Skip to main content
HomeCity Real Estate logo

HomeCity Real Estate reviews & trust report

HomeCity Real Estate is a Texas-based real estate company specializing in assisting buyers and sellers in navigating the local property market. Established in 1981, the company has built a reputation for its comprehensive home search services, catering primarily to individuals and families looking to relocate or invest in residential properties across Texas. With a strong focus on the San Antonio area, HomeCity Real Estate employs experienced local agents who provide expert guidance throughout the buying and selling processes. The company offers an advanced searching system that allows users to explore available homes and access detailed neighborhood information. HomeCity Real Estate also provides free home valuations, helping sellers understand their property's worth in today's market. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, the company has garnered numerous positive reviews from clients, reflecting its dedication to delivering quality real estate services in Central and South Texas.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview71 customer reviews

HomeCity Real Estate has a positive customer experience.

HomeCity Real Estate receives high praise from customers, with many highlighting the exceptional service provided by their agents. Reviewers frequently mention the supportive and knowledgeable nature of agents like Sterling Mack, Alicia Caballero, and Karen Sally, who guide clients through the home buying process with care and expertise.

Read full summary

Many express satisfaction with the personal attention and responsiveness they received, making the experience smooth and enjoyable. However, a few negative reviews point to issues with specific agents, including complaints about unprofessional behavior and a lack of support during the closing process. Despite these criticisms, the overwhelming majority of feedback reflects a positive sentiment towards HomeCity's agents and their commitment to client satisfaction. Overall, HomeCity Real Estate is viewed favorably by most customers.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.7/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 93% happy · 7% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Website & app
  • Easy to use
71 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.7
100%
4.7 / 5 overall
71 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people.

Not enough history for a trend yet: 1 review in 1 month. The chart appears once reviews span two months.

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 71 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 66 positive reviews

  • Customer service32%
    21 mentions
  • Website & app23%
    15 mentions
  • Easy to use23%
    15 mentions
  • Helpful support21%
    14 mentions
“Experienced a level of comfort during the entire home sales experience knowing that Karen had everything under contro...”
On “Customer service” · Jun 23, 2014

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Home & Garden.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
HomeCity Real Estate logo
HomeCity Real Estate
4.7 out of 5 (good)71
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,809
4.7 out of 5 (good)1,004
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,000

Bottom line: HomeCity Real Estate is #3 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Home Store + More scores higher (4.9 vs 4.6).

Reviews

71 reviews of HomeCity Real Estate. Filter by what matters to you.

4.7ⓘ

Customer reviews (71)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Kirby Bennink

Never assume, ask questions or you too can be screwed out of $5K at closing...

We purchased our new house, closed on it, then sold our current house. We had a $5K surprise at closing. We originally came to an agreement price on our house and the buyer was good with it. Then the inspection found some issues so we gave them a $5K seller concession. Then later the appraisal came back even lower so we agreed on the appraised value. Now common sense tells you that the selling price was reduced to the new appraised value and that the concession was off the table. It wasn't so we got burned out of $5K at closing and the buyer ended up getting the house for $5K less than our lowered offer. A good realtor would have pointed this out to us but ours said nothing. By having it as a concession, she was able to get her commission on the $5K and we had to pay it at closing. Very shady business and I will never use this reality company again nor will I ever recommend them to any of my friends. We felt like we were totally taken advantage of. Our realtor never even put a sold sign up in front of our house nor did she ever show it once yet she got her commission.

Report
David Hurn & Paula Spring

Jody is truly a gem

We so totally lucked out. Finding a real estate agent while sitting in California and using the internet can be risky. Jody is wonderful; we couldn't have handpicked a better person. She is efficient, friendly, responsive, reliable, thorough, and so much more. If she didn't have the answer to something, you could be sure she would find out and get back to you. We could count on her to show us only what met our criteria, thereby, not wasting our time and hers. She understood exactly what we were looking for and helped me notice things about each property that I was missing on my own. I cannot begin to give enough praise for Jody. She does a great walkthrough. Besides all of the above, she is FUN!

Report
Rekha Nilkanth

Joni James of HomeCity Real Estate provided me with a stellar service in Austin, Tx.

Thank you HomeCity for introducing such a friendly & patient agent in Joni James to me! Right from the day, I received information from your office until close of escrow, Joni was always there for me. Remember this was a long distance communication from west coast to Texas, but I did not feel I was far away from the action. I was very happy with service provided to me.

Report
Patrica Cornelius

You Can Count On HomeCity

Michelle Yarnell was the best . She was on the job the first time we met. She always followed up on email, texts and phone calls. She gave great advise on everything. From mortgage lenders, worked with sellers, inspections. She made the whole buying process a feel like a piece of cake. I told her what I wanted and the time line was right on time. Hats off to Home City @ Michelle.

Report
Elane Stifflemire

Friendliness, Effiencent, Goes way beyond the ordinary

I found HomeCity Real Estate to be #1 in everything. they connected me with the best agent, Bruce Keith.

Report
Troy Matteson

Great Experience, awesome agent. A+++

We looked for land for over a year. Mike Murphy was so helpful and patient as we looked at many properties in many parts of central Texas. Overall it was a fantastic experience with great service and communication. We will use Mike and Homecity again!!!

Report
Cherie Mihnovets

Michelle Higgins is awesome, we have bought and sold homes with her!

Michelle makes buying or selling a stress free experience! She keeps you informed trough the whole process! We won't use anyone else ever!

Report
Hannah Halydier

Honest and Reliable

The people at HomeCity and our Realtor, Craig Scott, knew from the beginning that our experiences with Realtors had not been pleasant. That changed as soon as we got in touch with someone from HomeCity. Their website is incredibly helpful, and very user friendly. After putting in our offer, Craig was always on top of the process and communicated what he knew with us constantly, whether it was through email, text or a call. Every bump in the road we hit, he was on the phone with someone else and making sure we knew what was happening. We know that if we had tried to buy a house through any other Realtor or Realty Office, it would have been a more painful process. We can't say enough about how Craig took care of us during the process, and we will be recommending him to family and friends who plan on moving to the Austin area.

Report
Sherry Dorsey

Matt Wittee was essential to finding the right house!

We had lots of trials getting just the right house. My realtor Matt Wittee stuck with me through all kinds of trials. He was great when I had questions. He could answer finance to house construction questions. He always got back to me immediately. Sad I won't be talking to him so often.

Report
Woody Hill
Woody Hill
1 review

Great Service!

It was a pleasure to work with Jannie Maldenado at HomeCity. She is a true professional and a pleasure to be around. I highly recommend her if you are looking for an honest and hard-working real estate agent!

Report
Rodolfo Gutierrez

Amazing people you can trust

I never used a Realtor before but now I feel Kim Luttrull as part of my family. She was always with our family no matter was at 7 am or late at night. Always fighting for us with a level of expertise that made us feel secure in every step. Always with smile in her face but strong at the time of dealing with the builder. If I buy another house in the future I will choose Homecity and specially Kim as my realtor.

Report
Jimmy Garza
Jimmy Garza
1 review

Real Estate agent did not provide a good experience.

My real estate agent was very nice and professional, but made my first time buying experience not very good. My home was over a month and a half behind schedule and I had to schedule all my own walk throughs and closings. My agent was aware of all the difficulties and frustrations that I was encountering, but did not receive any sort of commentary, feedback, or guidance until I prompted them. He was over 15 minutes late to my final closing. I inquired with friends, family, and other colleagues if they had similar experience with their real estate agent and an overwhelming response was 'no'. Their real estate agent experiences were very positive as they had and advocate acting as an extension of themselves representing them in the home buying/building process.

Report
Philip Mogavero

Joe at Homecity Rocks!

We made our purchase in Austin using Homecity, beginning with a long distance on-line search from California. We were matched with Joe Longton who took the time to line up several properties for us to review when we came to town. Joe was extremely attentive and a joy to work with. When we found a home with a view we loved, but not the interior, he fought hard to get us a great deal that allowed us to make the change to make the whole family happy. Joe stayed with us every step of the way to insure that we were satisfied. We would strongly recommend Joe Longton and Homecity!

Report
Gary P Gunter Jr.

HomeCity exceeded my expectations.

I was blown away by the traffic and interest generated from the sale of our home. Though skeptical at first, in the end I was very pleased with my experience having HomeCity take care of my family's realty needs.

Report
Rich Antoine
Rich Antoine
1 review

Mike Murphy does it again!!!!

I can't say enough about Mike Murphy. His service and attention to his clients is impeccable. We have had 4 transactions with him in the last 2 years. There is a reason we will come back to Home City, it's Mike Murphy!

Report
D. Lorelei Burkhalter

Not the best experience

I trusted my agent as a friend, but she lied to me on several occasions, even with agents who where interested in putting an offer in on my home. She recommended a title company, and I would receive a discout, but that didnt happen. I even found my home which I purchased and she cashed in on the commission. After closing, she dropped me like a hot cake! I would not recommend Marie.

Report
Andrew Perez
Andrew Perez
1 review

Best team and great agent communication.

My agent Robert W, was the best. He made the whole house hunting process a piece of cake. Constantly communicated via email, text and phone. Always quick to respond to my questions. As a first time homebuyer I was amazed by how easy the whole process was. Thanks!

Report
Emily Swanzy
Emily Swanzy
1 review

Cilia was beyond awesome! Best home buying experience yet!

She really got me and what and what I wanted. I would recommend her to everyone!

Report
Sandra Hall
Sandra Hall
1 review

evaluations don't require a catch statement, just a good report

HomeCity Real Estate was most helpful in responding to my needs and was able to connect me with a reliable and efficient realtor who cared about what I was looking for in a home and helped me find the right place at the right price. In addition, the realtor negotiated on our behalf with a difficult seller, solved all concerns with the mortgage provider and got the sale closed in a very short time frame. What's not to like? Thank you for great job!

Report

Alternatives to HomeCity Real Estate

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.