John Shepherd Estate Agents reviews & trust report
John Shepherd Estate Agents is a leading property management and real estate agency operating in the Midlands. The company specializes in sales, lettings, and property management services, catering to a diverse clientele that includes landlords, tenants, home buyers, and sellers. With extensive local expertise spanning over three decades, John Shepherd provides comprehensive support to individuals looking to buy, sell, or rent properties in the region.
The company offers a range of services, including expert property valuations, dedicated landlord support, and tailored solutions for tenants seeking their ideal homes. John Shepherd is committed to delivering quality property management and facilitating seamless transactions, making it a trusted choice for those navigating the Midlands real estate market. Customers can access a wide selection of properties for sale and rent, alongside financial services to assist in their property-related decisions.
John Shepherd Estate Agents has a positive customer experience.
John Shepherd Estate Agents receives a mix of praise and criticism from its clients. Many reviewers commend the professionalism and responsiveness of staff members like John Blythe, Lauren Foster, and Melissa Cannon, highlighting their helpfulness in navigating tenancy issues and maintenance requests.
Read full summaryShow less
Customers appreciate the friendly service and efficient handling of processes, such as moving out and deposit returns. However, a significant number of negative reviews express dissatisfaction with the management of properties, citing poor communication and unresolved maintenance issues. Some clients report frustrating experiences, particularly after the agency took over properties, leading to a decline in service quality.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
★
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.3
698
100%
+0.5
● Low
4.3 / 5 overall
=
698 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.
Last 3 months
4.0▲ 0.5
12-month avg
3.5
All-time
4.3
Category avg
4.3
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Aug 24
3.3
12
Sep 24
3.3
10
Oct 24
3.6
15
Nov 24
3.9
11
Dec 24
2.0
4
Jan 25
3.1
9
Feb 25
3.6
10
Mar 25
3.2
13
Apr 25
3.6
17
May 25
3.7
9
Jun 25
4.4
10
Jul 25
3.6
5
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 400 positive reviews
Customer service33%
130 mentions
Helpful support28%
112 mentions
Fast & efficient27%
109 mentions
Professionalism24%
97 mentions
“I had a viewing with Millie”
On “Customer service” · Jun 11, 2025
Top complaintsof 93 negative reviews
Customer service28%
26 mentions
Payment issues25%
23 mentions
Response time20%
19 mentions
Communication17%
16 mentions
“Centrick used to manage my property, and I never had any issues with them for 7 years”
On “Customer service” · Jul 7, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Home & Garden.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
48 days now after leaving one of John Sheperd rental properties and l am still waiting for my deposit. It should have been paid within ten days. Tina Margetts is dealing with me and she is completely useless at her job. Looks like l will have to go to court to sort this out. l am completely pissed off with this company and Tina.
If I could post ZERO stars I would. Absolutely abysmal service from start to finish. Zero customer service. It's hard to tell if their staff is strained to be unhelpful or just plain stupid, such is the degree of their incompetence. This business needs to be avoided. Sadly as with many in this industry, very little checks and accountability is possible so they keep on treating clients with contempt.
Unreliable, no communication.
I am the landlord and while they 'managed' my property the tenant managed to get 2 debt collections for my flat. John Shepherd did not tell me this.
Cheryl Quinney in the Bham office is probably the least capable of all them. Completely useless and unprofessional.
They are not willing to solve the issues and refund me from the tenant's deposit, or communicate to find a solution.
I was told that I should pay for the cleaning fee and they refund. They have not refunded me. The tenant
still owes late payment fees from unpaid electricity, they also don't refund me that either OR communicate to find a solution. (Tenant played a very nasty game to move his electricity debt onto my name, that they don't want to refund.)
They do not respond to my emails to solve the problem. I provided proof, statements to the agent, but they don't communicate to discuss what to do and hold onto all of my money.
I also had different communication about advertising my flat. The agent told me I cannot advertise while the prev tenant is there then they said that is not true.
They caused me a lot of problem and lost money, never ever again do business with them.
*update 3 months later: I have managed to talk to the agency who seemed interested to resolve it that day, however it has been another month without any update/reply or solution, so still at the same point as 5months ago. I was also asked to remove the negative reviews.
*update 4. Nov. 2024: Received a statement saying that instead of they pay me back the cleaning fee I paid, I need to pay them. Basically instead of they refund me the cleaning fee I have paid, they want me to pay them back. I called them around 7 times, emailed Kai-Ewan 8 times, and still after 3 weeks, no reply. :)
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Condescending senior property manager
Took over previous contract. Clear communication issues on handover. When I mentioned more than one month he replied with 'months' in quotation marks. Happy to not deal with this rude business going forward :)
Since Tassi was bought out by John Shepherd, my experience with them has gone rapidly downhill. Maintenance requests and contact form submissions are not actioned, phones are never answered, and if you even get in contact with someone through previous correspondence or guessing their new email address, they'll just stop responding when you've asked them questions.
Disgusting service. They have held on to my deposit it has been over a month since my tenancy finished. I have tried to contact them many times and just get left in the dark. Get told different things by different people. No one actually knows what they’re doing here. Appealing agents, rude and just take your money
Awful experience. Never respond to emails or action any requests. Numerous emails sent over a number of months. Visited in person and still made no progress. Totally useless !
Rented via the Birmingham branch after they acquired Centrick Lettings. Post acquisition, a third party company, instructed on behalf of John Shepherd/Centrick illegally closed all of my utility bill accounts (accounts in my own name) with my utility suppliers without providing me any notice. It wasn’t until I received notification directly from the supplier to advise I was to expect my final bill that i was made aware of the issue. When calling my property manager (Bethany Turner) to discuss the issue I was initially advised ‘oh yeah this is an error that has happened to other flats too’ and that I would need to resolve the issue with the suppliers myself. It wasn’t until I told them the suppliers were refusing to discuss the matter with me now the accounts were no longer under my name that they then agreed to assist. I work in the Property Management industry myself and fully appreciate that errors can occur from time to time, however this was simply the result of incompetence and complacency. The service received when trying to resolve this was also subpar at best, I even escalated the matter to somebody more ‘senior’ (Kai Rodney) within the company and didn’t receive acknowledgment of my email for 3 weeks. Again, appreciating how busy and overwhelming this industry can be it does not change the fact that I was unable to have access to my utility accounts for almost two months with little to no communication on the matter. It has since transpired that they did exactly the same for my council tax too, removing my name from the council tax for the property while I was there and only now after having left the property am i being issued with a bill for the period they decided to remove me from the account. To add insult to injury, my contact details were issued to a maintenance company (once I’d vacated the property at the end of my tenancy) in regard to gaining access in order to do works in the flat I no longer lived in, meaning by no great surprise the incompetent staff members had somehow managed to provide my details to the contractors knowing full well I was no longer the tenant in the property which is worrying when in this industry, and many others, Data Protection is a serious matter. I have seen that Chris Blick is listed in the responses on trust pilot as a point of contact for escalation of such complaints. Ironically, despite copying Chris into my email correspondence he never did take a minute to provide a response of any kind, but it did encourage Bethany to respond in a slightly more timely manner. I welcome Chris to provide an attempt to justify my aforementioned experience and his employee’s truly shocking and incompetent service.
Horrible service.
I'm the owner of the parking space and they rented my car parking space to someone else! And their aggressive tenant is threatening to me!
They told tenants at Nightingale Quarter, Fox House, and Derby that they could use numerous parking spaces which belong to other residents. And they even charged poor tenants. Do yourself a favour - don't touch it as a plaque!
Tell your tenants that THEY DON'T OWN THEIR PARKING SPACE AND CAN'T PARK THERE!
How do you dare to take money from the tenants for a parking space which doesn't belong to them?!
Bad experience at John Shepherd Lettings department Solihull
I have experienced the worst service from John shepherd Lettings team that anybody could possibly get . I am a professional lady in my 50’s just needing help and support in finding a home with the rental team in Solihull . In my experience with John shepherds at Solihull branch , I felt under valued , I was made to feel
Uncomfortable inquiring about properties , I was unsupported , dismissed on personal choices , not contacted and communicated with . The letting staff attitudes were totally unprofessional and unsupportive making me feel
As if I was the problem in calling them I strongly advise not to use this agent to prevent any similar experiences happening to yourselves . Please seek proper and professional support from another agent . I am writing these comments to prevent people experiencing the under valued attitudes and professionalism that will happen with John shepherd. 3/6/2024
Monique A
I would never in a million year recommend this company the staff are shocking and the way they treat customers is appalling! I have fought with this company for 5 months over a £750 deposit that they refused to release to myself. My flat that they were supposed to manage and look after is and absolute DISGRACEFUL TIP, they never fixed any problems and if they did it was a half arsed job! My Tenant had called them multiple times with occurring problems asking them to fix them and no one ever got back to her! The reason for having a leasing agent is to take a weight of the Landlord's shoulders with one less issue to deal with! Leah and Julie (at the Sutton Coldfield branch) are an waste of time to even speak to! They truly do not care about helping anyone, they ignore multiple phone calls and emails! If you are looking for a lease agent to manage any property of your DO NOT use John Shepherd! If you ever decide to use them get ready to contact the Property Ombudsmen to file a complaint to try and get your Tenants deposit back because as soon as you want to end your agreement with them and change leasing agents or do all the work yourself it is going to be a ball ache and very stressful time getting that deposit back! Please learn from my mistake of going with them they are an utter joke!!!
If I was able to give them 0 stars I would!
I am utterly appalled by the unprofessional conduct and lack of accountability displayed by Centrick (now acquired by John Shepherds). Despite my repeated efforts to resolve an issue caused by their own incompetence, they have chosen to shift the blame onto me, the tenant.
Their delays and constant stream of excuses have left me in an untenable situation. Due to their failure in handling basic tenancy renewal procedures and basic obligations, I was essentially forced to remain in my property beyond the intended lease period, waiting for them to rectify their own mistakes and they were still saying it is okay and I do not need to worry. But you know what, they secretly put the extra cost on my account! After reaching out to them regarding the additional rental charges several times, they have not only failed to rectify the situation but have also threatened to deduct payments from my deposit now, showing a complete disregard for their responsibilities as property managers.
Their refusal to acknowledge their mistakes and instead burden the tenant with unjust financial consequences is utterly unacceptable. It is clear that their priority lies not in providing quality service but in squeezing every penny out of their tenants.
Avoid John Shepherd (Centrick) at all COST!!! Their lack of professionalism and blatant disregard for tenant welfare make them wholly unfit to manage any property.
Dear all,
I need help. If anyone has any advice please feel free to leave your comments.
Since moving in three weeks ago, I have discovered that 1. the main door was difficult to open and close, 2. one of the light was damaged (not bulb), 3. the bed mattress was damaged, 4. the carpet was full of dust with dark spots, 5. one of chair was broken, 6. wardrobe has big whole which is also broke, 7.the toilet is smelly.
I’ve waited for two weeks to get fixing, but nothing changes until now. I want to unwind contract and deposit back because when discussing the property agent stated [that it is well-furnished with professional cleanness with professional inspection].
I signed the tenancy agreement on the basis of the misleading information I was given.
However, agent didn’t agree to unwind (even no apology), and I’m still waiting agent to provide landlord’s detail.
Except property ombudsman(I’ve submitted), anything else I can to to report this fraud?
One of the worst letting agents. Impossible to get your deposit back. Hannah Britten lied and produced fake 'evidence' to succeed. Awful human being and awful company
The Sutton Cold Field team namely Julie & Leah are shocking at customer service, with holding our deposit for no reason due to their inability provide us with a inventory of the property and accusing my partner of not handing a key when they have now "found"it as it was simply not handed in by their office team members. When you call they dont answer for a day and when you email there is no response either. I will definitely not recommend sending them any money as they are NOT trustworthy. Stay clear, I will not be sworn either, the manager of this branch is shocking!!!
Upon moving into this property as of DECEMBER 2022, the property was NOT cleaned upon my arrival and was in poor state. I actually had to purchase cleaning products to proceed with a deep cleaning of my own bedroom. Neither were the cupboards, stove, living area or any other shared kitchen facilities. So the notion that this flat was in good living condition is incorrect. I left the flat in a better condition than I found it in. The walls were already in poor condition upon my arrival also. They were discoloured and had fine cracks in them, evident as standard wear and tear, which is not tenant responsibility. I have inflicted no physical damage on any walls within my short stay at the accommodation. The floors were a huge thing I complained about upon moving into the property and they were ALSO in poor condition upon moving in. I also complained to this to the John shepherd, which was ignored. I was told that the landlord found it suitable and that I shouldn’t not have signed the tenancy agreement if I was not happy with the state of the walls and carpet, which I continue to STRESS, was in extremely poor condition before moving into the property which I unfortunately did not view before i signed the lease. The lights near my room have never worked and are built into the wall, I’m not sure how I am supposed to take responsibility for THAT as it was already poorly fitted BEFORE I moved into the property and I would not know how to change them. I never touched them. The state of the bathroom is of wear and tear, no physical damage inflicted in any such way. The bed, also in poor condition upon moving into the property. The flooring of the kitchen was always scuffed up and in poor condition prior to me moving in. I accept blame for one of the TWO living room chairs I met during my whole time at the tenancy (there were never 4). I weakened one leg as I used it to stand on top of the electricity box to reset the meter. But not to the amount I am being requested to pay for a singular chair. I’d like to see a receipt for the same chair, in order to replace, or paying for one at a reasonable price. I remind you I had been living there for six months only. Many of the problems the landlord is requesting me to fix were there BEFORE I moved in which is unnaceptable. I complained to my flatmate, as seen in the attached messages (same number can be found on the system) on my MOVE IN DATE on the poor quality of the house and he even offered to clean it as nobody in John shepherd had bothered to arrange a cleaning. Repost as my review was deleted and I will keep reposting and checking. Rajak Ali and the rest are horrifically negligent and cold
Went through the whole painful process of renting an apartment through John Shepherd and goodlord and did everything that was required and paid the fees and got the keys to the flat and checked in today only to find so many small issues that has not been taken care of and so many things needs to be fixed even though they had all this time to take care of it and clean it probably!!
**UPDATE**
They came in and fixed what needed to be fixed
also I want to mention that agent Meghan was helpful though out the process
Avoid dealings with Vijay Kapila from Birmingham branch if at all possible. He arranges people to come into your flat without warning. He shares other people’s contracts for other flats with you breaking confidentiality. He pretends the contracts are yours to try and stop you leaving presenting a huge bill. Very underhand tactics to extract fees. No deposit back still too.
John Shepherd Estate Agents is a leading property management and real estate agency operating in the Midlands. The company specializes in sales, lettings, and property management services, catering to a diverse clientele that includes landlords, tenants, home buyers, and sellers. With extensive local expertise spanning over three decades, John Shepherd provides comprehensive support to individuals looking to buy, sell, or rent properties in the region.
The company offers a range of services, including expert property valuations, dedicated landlord support, and tailored solutions for tenants seeking their ideal homes. John Shepherd is committed to delivering quality property management and facilitating seamless transactions, making it a trusted choice for those navigating the Midlands real estate market. Customers can access a wide selection of properties for sale and rent, alongside financial services to assist in their property-related decisions.