather holder. Emailed them three times before someone replied, they stated those bonuses are only available while supplies last of course you think they would take that offer away if they didn’t have those in stock felt like it was a scam. I emailed them back to voice, my opinion and of course they haven’t replied I won’t be doing business with them again. They could’ve apologized and offered another bonus to me to keep me happy.

Report
Tammy Hamilton

3rd time this has happened we were…

3rd time this has happened we were shorted on our order. We were suppose to get a bonus pack of cigars and they never came, even tho they showed on our invoice. After the order was placed, poof! the bonus pack of cigars are off the invoice and they do nothing to support or make the order right. We are done.

Report

Alternatives to JR Cigars

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.