Karl Tatler Estate Agents is a well-established property agency operating in the Wirral and Cheshire West regions since 1997. The company specializes in residential real estate services, including selling and letting properties. With a diverse portfolio that caters to both buyers and renters, Karl Tatler aims to provide comprehensive support throughout the property transaction process.
Targeting homeowners, prospective buyers, and tenants, the company offers property valuations, mortgage and insurance services, and expert advice on the local market. With a reputation for exceptional customer service, Karl Tatler Estate Agents is dedicated to helping clients navigate the complexities of real estate in their area. For those looking to buy, sell, or rent properties in Wirral, Karl Tatler serves as a trusted resource for reliable and professional assistance.
Karl Tatler Estate Agents has a mixed customer experience.
Karl Tatler Estate Agents receives a mix of feedback, with many customers praising the excellent service and professionalism of staff like Melvyn Hamid and Sarah Graham, who are noted for their constant communication and support throughout the buying process. Reviewers highlight the agency's efficiency and helpfulness, particularly in challenging situations, making the experience smoother for many.
Read full summaryShow less
However, significant complaints arise regarding poor communication and unprofessionalism, especially from the Greasby branch, where customers feel misled and frustrated with the handling of their transactions. Issues such as delays in deposit returns and a lack of coordination among staff contribute to a negative perception for some. Overall, while there are commendable aspects of service, the negative experiences cannot be overlooked, leading to a sentiment that is mixed.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
★
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
3.5
37
100%
● Low
3.5 / 5 overall
=
37 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jun 2025.
Last 3 months
2.0▼ 3.0
12-month avg
3.1
All-time
3.5
Category avg
4.3
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Jul 24
5.0
1
Aug 24
4.5
2
Sep 24
—
0
Oct 24
1.0
1
Nov 24
—
0
Dec 24
—
0
Jan 25
—
0
Feb 25
—
0
Mar 25
5.0
1
Apr 25
—
0
May 25
1.0
2
Jun 25
3.0
2
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 37 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 23 positive reviews
Customer service43%
10 mentions
Professionalism26%
6 mentions
Helpful support22%
5 mentions
Friendly staff17%
4 mentions
“We have just purchased a house using Karl Tatler Estate Agents”
On “Customer service” · Jun 18, 2025
Top complaintsof 14 negative reviews
Customer service43%
6 mentions
Pricing29%
4 mentions
Communication14%
2 mentions
“I work a lot with companies on Voice of the customer (VOC) They simply don't understand it”
On “Customer service” · Jun 13, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Home & Garden.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
Excellent service from the beginning to the point of purchase. We have just purchased a house using…
We have just purchased a house using Karl Tatler Estate Agents.
From the very beginning to the point of completion, they have been amazing.
They were very professional and kept us up-to-date from t... See more
The Greasby Branch, right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing
The Greasby Branch was very poor to say the least.
They showed all the wonderful statistics of how they are the best.
As soon as I signed the agreement it all changes, sales executive it was given to... See more
I'm still waiting for my deposit on my house I handed the keys in on the 14th day of the month and on the 22 day of the month I phoned Beth Ellis and she was very unprofessional towards me I wouldn't... See more
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Excellent service from the beginning to the point of purchase. We have just purchased a house using…
We have just purchased a house using Karl Tatler Estate Agents.
From the very beginning to the point of completion, they have been amazing.
They were very professional and kept us up-to-date from the start to the end of the Sale. We would like to send a big Thank You to Karla Evans -Assistant Manager and Lucie Smith who was our Sales Progressor.
The Greasby Branch, right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing
The Greasby Branch was very poor to say the least.
They showed all the wonderful statistics of how they are the best.
As soon as I signed the agreement it all changes, sales executive it was given to (Jess) was useless and got one viewer for the time it was with them. Handed over at one stage to a young gentleman who managed to get two.
Went in sit with Jess to see why it's not moving as we had put an offer on another property. She said its priced a bit high (was their evaluation not mine) so I lowered it.
Had made the decision they price high as their fees are the highest on the wirral, went it to give them written notice of 14 days as per their contract. Offered Jess the letter she we don't need that will enter into system.
So the first day we put it on the market with another estate agent we get a call from Noah saying we were in breach of contract, why you may ask? Jess had not entered anything on the system.
I work a lot with companies on Voice of the customer (VOC) They simply don't understand it. Trying to send an email to Karl Tatler himself is some what difficult for obvious reasons, but I will find a way.
Quite simple if want proper customer service don't use Karl Tatler
I'm still waiting for my deposit on my house I handed the keys in on the 14th day of the month and on the 22 day of the month I phoned Beth Ellis and she was very unprofessional towards me I wouldn't recommend them as estate agents and property letting agents advertising rental property with pictures which were at least 10 years old planting shrubs in the front and back garden knowingly years down the line they will be too big for the garden asking landlords permission to cut large shrubs down or conifers and saying no even at least 5 were cut down previously finding small faults cooker cleaned £100
Karl Tatler was amazing - I dealt personally with Melvyn Hamid who is based in Prenton. He was amazing, so professional and would always be in constant contact updating us with where they were up too, and our house was sold within a week of being on the market!! Would definitely recommend!
Karl Tatler begged me to let them sell my house ,and promised they would get me over £700k after a year of reductions we accepted a byer at £638k the couple pulled out.
Within 24hrs my ex wife was advised to reduce it 25k , they then told my ex wife selling it for £615k was a good deal !! Feeling ripped off is an understatement, stay clear they lie to get your business!!
As we are moving back to the UK from Greece we found a property through Karl Tatler. It was quite a challenge but Emmie Hughes in the Lettings HQ has been an absolute star. So hard working, helpful and patient. Thank you Emmie for all your help!
I worked with Sarah on our recent purchase of a property through Karl Tatler - there were a few challenges along the way as the solicitors raised questions and Sarah was there every step of the way, liaising with the vendor and my self to ensure that extra level of communication that you need in a purchase sometimes - thank you :)
The best estate agents !
Very efficient, proactive. I have experience of other agents and KT are the best - from start to completion. Excellent knowledge, Very friendly and helpful staff always. Kerry at KT was excellent throughout. Totally recommend.
Brilliant service from Karl Tatler. We put a property on the market at just about the worst time in the middle of December. Karl Tatler did a great job of the pictures/description and then proceeded to proactively phone around 200 matching clients. Viewings were generated even just before Christmas! I dealt with the Moreton branch and Clemmie Robertson was my dedicated sales advisor, she was exceptional, she has a real positive 'zeal' about her. She kept me well informed by phone and email and we have just agreed an offer. Highly recommend.
Could not have had a better experience. A big thanks to Sarah Graham our sales progressor. She kept us up to date on how things were moving along. Buying a new home is stressful and thanks to Sarah she helped make things a lot more stress free.
Thank you Sarah ever so much.
L&K McC
We decided to sell our property with Karl Tatler (Little Sutton) in October this year, initially they came out and provided a valuation etc which was all fine. We decided to proceed and listed our property for sale with them, this is when issues began to arise.
The initial listing was really poor with poor photos, incorrect property information and spelling mistakes throughout the listing. We asked to retake some internal photos which they did within 3 days, during this appointment I pointed out listing errors which were corrected. When asked to retake external photos they advised me they're too busy but would be in contact in the week when they can take them, 10 days later I had to initiate contact and ask them again to come and retake the photos. We received a request to view a couple of days later, after getting the property ready to view no one turned up. I contacted Karl Tatler to chase the viewer and it transpired they had booked the viewing on the wrong day, this resulted in loss of interest and a potential sale with no explanation or apology offered and they dodged the question every time I asked for an explanation. After consulting another estate agent I was advised this would have massively affected interest in the sale of the property because most interest is generated within the first 14 days and would need completely relisting. This was mentioned to Karl Tatler who's solution was a premium right move listing which wouldn't make a difference to interest. Communication has been poor throughout with contact only initiated when I have contact them. We have now given them notice to remove the listing and my phone hasn't stopped ringing with calls from them since. Incompetence is ripe, avoid if you actually want to sell.
Very good experience with Karl Tatler for the last 9 years renting a property. All queries and issues dealt with efficiently and promptly. Thank you Calum for your help in looking for new premises over last weeks. Appreciated.
I have recently tried to sell a proper with Karl Tatler (Prenton)
And have years of experience selling my properties and never come across a company who live on there passed success as much as Karl Tatler.
They were the most expensive over 1k more than the nearest competitor.
I had seven viewing of which one was a no show however KT kept it on their figures as a viewing, They attended two of the viewing and were late to both.
The EPC cert I believed was covered in the price however they informed me it was an extra charge and they had put an extra £40 on the price. (Please beware you can sort your own EPC cert. On line for around £50. This is what I did.
The house took 9 months before falling through when asking them for updates or information we received little to none, being told constantly there was just one more form for the buyer to sign. I believe they have forgot who they work for.
Extremely disappointed and would put anyone I know off going through this experience.
Overall i was pleased with my experience. At the start i was given a realistic sales price which was achieved in good time. The staff were always friendly and efficient. My only reservation would be down to communication issues. Often i did not get replies to messages i had left. When i raised this with Sue ( manageress ) she assured me that i could always contact her directly. She was true to her word so a big plus and a thank you for that.
I sold my house with Karl Tatler. This was under the support, guidance, and overall positivity of Pippa at the Wallasey branch. She was open, honest, helpful and really great at guiding me through what is , at times, a difficult, stressful process.
I felt that she was always on my side and strove to achieve the best outcome for me and the sale of my property. Calls were always returned in a timely manner, questions answered with both honesty and integrity.
Both Pippa and Karl Tatler are highly recommended.
If you get Sarah Graham as your sales progressor you've struck gold.Buying a house in Wallasey was quite stressful due to delays on sellers side but Sarah was so helpful and proactive, kept us informed at every stage and gave useful advice.
Avoid these if you have a property to rent.the lady that deals with the lettings is basically a liar and will swear black is white.even when the facts are presented. We own a few buy to let properties and certainly wont be adding more with these guys.Theres way better letting agents than these charlatans.
Karl Tatler Estate Agents is a well-established property agency operating in the Wirral and Cheshire West regions since 1997. The company specializes in residential real estate services, including selling and letting properties. With a diverse portfolio that caters to both buyers and renters, Karl Tatler aims to provide comprehensive support throughout the property transaction process.
Targeting homeowners, prospective buyers, and tenants, the company offers property valuations, mortgage and insurance services, and expert advice on the local market. With a reputation for exceptional customer service, Karl Tatler Estate Agents is dedicated to helping clients navigate the complexities of real estate in their area. For those looking to buy, sell, or rent properties in Wirral, Karl Tatler serves as a trusted resource for reliable and professional assistance.